Forum › "Madoka" discussion

Cate
joined May 15, 2015

;-;

Tag%20rock%20snake
joined Aug 16, 2014

Daily Reminder that Homura did Nothing Wrong

Capture
joined Dec 12, 2016

If making everyone happy is wrong then I don't want to be right.

Adeptus%20machanicus
joined Mar 7, 2014

Daily Reminder that Homura did Nothing Wrong

Every single time. Unironically.
H O M U R A D I D N O T H I N G W R O N G !

Super High School Level Artist
6b78b4b6e167268ccc1cfdc9df05de3f33b6b4a9_hq
joined Dec 28, 2016

Homura did everything wrong.

Except for what she did to Keyubey. That was right.

Best Mangaka Rohan
25dfc3e30a88f17394a8d2037430b766
joined Dec 13, 2016

Why the most famous yuri game has to be a tragic one?! ;_;

Screen%20shot%202022-12-24%20at%201.57.08%20am
joined Jun 11, 2016

Why the most famous yuri game has to be a tragic one?! ;_;

Yuri Game? Don't you mean anime?

last edited at Apr 2, 2017 9:23PM

Alice Cheshire Moderator
Dynasty_misc015
joined Nov 7, 2014

Super High School Level Artist posted:

Homura did everything wrong.

Except for what she did to Keyubey. That was right.

You misspelled "literally nothing wrong". Especially what she did to Kyuubey.

AquarianDemocrat
Retry
joined Jan 23, 2012

Homura = justice.

Capture
joined Dec 12, 2016

Why the most famous yuri game has to be a tragic one?! ;_;

Yuri Game? Don't you mean anime?

It did have a pretty well received game come out on the PSP.

And once again, a scene like this would only be possible thanks to our lord and savior, Homura.

last edited at Apr 2, 2017 11:12PM

Sakamoto%20nichijou%20tissues-min
joined Jan 20, 2016

Why the most famous yuri game has to be a tragic one?! ;_;

Yuri Game? Don't you mean anime?

It did have a pretty well received game come out on the PSP.

And once again, a scene like this would only be possible thanks to our lord and savior, Homura.

^^ I think you misspelled the name of our lord and savior, Madoka and her partner Homura. :)

Reimu-pet-cirno
joined May 17, 2013

You misspelled "literally nothing wrong". Especially what she did to Kyuubey.

Exactly. Aside from dragging her girlfriend down from heaven to essentially keep her in a cellar so she'd have to live like Homura wanted instead of how she chose, Homura Did Nothing Wrong.

Alice Cheshire Moderator
Dynasty_misc015
joined Nov 7, 2014

Polycell posted:

Exactly. Aside from dragging her girlfriend down from heaven to essentially keep her in a cellar so she'd have to live like Homura wanted instead of how she chose, Homura Did Nothing Wrong.

That's kinda overlooking the important detail of how Homura did that to protect her from something Homura knew to be a danger and which Madoka didn't seem to be paying any mind at all. Your reasoning is 110% off.

Reimu-pet-cirno
joined May 17, 2013

Wasn't she the one that told Kyubey about Madokami(and the witch system) in the first place? She's not blameless, no matter how hard you try.

Alice Cheshire Moderator
Dynasty_misc015
joined Nov 7, 2014

Polycell posted:

Wasn't she the one that told Kyubey about Madokami(and the witch system) in the first place? She's not blameless, no matter how hard you try.

Yeah, because she wasn't even sure it had really happened. You DO realize that Homura's mental state degraded pretty severely over the course of her time loops, right? By the end of the series she was questioning her own sanity quite severely. Hence why Rebellion even happened to begin with. She's far more blameless than you're attempting to paint her as.

joined Apr 21, 2014

Polycell posted:

Wasn't she the one that told Kyubey about Madokami(and the witch system) in the first place? She's not blameless, no matter how hard you try.

Yeah, because she wasn't even sure it had really happened. You DO realize that Homura's mental state degraded pretty severely over the course of her time loops, right? By the end of the series she was questioning her own sanity quite severely. Hence why Rebellion even happened to begin with. She's far more blameless than you're attempting to paint her as.

Yeah, and in any case no one suspected that Kyubey would have the ability to recapture Madoka. She had no reason to hide it.

joined Jun 28, 2017

Glad to see there are still fans who's mental stability hasn't completely degraded yet.
Five things wrong with the second movie:

Madoka dumped the person that loved her most in a world where she never existed and had her suffer from that.
Madoka left the Incubators free to fuck everything up as much as they liked.
Madoka created the universe she wanted without considering what anybody else wanted.
Children shouldn't be responsible for the universe.
She didn't erase all of the sufferings of trying to save Madoka hundreds of times from Homaru's mind, which she could have easily done.

Basically, Homaru could be forgiven for thinking Madoka didn't give a fuck about her after all she had done for her.
Homaru saved the universe and made everyone happy who wasn't an Incubator.

To reply you must either login or sign up.