The amount of comments is almost reaching the same amount of comments in Citrus, and considering that this manga doesn't explicitly show a yuri scene/pairing(although it's pretty obvious it's going that way/or not) compared to Citrus... I think it's just awesome :)

The difference between citrus and this is that half of the comments citrus has acquired are from people who hate it (including myself) whereas this is 100% agreed love that has gotten this manga so many comments.

Considering that a sizeable amont of comments here are about how much Shou is baiting us, I wouldn't say that there's pure love in this thread.

If this thread gets more comments then Stretch will be animated instead of Citrus!

If this thread gets more comments then Stretch will be animated instead of Citrus!

Can't we have both?

Considering that a sizeable amont of comments here are about how much Shou is baiting us, I wouldn't say that there's pure love in this thread.

Don't forget about the considerable number of discussions we had about their backstories as well. That soaked up lots of pages.

Considering that a sizeable amont of comments here are about how much Shou is baiting us, I wouldn't say that there's pure love in this thread.

Oh, we're all just masochists apparently.
So there's a lot of unpure love here instead.

If this thread gets more comments then Stretch will be animated instead of Citrus!

Can't we have both?

No

Considering that a sizeable amont of comments here are about how much Shou is baiting us, I wouldn't say that there's pure love in this thread.

Oh, we're all just masochists apparently.
So there's a lot of unpure love here instead.

Basically this.

It's not what I would have done.

Seriously, Citrus is getting worse and worse. Art and plot. Does it have plot to begin with? I dont know...Cant catch up with the story anymore.
Stretch, in the other hand, get better and better. It's a manga that you think nonsense but has so many details in it, even there's yuri or not.

Seriously, Citrus is getting worse and worse. Art and plot. Does it have plot to begin with? I dont know...Cant catch up with the story anymore.
Stretch, in the other hand, get better and better. It's a manga that you think nonsense but has so many details in it, even there's yuri or not.

It had a plot during the Mei's father arc. I'm guessing at that point Sabo saw how popular it was and thought, 'Well, I WAS going to end it here, but now..?'.

Pretty obvious they're just milking it at this point. Which is a shame, this would be a great if it had ended there. Sadly it jumped from that to a forced love triangle... to another forced love triangle... and now it's about to be a forced love square.

The fact that it was a pseudo-incest love story has completely taken a back seat. I thought that was the premise of the whole manga?!

last edited at Dec 2, 2014 1:53PM

Seriously, Citrus is getting worse and worse. Art and plot. Does it have plot to begin with? I dont know...Cant catch up with the story anymore.
Stretch, in the other hand, get better and better. It's a manga that you think nonsense but has so many details in it, even there's yuri or not.

It had a plot during the Mei's father arc. I'm guessing at that point Sabo saw how popular it was and thought, 'Well, I WAS going to end it here, but now..?'.

Pretty obvious they're just milking it at this point. Which is a shame, this would be a great if it had ended there. Sadly it jumped from that to a forced love triangle... to another forced love triangle... and now it's about to be a forced love square.

The fact that it was a pseudo-incest love story has completely taken a back seat. I thought that was the premise of the whole manga?!

Yeah, you're damn right! Now I remember that Citrus was about two sisters...
Wow, Triangle to square already? Well, when will we have a...idk, may be a forced love circle. Citrus wasnt bad at first, I liked it but now ...no.

Pretty obvious they're just milking it at this point. Which is a shame, this would be a great if it had ended there. Sadly it jumped from that to a forced love triangle... to another forced love triangle... and now it's about to be a forced love square.

The fact that it was a pseudo-incest love story has completely taken a back seat. I thought that was the premise of the whole manga?!

I checked it out around the time the first love triangle started.......really hated it. i cant imagine the horrors of a love square. (i semi-checked it out from time to time to see if it ever got decent again.......nope)

I'm sure Citrus will eventually reach a love shape so complex the entire universe will implode.

Just realized we're staining Stretch's discussion thread with talk about Shitrus. :(

last edited at Dec 2, 2014 2:23PM

Well they are the two most popular series on Dynasty right now so it's understandable that they are compared. Much like how Naruto, One Piece, and Bleach wer...are constantly compared against one another. It's inevitable. One thing about Citrus is that it started off literally just like any other het romance story. Boy force kisses girl and girl falls for him like some weak-kneed individual despite having a clearly strong individual no BS personality before said kiss. Citrus started turning around with the father arc in my opinion but then it had that ridiculous childhood friend pseudo love triangle arc. It went backwards. Stretch on the other hand, has far superior story telling and characters mixing with elements of drama, humor, stretching, and teasing while managing to keep most things a mystery to the readers.

I think Citrus' problem is is that we rarely get long running yuri series here with good artwork and Citrus has/had a lot of potential. Thus it gets a lot of attention despite not being a very well written story (my opinion).

They're equally good, the difference is that once is focused on adults and the other on teenagers. With that in mind, the characterization of everyone makes perfect sense and is easy to create attachement to the characters.

You will convince me citrus's characterization is even halfway decent when the plains of coldharbour become a place of whimsy and fun.

You're being way too harsh. They're high school girls and having dramas about everything is just like they are.

And hell, Keiko wasn't that different to Mei on High school.

You're being way too harsh. They're high school girls and having dramas about everything is just like they are.

And hell, Keiko wasn't that different to Mei on High school.

It's not about who the characters are, its the writing itself... it is terrible specially when looking at the sources of drama and how everything develops, character's actions and behaviors are nonsensical and feed into the terrible drama. It is a bad soap opera.

Comparing Citrus and Stretch, even if not exactly of the same genre, it is pretty obvious that Stretch is far superior in writing quality.

When was the last time you were in high school? Citrus started out mediocre, got good for one arc then turned pure dogshit as it continued way past the point it should have.
You are never going to convince me anything individual elements in that series were any good.

Also what flips said.

last edited at Dec 2, 2014 4:46PM

So we don't keep derailing this thread, I posted my answers on the Citrus thread.

So we don't keep derailing this thread, I posted my answers on the Citrus thread.

I only made statements, not interested in discussing, would be pointless.

When Stretch penetrates the Yuri threshold entirely, it'll be a glorious day.

Prism is about a teenage love story too, and it still has a extremely story telling.This is about the mangaka, not everybody is a good story teller.
Let's stretching, nobody cares about 2 girls citrus-ing each other.

Let's stretching, nobody cares about 2 girls citrus-ing each other.

That sounds painful.