Embersember posted:
Why is the moderator being so rude, the guy was just hesitant.
True
Yep, shouting someone down for stating their opinion is a bit overkill.
I actually read Nezchan's comment first then read Breizh's comment. I'm surprised at the reaction.
Nezchan, your comment was very unnecessary and frankly rude/mean.
It came across as somewhat abrupt, yes, but I'm sure Nezchan is just worried.
I wonder if there are different interpretations of what Breizh is saying? I first read it as them saying they thought the illness was made up/hypochondria/whatever, which would be out of line for a med student to say of someone they had not examined. But it sounds like other people got the impression that they were just concerned about the mix of medications which may not be helpful together or for that purpose, which is fair.
I understood "there are some strange things in this that are bothering me with this." as simply meaning, they think some meds etc. are weird/unnecessary, so I wanted them to elaborated on that.
It's interesting because I read the comment as throwing doubt on the legitimacy of the fundraising campaign. Different people are going to interpret this very vague comment in different ways and I think it has a more negative impact on peoples' decisions than a positive one. Understandable that Nezchan would be so curt with Breizh.
Also, it's not great that it's the very first comment you read under the thread cause now we're talking about this instead of what's really important: getting some aid to this woman in need. I've never bought a commission before but now seems a good time to start.