Strictly minimally, Sakura Trick is a 4koma comedy series about kissing. There is nothing definitively SoL about any of that.
At best, you could probably call the segments relating to Yuzu and Kaede SoL, because they follow the standard subtext/one-sided crush formula and are mostly reserved for comedy shenanigans. However, both Yuu x Haruka and Kotone x Shizuku segments are strictly romance, with the comedy even toned down on Kotone x Shizuku's side for a bit more drama.
You'll really have to point out for me where lighthearted yuri with actual relationship development/kissing is such a common occurrence. Even on Dynasty you'll be hard pressed to find similar series. Most long-running series which ever actually get somewhere will engage in at least a moderate helping of drama, or spend a long time on pre-relationship buildup before the couple ever actually gets together. The only really comparable series I can think of in tone to Sakura Trick is Fu-Fu, or Kase-san as sort of a far candidate given most of its scanlated material is still of the pre-dating stage.
It is pretty demeaning to call all of the yuri content in Sakura Trick "pandering" when there's no reason to suspect the mangaka of not being serious and the yuri is, in fact, the main point of the manga (not SoL). For one thing considering that Tachi got her start doing yuri K-On doujins there's no reason not to think she is a serious yuri mangaka. I also completely fail to see how anyone could come to the conclusion that the characters in Sakura Trick are lacking in emotional substance. Even in spite of the comedic tone or misunderstandings, it is absolutely clear beyond any question that Yuu and Haruka genuinely love each other, and this is growing by the day.
People will have their own tastes for things like comedy, but I maintain that any "yuri" fan who believes that the yuri in Sakura Trick is ungenuine or "just pandering" is spewing complete bullshit. It's a proper yuri series like any of the others out there.
last edited at Mar 1, 2014 4:26AM