Forum › Posts by Gutterslob

Gutterslob
Img_4463
joined Sep 30, 2023

more romantic tension here than anything actually tagged sakuya x youmu

Img_4463
joined Sep 30, 2023

The way my face lit up when I learned this would be a Shinmyoumaru chapter...

Yeah writing Seija in particular seems like it demands any particular author to make some pretty fundamental characterization decisions wrt how far her contrarian-iness goes. For a long while i struggled to imagine her having any sort of non-destructive long term relationships because of my own "read" on the character, but softer portrayals (such as this) have won me over to not being completely opposed to it. In this interpretation's case I'd say her nature seems less bizarro-like and moreso interpreting "this food is 'good' (high quality tasty etc.) and therefore Bad, food should be worse", lol. But I might just be projecting my own interpretation there.

Gutterslob
Img_4463
joined Sep 30, 2023
Huz11ivayaefbpm-orig

look at the SIZE of that BUNNY!!!

Gutterslob
Img_4463
joined Sep 30, 2023

I really like that this ends with the suicide having failed. It manages to be more hopeful without reneging on there being serious consequences for it (hell, Saki does NOT seem pleased with her situation - the ending is optimistic but I'd struggle to call it "happy" in that context). Plus those two are juuuuuuuuust the right level of toxic for each other with how it wrapped up. XP

Edit: theres just something really compelling about the loss of autonomy there, I think is what I'm getting at. Her big show of self-determination ended up with her stuck in a hospital after she tried making that decision for someone else. I think thats really sweet in an ugly, ironic kinda way.

last edited at Oct 19, 2026 8:02PM

Gutterslob
Img_4463
joined Sep 30, 2023

waiting for the boob groping next chapter

momiji's boobs hehehehe

(this has been getting more pointedly ecchi tbh. its still toeing that damnable line where i can't QUITE tell where its going to commit though)

Img_4463
joined Sep 30, 2023

new kyouko outfit!!

Gutterslob
Img_4463
joined Sep 30, 2023

can't believe the damn assassin/super-soldier school got canonized. having vicarious "I KNEW IT!!!" satisfaction for everyone theorizing about that, unless there was equally unsubtle indicators beforehand i missed

Img_4463
joined Sep 30, 2023

What if it's a Paranoia Agent episode 3 situation and they have the same body but two different identities? (Not in favor of that scenario myself but like, it's possible...)

Gutterslob
Img_4463
joined Sep 30, 2023

oh man that was a twist ending let me check the comments
...
oh we arguing about gender? damn. I think that we should just consider Momij/Kouyou genderfluid until further notice, but that's just my opinion.

To be fair no other comments had been published since the new chapter was posted. (Unless some shit got mega-deleted).

I wish new girl the best. Not especially liking the portrayals of "lesbians" so far (quotes are there solely for the MC who's status is. in narrative superposition rn) but its at least nice to see someone straightf- a girl be shown as straightforwardly- shit a narratively-confirmed girl be attracted to another girl in this versus MC's "yeah i guess thats it" feelings on the subject. I will take a good ol "problematic" lesbian pervert any day, I'd reckon jacket-sniffers count.

Img_4463
joined Sep 30, 2023

holy shit that Chimi's TINY!!

Gutterslob
Img_4463
joined Sep 30, 2023

cousins are absolutely still incest i'm slightly flabberghasted by peoples heightened standards there. like they share grandparents?? and like, they aren't exactly estranged or anything social-wise. its not a "lesser" form of incest gawd!! gatekeepers smh
(glad the tags there even if its funny on a story thats technically subtext if you want to try REALLY hard to deny the obvious)

Img_4463
joined Sep 30, 2023

Actually pretty cute for the het that it is. Never would've thought of this pairing but it makes an odd bit of sense (relatively). Way prefer it to RinnoMarisa, which comes off a bit pervy old man-ish. (The only acceptable age gaps go the other way, like here! lmfao) IDK though maybe Rinn/Mari hits better if you've actually read the COLAs, still need to get to them.

Gutterslob
Img_4463
joined Sep 30, 2023

I'd loooooooooove it if this is going in the direction that Momiji IS Kouyou's "true" self and Ao's increasing fondness for "Kouyou" is merely her finding ways to see Girlhood through the sheer eggstrocity of it all. (And thus that she's still totally gay.) Still not sure that, or even a more gender-fluid approach, (hell even a "cishet but continuing to be gender nonconforming" approach) is where things are headed though. But each chapter does seem to make Actual Trans Girl Momiji more probable, so at this rate....????

Img_4463
joined Sep 30, 2023

Really love this take on Reimu's characterization. Also, kinda funny how they just sorta grow boobs, but I think I prefer that to it being more straightforwardly lolicon-y.
Edit arguing with myself: Reimu IS depicted with a bosom in other panels, it's just more noticeable when they're being fully defined like that. Meanwhile Marisa really didn't change much. XP

last edited at Sep 7, 2026 6:33PM

Gutterslob
Img_4463
joined Sep 30, 2023

they've invented the trans girl version of yuri bait and i'm. unironically excited to gamble with a different aspect of identity for once! (though in the case this is bait in that way it would also count as yuri bait for the same reason lmfao)

somewhat heartening is "his" seeming enjoyment of being cute? this continues to do a marvelous job threading the needle where theres just enough indicating maybe the good faith interpretation holds true while not really disproving any bad faith either. deserves a "psychological thriller" tag haha

Gutterslob
Img_4463
joined Sep 30, 2023
Hqwoyljauaaia8t-orig

ahhh, a conundrum that can only be solved through COMBAT!

Gutterslob
Img_4463
joined Sep 30, 2023

This second chapter really cements to dynamic of "flirting with going somewhere really confrontational and gross, but not" and "flirting with something that actually is saying something Profound about constructed gender or something, but not" at the same time. I'm cool with it being here at this point, it seems averse to going SO far as to cross a clear line for this site, but i am also not optimistic for where its headed. I joked before about them both turning out trans but another 'fun option' would be if Ao realizes she definitely likes girls and definitely doesn't like boys alongside Momiji deciding she "can't" be a girl (ideally for reasons of genuine identity rather than biology) and they don't stay together at the end of the series. I'm rooting for the author to pull a 180 and make this genuine trans lesbian rep but considering the alternatives to that or "making it just regular straight" is somewhat reassuring.

(I do find it funny how we now have panels contrasting Ao's perception of boymode!momiji with momiji standard that could be construed as setup for Ao realizing shes a lesbian or bisexual. It is doing something interesting there maybe -and neither outcome is necessarily negative out of context.)

last edited at Aug 19, 2026 8:33PM

Gutterslob
Img_4463
joined Sep 30, 2023

I think the people in this thread forgot nonbinary people exist. Like, one of my main reasons for transitioning was distancing myself as far from masculinity as possible on moral grounds. I will fight anyone who tries to tell me I'm not a woman, but in a hypothetical world where gender norms are reversed, I'd be just as fervently a man instead. Momiji seems to have a similarly utilitarian relationship with gender. She's still trans, but she arrived there as a function of her circumstances, not due to any inherent self-identity. She's not going to represent the average trans woman's experience, nor should she.

Dear God i hope the manga turns out to be as benign as your good faith wills it, but i fear you might be projecting a bit too much understanding of feminism & gender roles onto this. Though (echoing what others have said) I am myself unsure of how deeply the author understands anything, the whole manga seems to hop onto an actually topical point and back off again at random measures.

In that sense, while I'm deeply cynical, I am looking forward to see more of this?!?

Gutterslob
Img_4463
joined Sep 30, 2023

It's funny how the discussion always splits into this is trash vs. no, you don't get it, this is going to explore queerness, etc. When it's obviously just a het story that adds a few twists to make it more fun, like Ranma. Queer reads are fine, but ultimately these stories don't get past that surface so shit talking the story is also ok. Both sides are pretty annoying tbh but I think these type of stories are very honest from the beggining so the complains feel kind of forced

i mean, a queer reading IS directly invoked by the text (the girl all but calls herself gay), so thats a bit. not-actually-mutually-exclusive to it being largely irreverent towards actual sensibilities in that area. its both, for better or worse. (probably worse.) (holding out hope though...?)

Best case scenario for all this argumentation is that she ends up transitioning and its het the other way. XP

Img_4463
joined Sep 30, 2023

need some Plussy now

Img_4463
joined Sep 30, 2023

was Letty being a fairy A Thing that was believed back in the day? this is like the third doujin so far to say that...

Edit: ok not sure if any other doujins say that, I definitely read this one already and forgot. Still though lmao

last edited at Jul 21, 2026 8:09PM

Gutterslob
Img_4463
joined Sep 30, 2023
Hl5ri7gw0aaxpar-orig

People treating fatness with the same level of concern as like, recreational drug use, when “fat” is something you can literally just BE, is always kinda sad. Like i should just be shouting “AWOOOGA” here and instead I gotta be woke or whatever. (Also re:lore- adventurers canonically fluctuate body weight quite a bit due to how resurrection works in-universe, which I suspect has led to some of the fanart interpretations? Also theres portions of the manga where Falin is drawn a bit more heavier-set, though by no means “fat” necessarily.)

Oh and for the record, AWOOOOGA eyes pop out of my skull wolf whistles

Img_4463
joined Sep 30, 2023

oh my god look at the size of those EARS!!!

Gutterslob
Ginko Nut discussion 10 Jul 19:01
Img_4463
joined Sep 30, 2023

ohhh shoot this is Mizutataki? I knew it felt like a precursor to the “official” slice-of-life-y manga style but it actually being by the Lotus Eater’s author was more than I reckon’d. (Trying to read all the TH doujins in chrono order lol.)

last edited at Jul 10, 2026 7:02PM

Img_4463
joined Sep 30, 2023

Not sure why people were confused regarding the timescale on the “man she loved” thing, story makes a point that there was a while between her finding the witch and waking her up. Theres enough room in there for an ill-fated romance with some generic audience-displeasant townsguy without it being cheating of w/e. Bi rights i guess?
This does read as allegory for questioning/denial/closeting & the coming out process. Pretty good! :3