Forum › Howling Song for Husky Girl discussion

joined Aug 3, 2025

Page 2: so the doctor's just going to violate patient privacy and blab everything, huh?

Page 3: whoa whoa is the doctor conniving a bunch of MINORS into pressuring their MOM about a life-changing, career-ending surgery?? So he doesn't have to do his own **** job??

Rest of the chapter: . . . I read it. Still don't get it. This chapter makes less sense the more I think about it lmao. Also, the mom looks like the same age as her kids. . . which is very disorienting.

Leaping%20cow
joined Sep 27, 2017

Feels like she gave her daughter abandonment issues for basically no reason...and if the cancer did kill her when she was gone they would have never met again. Genuinely baffling parenting here lol

joined Aug 3, 2025

It really does read strangely.
If the mom had said:
"My life was falling apart. I could barely take care of myself, let alone two children." - sad, but understandable
"Your dad/family member wouldn't let me take you both." - makes sense, sounds plausible.
"I couldn't offer you a stable home, and I was afraid of dying in front of you. So I had to pick one child, the one who was a better singer" - makes. . . Okay no that still doesn't make sense and would be super messed up LOL

The mom straight up telling her daughter: "You were less talented. I didn't want you to make you anxious because of your lack of talent. So I picked your sister, and left you."
is just CRAZY!

Capturar
joined Jun 27, 2018

As a physician and a certified stick-in-the-mud, I need to say:

That doctor is a quack.

Radiotherapy would have fucked up her voice too.

And surgery is never curative for metastatic throat cancer. She needs chemo and maybe immunotherapy.

Leaping%20cow
joined Sep 27, 2017

It really does read strangely.
If the mom had said:
"My life was falling apart. I could barely take care of myself, let alone two children." - sad, but understandable
"Your dad/family member wouldn't let me take you both." - makes sense, sounds plausible.
"I couldn't offer you a stable home, and I was afraid of dying in front of you. So I had to pick one child, the one who was a better singer" - makes. . . Okay no that still doesn't make sense and would be super messed up LOL

The mom straight up telling her daughter: "You were less talented. I didn't want you to make you anxious because of your lack of talent. So I picked your sister, and left you."
is just CRAZY!

Yeah it feels like there's a lot of reasons that would have at least made more sense lol

joined Jun 11, 2021

the whole mom situation kinda nosedived this manga wtf lmao. it also bothers me that the author cant draw her to look like anything other than a fellow high school girl, like she looks exactly like her daughters

joined Jun 11, 2021

clearly this kind of drama is not the author's strong suit. let's get back to the lesbian fluff please

To reply you must either login or sign up.