I'm a bit confused. Did Flan kill Sakuya or not?

Yeah, I suppose so.

Cant tell

"Because I broke oneesamas favorite toy" < that referring to Sakuya so most probably yes.

last edited at Jun 30, 2014 5:10PM

http://dynasty-scans.com/chapters/forbidden_fruit_1#3
^ says it clearly.

Rem would have used past tense when referring to Sakuya instead of present. I think "break" is loosely used here. You can break a toy and still use it, just how you can break someone's body and not kill them. It felt like Flan was just baiting Ram with her choice of words.

I always need to read twice to understand everything about Minakata Sunao's manga

Since it opens with Flan taking her clothes off, I doubt "broke" means "killed."

It doesn't make sense for Sakuya to be dead if Remilia is coming in there saying "don't lay your hands on Sakuya."

last edited at Jul 1, 2014 3:19PM

It doesn't make sense for Sakuya to be dead if Remilia is coming in there saying "don't lay your hands on Sakuya."

true she is not dead I think. more plausible if she is just hurt really bad with 'play' with flandre

last edited at Jul 1, 2014 7:39PM

I agree with

Rem would have used past tense when referring to Sakuya instead of present.

and

It doesn't make sense for Sakuya to be dead if Remilia is coming in there saying "don't lay your hands on Sakuya."

I think it's fairly obvious that Sakuya's not dead, but is in a bad state, yes.

It's interesting that with this and "Lonesome", which are supposed to be FlanRemi, both establish pretty clearly that Remilia loves Sakuya, and that Flandre gets jealous of the latter for that. Emotionally, neither story is properly FlanRemi at all.