Forum › Posts by SpencerSDH

Naqpcjy
joined Nov 15, 2017

Chapter needs tomboy tag.

Naqpcjy
joined Nov 15, 2017

So glad this is here. Saw it on Sadpanda a few days ago.

SpencerSDH
VAMPEERZ discussion 26 Sep 18:35
Naqpcjy
joined Nov 15, 2017

Author/artist is very good at drawing kissing scenes.

it may be because the artist also draws hentai

That's not enough for kisses this good. You'd have to study lips real closely to get this kind of detail.

On another note, I love how horny these two are. They seriously can't get within a foot of each other without making out.

last edited at Sep 26, 2020 6:38PM

SpencerSDH
Naqpcjy
joined Nov 15, 2017

This book contains some extremely out of character moments and some characters are treated quite unfairly

Well, this is the Madoka fandom, after all, and I wouldn't have it any other way.

last edited at Sep 24, 2020 9:08PM

Naqpcjy
joined Nov 15, 2017

The dream you can't leave until you make out.

SpencerSDH
Image Comments 21 Sep 21:17
Naqpcjy
joined Nov 15, 2017
79257459_p0

Those are very tiny hands.

SpencerSDH
Image Comments 12 Sep 22:31
Naqpcjy
joined Nov 15, 2017
83830275_p2

@elevown Aerith's fingers are bent, which is why they look so short. Just as well, thin fingers in general are a stylistic choice. As an artist you should know better than to generalize an entire artists body of work based on one image. Your comment comes off a condescending, and the fact that you are so confident in your assumptions shows you either paid no attention, or didn't care.

SpencerSDH
Image Comments 07 Sep 23:20
Naqpcjy
joined Nov 15, 2017
Egxdyr1vaacuifr-orig

Yeah, but we all know this is gonna end with NTR.

SpencerSDH
Yuru Yuri discussion 04 Sep 21:55
Naqpcjy
joined Nov 15, 2017

Seeing Kyouko having clothes painted on her reminded me of that hentai doujin where all the girls painted clothes on each other.

Which one might that be?

https://dynasty-scans.com/chapters/nuru_yuri_1

SpencerSDH
Naqpcjy
joined Nov 15, 2017

While I'm not against prostitution per se, pretending it should be considered a normal job is naive at best, disingenuous at worst. You're denying the suffering of millions of people around the world.

Just answer about this sincerely: would you want your sister or your mother work that kind of job? Just think about it carefully. If you answer yes, you're a liar.

And blah blah blah, "sexuality and romanticism aren't synonyms"... everyone here knows that. It's not as if anyone is denying that there can be sex without love and love without sex. It's an obvious strawman.

It's just that usually (not always), one leads to the other, not necessarily in that order. Pretending they are unrelated because there are some exceptions is dishonest.

No, prostitution is not a "normal job", because it involves a lot of psychological and physical factors that touch intimacy, social image and self-representation. I don't doubt there are well adjusted prostitutes, but I think they are the minority among the millions of exploited others.

Yes, any adult can choose to sell sexual services if they want to (emphasis on "they want to").

And no, this manga is just a fantasy and probably doesn't depict any reality about lesbian prostitution and it leaves the questions about that occupation unanswered, because it's not the focus of the story.

Part of the reason sex work is so unsafe in most of the world is because is because of it's illegality. When you decriminalize and regulate, as with any illegal industry e.g. marijuana, the criminal elements can be weeded out and it can be made as safe as any other industry. It's fine if you don't like it, but let's not pretend that this isn't just your personal preferences. Also, lets not ignore the tens of millions of people all over the world who are so uneducated about how to find a partner that prostitution is pretty much the only sexual intimacy they will receive in their entire lives. This is one of the biggest reasons that the sex industry will never go away. The vast majority of human beings, like all animals, need some kind of sexual relief that isn't just a hand.

SpencerSDH
Image Comments 31 Aug 21:27
Naqpcjy
joined Nov 15, 2017
Ef-0y_quyaeenlh-orig

Boob Into You

Naqpcjy
joined Nov 15, 2017

Remember when this series had a subtext tag on it?

SpencerSDH
Image Comments 28 Aug 22:16
Naqpcjy
joined Nov 15, 2017
83700503_p0

I don't see any yuri here. Why, she's just using her quirk to levitate some undergarments!

SpencerSDH
Naqpcjy
joined Nov 15, 2017

YES DEAR GOD CHECK HER PULSE!!!

Naqpcjy
joined Nov 15, 2017

Some days, lovers, and other days, best friends? Correct me if I'm wrong, but that seems like a pretty normal relationship right? They're basically married at this point.

last edited at Aug 23, 2020 8:19PM

Naqpcjy
joined Nov 15, 2017

What an incredibly unique take on the societal changes occurring due to the Covid pandemic. Props to Neji for such an interesting idea.

last edited at Aug 22, 2020 11:27PM

Naqpcjy
joined Nov 15, 2017

This is such a crack ship that I can't even get into this. Like, I have no objections to the content, but my god the crack on display here is insane.

SpencerSDH
Naqpcjy
joined Nov 15, 2017

okay why is this story lowkey funny... the way that she retired bc she couldn’t top another girl anymore got me cackling

Seriously, holy shit the top energy is too strong.

SpencerSDH
Naqpcjy
joined Nov 15, 2017

Nothing like some good wholesome roleplay. Not enough of it in doujins.

SpencerSDH
VAMPEERZ discussion 21 Aug 10:06
Naqpcjy
joined Nov 15, 2017

25 pages, all to set up a fart joke. Never change Shou.

Naqpcjy
joined Nov 15, 2017

It helps that I also like tomboys, and they are really just two sides of the same coin.

Except tomboys don't bind, or use the men's room, or play on guys sports teams (for the most part) like a "femboy" would do makeup, tuck, join some all girls thing secretly, or wear much more rigidly gender-policed clothing. It's rare for their identity to be "revealed" as a gag or a trick (handsome girl was like drama associated with being misgendered and coming to grips with your sexuality, some comedy came in how her anxieties were unfounded because her gf was so madly in love.) Outside the very small yuri bubble tomboys are always portrayed as ultimately straight whereas the femboys always flirt sexually with male characters. Tomgirls in like nisekoi, Tomo-chan, and I'm sure plenty of harems vs the scads of femboys that lust after MC.

Maybe I should be more clear. I like feminine dudes and masculine ladies and several varieties of each. I don't need to justify my personal preferences to anyone, especially not some rando on the internet.

I'm going to say one last thing at that will be the end of my input on this discussion. This is a comedy. There is no drama tag, and I don't expect to see one during this manga's run on the site. If you want accurate representation of the trans experience, don't look here, you won't find it.

Naqpcjy
joined Nov 15, 2017

When the author doesnt believe trans people are real, then to the author all trans people are simply "cross dressers".

Let's step back a bit from assuming anything about the authors beliefs shall we?

The thing is, these characters tend to "cross dress" all the time, which falls out of the realm of what someone cis would do.

This is a fictional story. Artistic liberties and all that.

Like why is his despair of potentially being gay a funny situation?

Ok, I'll take a crack at this. In a perfect world, worrying about your sexuality is utterly pointless, because nobody would judge you for it. One of the great things about fiction is that you can create a perfect/near perfect world, and use it to explore ideas that you like, without having to drag real world social issues into it. This is especially important being that this is a comedy and, nothing ruins a light-hearted tone like reminding the reader that the world is a shithole full of horrible people.

That being said, this is a world where the norm is that guys have no problem crossdressing at all. With that in mind, it is comical for the MC to be worried about being seen as gay, when nobody else gives a shit. Juxtaposition is one of the foundations of comedy, and in order to turn something serious into something funny, you have to juxtapose it with something that brings out the absurdity in it. That is what's happening here.

MC is worried about being seen as being gay. That's sad. How do we make it funny? We make it take place in a world where guys wear dresses without giving a shit about how it makes them look. Now the MCs worries are completely unfounded, and we can instead highlight the comical nature of the whole situation.

Naqpcjy
joined Nov 15, 2017

Yeah uh, yikes, playing crossdressing for comedy almost always ends up transphobic and homophobic. closeted me ate this kinda shit up, now I just cringe/get frustrated. If a character presents, thinks, acts in a particular, single gendered deal different from their assigned sex except for when they go "haha i'm boye/gurl gottem xDDDDD" or to assert a rigid gender binary every so often, it is really hard not to read that as anything but a trans character written by a transphobe to say that, despite everything someone may do, they can't change their gender.

Yep, because all crossdressers are either gay, or trans.

Also, why do people think that the crossdressing is being played for laughs here? I mean, I think the idea of crossdressing becoming a popular fad is pretty funny. It would be like if wooden clogs became a popular fad. That being said, the comedic drive of this series is clearly not the crossdressing itself. It's that the MC is confused because a dude is giving him a boner. I find this pretty relatable as someone who used to hate feminine guys, but now I think they're adorable. It helps that I also like tomboys, and they are really just two sides of the same coin.

SpencerSDH
Naqpcjy
joined Nov 15, 2017

This trope is beyond fucking boring, if your love falls apart because you go to different colleges then it really was nothing more than a high school flick

Maintaining a long distance relationship is difficult and scary, and for many people, it is impossible. Love isn't magic, and true love that can survive anything you throw at it doesn't exist.

Yes I am a cynical bastard, but it's true.

last edited at Aug 19, 2020 11:09PM

SpencerSDH
Naqpcjy
joined Nov 15, 2017

Can we get an Incest and Caliber gap tag on this please?