The comparison stands in that Otome games are usually about a female protagonist going for a male character in a romance route.
Yes, and they state outright what possible romance options you'll be able to pursue. There are also generally warnings for any kind of unusual content (although Japan being Japan, H-scenes in nukige can have dubious consent here and there because "true love" and all that).
A yuri route in those is just as "out of place" as a het route in a yuri game because it's not the intented point of the game.
I'm not talking about it being out of place or not. That's beside the point. I'm talking about the game being marketed as having a certain kind of content, so players rightfully expected only that content everywhere. Even in optional routes.
I personnally have no interest in that game, mostly because the protagonist doesn't appeal to me in the slightest, but I have no issue with the content itself for those who'll enjoy it.
As I said, fetish fuel is fine when it realizes that it's fetish fuel and doesn't try to pretend to be anything else. If the game was advertised as "mostly yuri but has a het scene or two because why the hell not, amirite?", people wouldn't have been surprised and annoyed by those scenes. Just like nobody is seriously pissed at games like Euphoria for having fucked up content, because people were warned about said content before they bought the game. And no, I'm not drawing parallels between Euphoria and Ladykiller, it was just the first "controversial" VN that I could remember.
Those VN stays VN no matter which route you go.
Yet the content changes.
If you don't like the FPS/RTS comparison, here's a different one. A game (not this one, just some game) was marketed as a slice of life fluff. There was no mention of anything but SoL while it was in development. However, after the release somebody found out that by choosing a certain route your protagonist turns from a regular bland adult into the Chosen One who bears the fate of the world on their shoulders and has to fulfil the ancient prophecy to save the world from two clans that... where was I again? Ah yes, a sudden shift in tone. Or a change in content that wasn't clearly shown in previews and demos.
False advertising is the problem, not the content itself.
last edited at Oct 12, 2016 5:00AM