Forum › Posts by NxY

NxY
Untitled-1
joined Oct 28, 2018

@strayalive
Oof!

Well, that's what I get for trying to reach out and find common ground with a shipper.

This is not an obstacle that needs to be crushed, it's one that simply happens to be there as a stepping stone towards the end goal. Sad for Sayaka, but just narratively sound.

Except it's not because as I've already said rejecting the confession will probably be the end of Touko and Sayaka's friendship. And you guys are either oblivious to the fact that there essentially has to be some fallout from Sayaka's confession (because she's not a fucking villain) or want that impact handwaved. I don't get it.

Where does anybody say that there won't be fallout from Sayaka's confession?

NxY
Untitled-1
joined Oct 28, 2018

Nakatani: Touko was created first, Yuu was born as her partner. I like troublesome girls. For me, I wanted to draw a girl that would be unmanageable, so I made Touko the heroine. For me, Yuu has the image of a hero who would help that unmanageable girl. That being said, I think of the characters as if they were born as individual people. It is at most a discussion of “At first it was like that.”

– So it’s a matter of those two moving towards to resolving the problem as a goal. While you draw those delicate feelings, I feel like you thought through the story with reasoning as you talk about the story.

Nakatani: Yes. However, there are times where I would have the characters take action in accordance to the story, “I can’t let them say this line,” “I can’t let them do this much yet.” I draw while keeping in mind the balance between what I want to to do with it as a story, and what the characters would do in the present situation. As I lay down the rails, occasionally with a detour, I put thought into it as I reason out on “How should I go about to bring it here?…..” Something like that.

I drew with the thoughts of wanting Yuu and Touko to be happy, so right now may be the painful part, I would be happy if you would continue to follow.

NxY
NxY
Untitled-1
joined Oct 28, 2018

Just some things I noticed re-reading chapter 37 On page '68', there's a background character that says his fortune told him to give up on his crush, so that could be a subtle parallel to Sayaka. Sayaka says she won't draw a fortune in case she gets bad luck for her confession but, Touko also doesn't get a fortune. I just really liked the black panels and want to see what Troyca would do with them. When Sayaka metaphorically reaches out to Touko's hidden self, it's a parallel to how the visual metaphor in chapter 11 describes Sayaka allowing Touko to keep up appearances. I feel that Sayaka's entire confession build up is a nice parallel to Yuu's. From consulting with someone with more experience beforehand, the anticipation immediately before and running away after.

last edited at Jan 1, 2019 6:59AM

NxY
Untitled-1
joined Oct 28, 2018
NxY
Untitled-1
joined Oct 28, 2018

They're ending on chapter 24 (Episode 13 "To the Terminal Station / Lighthouse")
http://yagakimi.com/story/

Which is an incredibly unsatisfying place to leave it. If they can't line up a second season, this is going to be disappointing for a lot of viewers.

It's better than them rushing to the play and mess up the pacing IMO. I'd rather have a disappointing ending but, a good adaptation than a bad adaptation with a conclusive ending.

NxY
Untitled-1
joined Oct 28, 2018

They're ending on chapter 24 (Episode 13 "To the Terminal Station / Lighthouse")
http://yagakimi.com/story/

NxY
Untitled-1
joined Oct 28, 2018

I'm not sure, I would like to see the play in ep13, for that, they might skip the OP and ending to fill everything (like preparations for the play and the after match) and that's 6 volumes (I think the anime will end exactly in chapter 32 "Off the Stage" ) so that leaves us with a little bit of vol 6 and extras, vol 7 and then whatever vol 8 has to offer... That's less than half of what they needed to adapt the first season.

That seems extremely unlikely. If they wanted to include the play they would have increased the pace of adaption.

Plus I don't think anybody on the team wants to rush it.

NxY
Untitled-1
joined Oct 28, 2018

NxY posted:

NxY posted:

YagaKimi was in 16th place for blu ray sales last week with 2,849 sales https://www.animenewsnetwork.com/news/2018-12-25/japan-animation-blu-ray-disc-ranking-december-17-23/.141303

This is so sad... So if you want to success in sells you have to make it about idols, but what's the problem with idols? they can't fall in love(for real) so no yuri.
But really, I was expecting around 4000 to 6000

Well, it is only one week. And each blu ray is $80, so that's already $227,920.

Yeah now that I think about 3000 to 4000 is still pretty good in average.

I don't think we'll get a second season... Maybe just OVA to complete the story, because I don't think the manga can pull off enough material for 12 more episodes

Well, it's likely to end at volume 8, leaving 4 volumes to adapt. That's easily enough for 12 episodes.

NxY
Untitled-1
joined Oct 28, 2018

Bluray already? So no ep. 13? Or was the sales number just preorders?

It's a shame if it doesn't get a second season, it's been so intelligent and understated.

They separate the season into 4 blu ray 'volumes'. This is just episodes 1-3, I think. Episode 13 is still coming out.

NxY
Untitled-1
joined Oct 28, 2018

NxY posted:

YagaKimi was in 16th place for blu ray sales last week with 2,849 sales https://www.animenewsnetwork.com/news/2018-12-25/japan-animation-blu-ray-disc-ranking-december-17-23/.141303

This is so sad... So if you want to success in sells you have to make it about idols, but what's the problem with idols? they can't fall in love(for real) so no yuri.
But really, I was expecting around 4000 to 6000

Well, it is only one week. And each blu ray is $80, so that's already $227,920.

NxY
Untitled-1
joined Oct 28, 2018

YagaKimi was in 16th place for blu ray sales last week with 2,849 sales https://www.animenewsnetwork.com/news/2018-12-25/japan-animation-blu-ray-disc-ranking-december-17-23/.141303

NxY
Untitled-1
joined Oct 28, 2018

'Slightly' late but, Merry Christmas everyone.

https://i.redd.it/7pv85ij3wl621.png

NxY
Untitled-1
joined Oct 28, 2018
NxY
Untitled-1
joined Oct 28, 2018

Just saw this on Reddit, thought you guys would like it https://giphy.com/gifs/yagate-kimi-ni-naru-touko-nanami-yuu-koito-fCTqvXw13ANWQCgZKD

NxY
Untitled-1
joined Oct 28, 2018

Just watched the 12th episode and, as usual, it's amazing

NxY
Untitled-1
joined Oct 28, 2018

I think the Dynasty should fix the sequence of extras and special in Volumes. Special 6 that had put in volume 6 which is Miyako x Riko story should be in volume 7 as special chapter. And they still haven’t upload yet the real extra chapter for volume 6. I think it was out days ago from 4s...

Where's that? (Volume 6 extra)

It’s this one in 4s mediafire link:
https://download2268.mediafire.com/ls315fgodhmg/e714a4zi24caz9c/%5B4s%5D+Yagate+Kimi+ni+Naru+-+Volume+6+Extras.zip

And already posted in Mangadex:
https://mangadex.org/chapter/500351/1

Thanks

I've never actually read Nakatani's comments before for some reason but, they're actually really cute. I'll have to read the rest.

last edited at Dec 20, 2018 5:37AM

NxY
Untitled-1
joined Oct 28, 2018

I think the Dynasty should fix the sequence of extras and special in Volumes. Special 6 that had put in volume 6 which is Miyako x Riko story should be in volume 7 as special chapter. And they still haven’t upload yet the real extra chapter for volume 6. I think it was out days ago from 4s...

Where's that? (Volume 6 extra)

NxY
Untitled-1
joined Oct 28, 2018

Well, I managed to find my avatar on Pixiv https://imgur.com/gallery/WT2hKRN
Edit: found a better quality version (can't find the original though).

Also the episodes up early this week https://goanimelist.me/yagate-kimi-ni-naru-episode-11

last edited at Dec 14, 2018 11:29AM

NxY
Untitled-1
joined Oct 28, 2018

In case you didn't read it, this is from an interview

Nakatani: It could be said that YagaKimi is approaching the climax or the last arc. To follow along until the end... eh, is it okay to say something that makes it sound like "it's about to end"? (laugh).

Anyways the serialization in Dengeki Daioh is heading towards the climax. Those who have read up to volume 6 may be worried and thinking "is it going to be alright?" but I believe that I'll be able to show everyone what they want to see, so please follow along!

Er... alright. Thanks? I don't doubt it will end well. I never once even considered this would end badly. Pretty sure one of my very first posts in this thread was that everyone can quote me on that until the end of the manga.

What I meant is that I really can't wait to see this resolved (rather than just hoping that it does at all). That video just really drove home how much I yearn for that. Sorry if that was misleading.

Oh, OK. Don't worry about it.
Edit:
Although in that case, the end won't come for another 11 - 15 months by my estimates. (Nakatani being 80% done, so that would be two more volumes, and the shortest volume being 7 chapters with the longest being 9)

last edited at Dec 9, 2018 8:30AM

NxY
Untitled-1
joined Oct 28, 2018

Imma let you all keep butting heads, but I just have to share this. I'm not sure if this was posted here before, but you can never post this kind of masterpiece too often.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E1UO5OE9FaQ

Probably the best YagaKimi MMV I ever saw. Of course, using an Aimer song elevates it 10 times over. I don't even know where all the coloured pages come from, but seeing the manga in full colour is astonishing.

This more than anything until now drives home how much I need a conclusion for this conflict that makes both of them happy...

In case you didn't read it, this is from an interview

Nakatani: It could be said that YagaKimi is approaching the climax, or the last arc. To follow along until the end... eh, is it okay to say something that makes it sound like "it's about to end"? (laugh).

Anyways the serialization in Dengeki Daioh is heading towards the climax. Those who have read up to volume 6 may be worried and thinking "is it going to be alright?" but I believe that I'll be able to show everyone what they want to see, so please follow along!

NxY
Untitled-1
joined Oct 28, 2018

I can only come to the conclusion Nakatani was writing it with 'what would be most interesting' rather than 'how can I best represent a particular orientation' in mind.

Nobody was arguing otherwise

This means that she is not making a deliberate statement and that trying to guess Yuu's orientation is futile considering neither Nakatani or Yuu are aware of it.

How do you know Nakatani isn't aware of it? Are you a mind reader?

'Aware' is the wrong word, 'particularly concerned' is better.

NxY
Untitled-1
joined Oct 28, 2018

A lot of people don't seem to realize that it's impossible not to include politics (in the wider sense, i.e. not restricted to everyday democratic process or lawmaking) in art. Even if an artist sets out to create something with the explicit goal of not taking a political side, that is also by itself a political side. Yuri, in general, is a genre that has always been heavily charged with politics since for starters it depicts something that many people still consider to be unnatural, immoral or unsavoury. If it's impossible to create art that isn't political, then this is true about Yuri even more.

I was referring more to authorial intent. I agree that Nakatani has to make some comment on LGBT in order to write the story she wants but, reading the interview EvilDevil posted, I can only come to the conclusion Nakatani was writing it with 'what would be most interesting' rather than 'how can I best represent a particular orientation' in mind.

This means that she is not making a deliberate statement and that trying to guess Yuu's orientation is futile considering neither Nakatani or Yuu are aware of it.

NxY
Untitled-1
joined Oct 28, 2018

I hope those top 10 haven't changed since, because I plan to make a meme out of this, and it would be really embarrasing if YagaKimi weren't 6th at the time I made that meme. -.-

It's currently 5th.

Well, considering I decided not to make that meme video today, that's actually good news. BTW, where can I find those rankings or whatever?
EDIT: Also, sorry for being so spammy before my 5-day-long self-punishment. I'd say where you can find more info on that, but then this would be spam, and, also I'd be accused of advertising my posts, so it's better to play it safe.

https://best100.animefestival.jp/

NxY
Untitled-1
joined Oct 28, 2018

I hope those top 10 haven't changed since, because I plan to make a meme out of this, and it would be really embarrasing if YagaKimi weren't 6th at the time I made that meme. -.-

It's currently 5th.