Office lady calls her "girl in the cap" (though I don't even know if "girl" is in the original) when calling from behind. That's the only hint we have. It's very tenuous, but the You character doesn't deny it. It would be enough in any other circumstances.
This is probably not helping things (sorry...), but Japanese and Korean have non-gendered pronouns. The literal translation of what the lady said in the original Korean comic would be something like, "Hey kid! (You with the) Baseball cap!". This is pretty much why there was confusion over which pronouns to use for characters like Crona (Soul Eater) and Hange (Attack on Titan) when their respective series were adapted into English, since the original Japanese didn't even have to deal with that issue. Also made me laugh whenever I read Ouran High School Host Club fics with the plot twist of "oh noes someone slipped up and referred to Haruhi as 'she/her' so now our cover is blown", because the characters live in Japan - when would that problem ever happen?
On the other hand, I'm pretty sure that Pito intended You to be seen as female, since the translation was approved and all. Plus, in all of the Pito comics that I've seen, I've yet to see one where the futa characters were meant to be interpreted as anything but female. I was under the impression that Pito tagged relevant tweets with "futanari warning" simply for the benefit of potential readers who didn't want to see their beloved Aqours characters being implied to have a dick. And yeah, if Pito saw this thread, I'd guess that their response would be something like "???? it's just You-chan as always, she just happens to have a penis".
The "did you let it all out" piece struck me as "did that help your frustration"...
That's literally what I said when I was screaming about this comic with a friend on Discord, haha. I'm sure it's no coincidence that it's juxtaposed with You's inner dialogue about how she was bottling up her feelings. I've always enjoyed how Pito's depicted You, whether as a lowkey player who hits on girls all the time (before you start pointing fingers at me, this description was lifted almost directly from a Pito tweet lol) or as an innocent and well-adjusted gal who can't stop blushing around her girlfriend.
While the manga and SIDs seem to depict You as a carefree and energetic girl, we did get to see a more complex side of her in the anime - particularly in Episode 11. It's always exciting to explore another side of a character - and it's all the more exciting if an artist depicts a side that's very different from the character's usual self, but somehow just makes it work. In my opinion, "Going Off Course" You is a great example of that. As the title says, she's straying from her usual persona of the perfect good girl, and in a way that feels in-character. The fact that You tends to clamp down on her feelings and just deal with whatever crap comes her way, and not discuss anything with her friends to boot is brought up in Episode 11, after all. This comic takes those feelings, cranks them up to 11, then steps back to let the chaos happen.
On the subject of the many faces of Pito's You-chan, this comic actually started out with Pito tweeting that it'd be nice to see a story where You belatedly hit puberty, and then adding, "I actually have a doujin planned out in my head already".
[To clarify - the Korean word for "puberty" can also mean "youth", as in that time of your adolescence when you go through puberty. Y'know, like the stuff you see in high school anime plots: becoming interested in boys/girls/etc., falling in love, dealing with confusing emotions, teen rebellion and mood swings in general, and so on. For example, whenever my cousin is being rebellious, my aunt literally says that he's "going through puberty", even though he's nearly 18. What she's technically saying is "he's in his rebellious youthful phase right now". So, Pito probably meant a story with You as a moody teen grappling with her emotions at a time when most of her peers would have found their balance, rather than a story where You literally deals with hormones and physical body growth and stuff.]
I love reading Pito's tweets, because there's usually a reply attached to the original drawing/comic that gives some background or unique insight into what's going on. For example, in this adorable childhood KanaMari image, you can see that Mari is impressed by Kanan's find and Kanan is happy to share it with her. But in a follow-up tweet, Pito explains what's really happening: Kanan is so tickled by how her new friend Mari always gives positive reactions to her discoveries that she excitedly looks for new things to show her all the time. In reality, Mari doesn't really like everything that Kanan brings to her - she just likes Kanan, period. BaKanan.
...whoops, sorry for the wall of text. tl;dr: alternative interpretations of You are awesome, and Pito has some great headcanons about the characters not just in the comics, but in tweets that follow those images as well.
last edited at Apr 15, 2017 1:01PM