Forum › Posts by Solid Ice

Solid Ice
Image Comments 16 Oct 22:24
Solid%20ice%20heart%203-29-15
joined Mar 30, 2015
Cpyfr0cu8aa6tth.png%20large

AshuraX, your comments provide lots of insight and depth into the pictured situation, not to mention humor.

Solid Ice
Solid%20ice%20heart%203-29-15
joined Mar 30, 2015

Mayu's poems seem to have hidden meaning.

Solid Ice
Gemini discussion 09 Oct 22:18
Solid%20ice%20heart%203-29-15
joined Mar 30, 2015

A pleasant read, however...

...what I really want to read is a sequel based on the panels at the bottom of the credits page!

Solid Ice
Solid%20ice%20heart%203-29-15
joined Mar 30, 2015

Very enjoyable. Is that a tear in Sorano's eye on p8?

Solid Ice
Image Comments 17 Sep 22:24
Solid%20ice%20heart%203-29-15
joined Mar 30, 2015
29455617

Out of this world

Solid Ice
Haru Ni discussion 16 Sep 07:28
Solid%20ice%20heart%203-29-15
joined Mar 30, 2015

I thought that it was more her remembering that conversation as she got to that train station and it was the last time she saw her.

Occam's Razor. Gumilove, this interpretation makes a lot of sense.

Solid Ice
Haru Ni discussion 15 Sep 22:04
Solid%20ice%20heart%203-29-15
joined Mar 30, 2015

I mean, she's waving goodbye to the apparition of the friend. If the friend was on the train and she was just seeing her off, then we would have been shown the friend in the train or had some hint that she was on it. It seems pretty clear to me that she's waving goodbye to her past and moving on via train.

My question is whether this is a sad but hopeful ending, where she is leaving to meet her future, or a horrible ending, where a teenage girl commits suicide over a failed love.

Yes, she is certainly waving good-bye to both her past and her friend's apparition. However, the fact that the crowd visible on p 26 has clearly disappeared by p 28 indicates that those people have just boarded the train (i.e. the train is not moving). Re never boarded the train.

I maintain that Re arrived at the train station with the hopes of a chance meeting with Fuyu. Re just happened to see Fuyu's apparition instead. Trains are a common form of transportation in Japan and for two friends to frequently meet at a given train station is perfectly normal.

Thus, I see no reason to believe an implied suicide.

Solid Ice
Haru Ni discussion 15 Sep 21:09
Solid%20ice%20heart%203-29-15
joined Mar 30, 2015

Wait, is she getting on the train or in front of the train? The answer to this question will significantly change my opinion of this story.

Neither; it looks like she is waving good-bye as the train departs.

Solid Ice
Solid%20ice%20heart%203-29-15
joined Mar 30, 2015

Pleasant and satisfying.

I wonder if there are people like that in real life...

They exist.

Solid Ice
Introduce Yourself..? 12 Sep 00:12
Solid%20ice%20heart%203-29-15
joined Mar 30, 2015

I am Solid Ice. I like to read. My favorite color is blue. I could expand on more engrossing details, but anticipation makes everything better ;)

Solid Ice
Love Sign discussion 11 Sep 22:07
Solid%20ice%20heart%203-29-15
joined Mar 30, 2015

Concise with a cliffhanger-style twist at the end.

Solid Ice
Itou-san discussion 10 Sep 18:53
Solid%20ice%20heart%203-29-15
joined Mar 30, 2015

The awkwardness between Ito and Sasano makes their development seem very natural.

Solid Ice
Solid%20ice%20heart%203-29-15
joined Mar 30, 2015

A pleasant read.

Solid%20ice%20heart%203-29-15
joined Mar 30, 2015

Ironically, while Kazuki is playing games, Mio is too innocent to notice.

Solid Ice
Snow-White discussion 29 Aug 13:07
Solid%20ice%20heart%203-29-15
joined Mar 30, 2015

Interesting twist on the classic tale.

Solid Ice
Solid%20ice%20heart%203-29-15
joined Mar 30, 2015

Masterpiece. This work is so expressive when it comes to Mokuzu's rough situation and how she and Nagisa take it in. The ongoing air of mystery enhances the anticipation throughout. Although tragic, the final ending runs in line with how these events would realistically unfold.

Solid Ice
Solid%20ice%20heart%203-29-15
joined Mar 30, 2015

Sweet and touching.

Solid%20ice%20heart%203-29-15
joined Mar 30, 2015

Wow. This is exceptional. So much excellent material in so few pages.

Solid Ice
Image Comments 13 Aug 23:37
Solid%20ice%20heart%203-29-15
joined Mar 30, 2015
48149309_p0

Their eye contact and facial expressions say a lot.

Solid Ice
Solid%20ice%20heart%203-29-15
joined Mar 30, 2015

The cover art is so full of emotion; very nice. A pleasant read as well.

Solid Ice
Image Comments 28 Jul 20:34
Solid%20ice%20heart%203-29-15
joined Mar 30, 2015
Aousagi1

The second frame is the best one

Solid Ice
Image Comments 07 Jul 21:30
Solid%20ice%20heart%203-29-15
joined Mar 30, 2015
Sumiaka

An interesting interaction

Solid Ice
Image Comments 05 Jul 23:45
Solid%20ice%20heart%203-29-15
joined Mar 30, 2015
51208642_p0

Such a delightful setting.

Solid%20ice%20heart%203-29-15
joined Mar 30, 2015

The glove-sharing scene is especially heartwarming.

Solid Ice
Image Comments 28 May 21:32
Solid%20ice%20heart%203-29-15
joined Mar 30, 2015
Thingy

Ouch! Don't those fangs hurt?