well, i just finished what has been scanlated of asper girl.
i almost stopped really early on because some of it was too much for me, but overall i'm glad i stuck with it.
i have plenty of criticism about both specific details and the general theme, but there was a lot that felt genuine and that i related to in one way or another. the depiction of ptsd is particularly powerful (and painful).
i definitely prefer ah... and mm... because i feel like it's more subtle — the autism spectrum is broad, but at times it felt like saitou (from asper girl) was more of a caricature than a true representation of someone on the spectum.
that said i will continue to follow along with the scanlation releases and would recommend it to people who are brave of heart, and not triggered by self harm, suicide, abuse, animal abuse, rape, among other things...
it's definitely not a fun read, but there is probably something there for you if you are interested in this type of content and can handle how intense it is.
Damn you're fast. I've only managed to get 12 chapters down since last night, but so far it's been a fantastic experience to me. I've worked with a few clients with ASDs before and during my time studying psychology in university (no, I did not finish with a degree, sadly) and I agree that Saitou does at times feel a bit cliché, but then again: so did the 16 year old Asperger's kid I worked with for ten months, even if he was completely different from Saitou or the other ASD-cases I met afterwards. An important takeaway from those experiences for me, however, was to not discount an ASD-case because it was either too typical or untypical, because as you say: it's a broad spectrum.
Ah.. and Mm... seems more subtle indeed, but my attention's been captured by Asper Girl for now, which takes up most of the time I'm not working today. Maybe I'll get around to reading more of it tomorrow.