I didn't say she isn't real. I said she's different character. And they both had the same tragedy, but she made different choice than OG Homura given the same circumstances, making her different character.
Keep in mind that being in Kamihama makes girls react differently to the same situations, thanks to the Doppel insurance. You didn't see anyone have a Mami-type freakout after Mitama's explanation.
If anything, the writers had to crank up the Magius' nastiness to justify why so many girls oppose them.
Also, MR Homura is still a very early version of Megane Homura, somewhat naive and not yet jaded, searching for a way to save everyone and not resigned to only save Madoka. Sure, she might not become the Coolmura we all know and love, but as far as she is concerned, that's probably for the best.
last edited at May 27, 2020 9:24AM