Forum › Posts by Sylke

Sylke
Weiwei
joined Oct 9, 2017

Camera girl x teacher, please.

^ Came here to say that.

Weiwei
joined Oct 9, 2017

It's cute but totally uninteresting so far - there's litterally no scenario.

I really have a hard time reading that kind of thing personnally.

Sylke
1 x ½ discussion 23 Apr 00:38
Weiwei
joined Oct 9, 2017

I don't think there's any member of my family I would fuck, because that would litterally wreck my relationship with them, and also I don't have much sexual attirance to any of them.

But this is not about me and everyone is free to love everyone as long as it's mutually OK and no sexual minor is involved. (in my country the sexual majority is 15)

I really like that manga personnally. I like big gender gap mangas too, and incest mangas. As long as it's treated smartly.

There's a manga I really used to like, that was about a 35 yo writer and a 11 year old girl falling in love. It was very smart friend and very sweet.

We just have to keep in mind that when you are younger and in a submissive position (like student/teacher or child/parent), everything is really warped and creating a fair and positive relationship is super hard.

Sylke
VAMPEERZ discussion 22 Apr 05:22
Weiwei
joined Oct 9, 2017

14 yo is old enough to have sex.

Though given the age of the vampire...

Sylke
VAMPEERZ discussion 21 Apr 23:43
Weiwei
joined Oct 9, 2017

Never cared about plagiarism personnally.

I liked Prism.
I like Stretch.
I'm super duper excited because I like this author. A lot.

Weiwei
joined Oct 9, 2017

Wow this last chapter looks so much like my love life - like me and every single het girl or even sometimes bi girl I crushed on... It hurts.

Weiwei
joined Oct 9, 2017

I thought it was another bad comedy with no scenario and only boring flirting but it's actually getting interesting.

Weiwei
joined Oct 9, 2017

The drawings irritates me, the scenario is absurd, the characters have no depths... I just dont get how this got 1000+ comments. Maybe I'm growing old ? :(

Sylke
Cocoa discussion 19 Apr 12:41
Weiwei
joined Oct 9, 2017

Lmao wtf am I reading

Sylke
Still Sick discussion 19 Apr 12:37
Weiwei
joined Oct 9, 2017

Phew. I thought this was about to run down the friendship route, but Maekawa went ahead and rolled it back in

YES!!! Goooooood yes

Weiwei
joined Oct 9, 2017

Am I the only one to think that this manga is utterly bad ? It's becoming harder and harder to read and god knows I'm not difficult to please.

Weiwei
joined Oct 9, 2017

Doesnt matter, had yuri

Weiwei
joined Oct 9, 2017

aaaaaawww <3

The transvestite-gay-guy part of me likes that so ~ fcking ~ much. <3

last edited at Apr 6, 2019 3:52PM

Sylke
Karura discussion 27 Mar 20:59
Weiwei
joined Oct 9, 2017

There was a few pages in this chapter that actually made me really interested. Its pretty rare I get moved by mangas so that was great.

Sylke
Weiwei
joined Oct 9, 2017

If this was about Seiji's problems, maybe it would prove to be interesting. But here, it seems to be about "LGBT people".

  • The lesbian is a manipulative bitch
  • The gay is a creepy psycho
  • The bisexual is a cheating whore
  • The trans (Sumon) is nondescript at the moment.
  • The crossdresser/genderfluid is just unconsciously wishing to be someone's bitch.

If this author tried to be an "ally" by showing a gallery of "realistic" LGBT characters, he isn't doing a very good job. He's just reinforcing stereotypes.

Hahah exactly

Weiwei
joined Oct 9, 2017

Well my tastes are the same as Nya-chan, though I'd add a lot of korean mangas that are not on this website.

Good yuri is very rare. But personnally "forgettable" yuri makes me super happy and since it's pretty much forgettable, I can re-read it over and over again. :3

This manga is continuing in the predictable Yukka x Hime route and I'm happy about it :3

As for Akira, let's hope for an happy end ? :D

Weiwei
joined Oct 9, 2017

Well let's see how it unfolds. I'm mildly annoyed by the trans representation but since it's not transyuri anymore, it's a lot more interesting. (as I said, it's really the "girl going out with a hot guy in dress" thing that annoys the shit out of me, because it's a very hypocrit fantasy of a lot of women out there and I suffered from it, as did a lot of others I'm sure)

And actually, if it's trans het, then it's nice that Akira is not passing (without it being yaoi like a lot of yaoi out there).

So I'm a lot more interested in that manga now.

This manga is only preaching at the moment. It's not telling a story.

Yup. Especially the first episodes were really annoying for that. It was basically trans advocacy over and over, and no one is interested in that. Supporting trans rights works by writing good trans stories, not trying super hard to be an ally and write something meh. (that will have the exact opposite impact)

Now there's romance and things seem to happen, so I'm happy. (I'm more interested in Yuuka x Hime but well, I'm rooting for Akira too of course)

Weiwei
joined Oct 9, 2017

Yeah, that's stories that appeal to trans women, but not trans stories.

Of course Boku Girl is annoying philosophically speaking, but since it's not talking about transgender issues, it annoys me a lot less.

If we start talking about gender bender in general, then 80 percent of the manga production is indeed super annoying.

Weiwei
joined Oct 9, 2017

Well I know hundreds of twoman ans passing is a LOT less an issue than what is usually said in the medias, especially body passing.

I made the list about TRANSGENDER mangas. Not gender bender ones. We're talking about representation of trans person here, not about magic things, because that has nothing to do with being trans ... ?

Like the hero of Boku Girl doesn't feel like he's a girl. He's just magically transformed.

So yeah, I'm only selecting the trans narrative.

And in the trans narrative, the tropes you are criticizing are most of the time not present.

Weiwei
joined Oct 9, 2017

Also as a twoman my reality is shitty enough, I prefer to read fantasy things that make me feel good.

Weiwei
joined Oct 9, 2017

Except most trans girls, especially transitionning in their teens, ends up passing fairly easily. And they certainly don't have big hands and square shoulders... Most "non passing" trans girls are trans girls that are early in transition or transitionned very late or are very unlucky on the biological side. Or that don't want to medically transition at all.

Wandering Son : no fantasy here (or object of comedy)
Double House : no fantasy here (or object of comedy)
Half & Half : no fantasy here (or object of comedy)
Nicoichi : no fantasy here (or object of comedy)
Otokono Doushi Renai Chuu : no fantasy here (or object of comedy)
Himegoto Juukyusai no Seifuku : no fantasy here (or object of comedy)
Kyu Kara Yonshimai : no fantasy here (or object of comedy)
Ai no Shintairaku : no fantasy here (or object of comedy)
F.Compo : might have a bit of fantasy or object of comedy here, but globally it's good-natured
Hanayome wa Motodan shi : no fantasy here (or object of comedy)
No Bra : I don't remember
Sunu Sumu Muriku no Koibito : no fantasy here (or object of comedy)
Arachne (Angel Sanctuary) : no fantasy here (or object of comedy)
Bokura no Hentai : no fantasy here (or object of comedy)
Genshiken Nidaime & Spotted Flower : it's a comedy but the tgirl is not the object, and she's not fantasized either

In all those mangas, there is depiction of how hard it is to transition, of rejection, of realistic things, of being a bit too tall, to wide, of getting spotted.

I don't remember having seen a transgender manga that made me say "fuuuuuuu" before, on the contrary the depictions of trans persons in mangas are pretty interesting and on point ! (can't say the same for the cinema, series, other medias... !)

Of course no manga is actually showing you the laser surgeries, the SRS surgeries, the FFS surgeries, the pills, the waxing, the pain, the dilatations, ... No manga show you in detail the medical side. But as far as the social side (getting bullied, dealing with your own body, wanting to kill yourself, prostitution, etc.) is concerned, these mangas do a great job.

Weiwei
joined Oct 9, 2017

Bah. If you depict a lesbian tgirl, you support the autogynephily theory.
If you depict a het tgirl you support the "homosexual boy in dress" theory.

None is "least interesting". Personnally I prefer lesbian tgirls story cause I'm a lesbian twoman, but I really enjoy het tgirls story because they make me feel really validated as a woman. Having a man love you is the best way to crush the idea that we are defined by our sex assigned at birth.

That's only my view on the topic and my feeling about it of course.

I litterally adore Prunus Girl. I didn't note it above because it's a yaoi, or mostly a NB x Boy, but gooooood, I feel so good reading this manga every time. The hero is SO FCKING COOL.

Gender hacking at its finest.

Weiwei
joined Oct 9, 2017

Admittedly I didn't read every het transgirl manga there is, but, focusing on the "real" transgender manga, not the magical ones, even though most of them are transgender metaphors (like Bra Girl, Boku Girl, Kanojo ni Haru ni...), nor the crossdressing or trap ones...

List of transgirls lesbians in manga :
- Wandering Son (main character)
- Double House
- Half & Half
- Nicoichi
- Otokono Doushi Renai Chuu (trans girl x trans girl )
- Himegoto Juukyusai no Seifuku (I believe she's trans right ?)
- Kyu Kara Yonshimai

List of transgirls het in manga :
- Wandering Son (yuki-san)
- Ai no Shintairaku
- F.Compo (trans guy x trans woman)
- Hanayome wa Motodan shi
- No Bra (if I remember well she's trans ?)
- Sunu Sumu Muriku no Koibito

Pansexual Tgirls :
- Arachne (Angel Sanctuary) (can't remember but pretty sure she's bi/pan, angel sanctuary is a big genderfuck anyway)
- Bokura no Hentai (not sure but I believe Marika was bi ?)
- Genshiken Nidaime & Spotted Flower (clearly bi/pan)

last edited at Mar 16, 2019 10:04AM

Weiwei
joined Oct 9, 2017

Aaaw now I'm starting to be interested. I luv het tgirls stories. <3 (Boku Girl <3)

And yuri between Hime and the tall blond girl is going to be so hawt.

last edited at Mar 16, 2019 8:40AM

Weiwei
joined Oct 9, 2017

the bi woman missed dicks so she went out to find em ,
the end .

this is why we should never trust bi women lolol

I laughed.

Biphobia is bad but lets be honnest, this scenario is so common its boring.

I still date bi girls though. I just make fun of it from time to time. To stay sane.