Forum › Posts by commiecat

commiecat
Dynastyscans
joined May 24, 2022

It's amazing seeing Sorawo so able to talk to Toriko about these things she previously kept under wraps by impulse, and even thinking about how there's no way she wants to take around it. She's grown so much. I hope she follows her Doppelganger's lead and gets some well-needed comfort.
She's opened up a lot and reflected meaningfully on her past quite a bit lately. It's nice to see.

Dynastyscans
joined May 24, 2022

Chang Le do you really know so little or are you actively trying to avoid your crush? If someone you want to spend time with asks if you want to eat, say yes girl, especially if you’re hungry.
I could give her the excuse of obliviousness if she actually wasn't hungry...

Dynastyscans
joined May 24, 2022

A bit too close to home as a grad student with professor family members, having heard many a story about inappropriate relationships with grad students. Can't help but imagine myself in the professors shoes and feel really skeeved out and that anxiety.
It's an unrealistic scenario, but that only makes the idea of being in that position more uncomfortable to me. Claiming that your grad student sexually assaulted you would not be easy.

I think what gets in the way of my enjoyment of ones written like this might be the passive position one of the characters is given. A contrasting example that I really like is Black & White, where both parties are jockeying. There's a lot of other things separating them ofc, but unless that aspect changes idk if I'll end up being able to enjoy this one.

Edit:
One thing I like is when pieces give some emotional significance to things like harassment or sexual assault. This doesn't have to be angsty, just any sort of story other than "wow this actually makes me fall in love with this person." That story was tired out by het romances a long time ago...

last edited at Nov 9, 2026 1:39AM

Dynastyscans
joined May 24, 2022

Ren really is a shitty person. Like she's leading Chitose on she says "Oh well I turned down her confession" yet on this date she didn't reiterate that and then even told her she could rent her again.

And then she has Mizuki who she can't stand but also enjoys being around how she can feel both at the same time is beyond me tbh. And now she shows up while you're on a rental date with the exact same girl she should have turned down in the first place.

Ren is a garbage human being.

Ren does shitty things. Being is doing. She doesn't have the essence of a shitty person because there is no such essence.

Many people make all sorts of these atrocious relationship moves. I know I'm among them. You learn, hopefully do your best to do right by the people you've hurt, and move on a changed person.

On enjoying but not standing someone, I think in this instance it's heavily tied to her suppression of expressing what she doesn't like. It's normal to be annoyed at a friend or a partner about something they did or are doing. When you repeatedly fail to honestly share (or introspect) how you feel and why, it can fester and break things apart. If I didn't tell my roommate to chill out and watch how she talks to me when we cook together, she'd really stress me out and make me overwhelmed. I'd actively dread cooking with her. Since I told her that and she can accommodate it, cooking with her is often a highlight of my day. She's fun.

The otherside of communicating is acting on things communicated to you ofc, that's what completes the loop.

commiecat
Dynastyscans
joined May 24, 2022

never change skyekurisu, I'm eating all this shit up lmao

commiecat
Dynastyscans
joined May 24, 2022

Dynasty needs to quality control, god damn.

okk ik this is probably bait but like.. 90% of manga on this site since the beginning is trash and thats why we're here? we love trash????

Well that's an extremely generalized and insulting statement to the vast majority of creatives whose work is uploaded here.

Well yes, it's generalized, but it's also aping Sturgeon's Law and not to be taken too seriously.
Also "trash" does not have to mean "bad" when discussing media. "Trash" can be supremely entertaining and enriching, while at the same time you know it's not high brow in any way.

I see, well I don't personally find calling everything that's not Shakespeare trash a good use of the word personally, but maybe I'm in the minority here and people love to use the word in a generalized way even if it's insulting to the overwhelming majority of creatives to reduce their works down to the equivalent of rotting garbage in a landfill.

I think pulp or pulpy (as in pulp romance, not pulp adventure or pulp scifi) may be a more appropriate term for what "trash" is trying to get across, if you want another word. Definitely a real point tho lol. There's SOoo many series and one-shots on here that aren't that good, but I love yuri so I'll keep reading that garbage.
[({this is a snowclone joke, there is no need to get upset about me suddenly calling it garbage})]

Dynastyscans
joined May 24, 2022

Reading some of the comments before the story like "Oh okay this is a story about a gender nonconforming boy with some ambiguity"
Which like, yes. technically...
There is also direct transphobia directed at the lead, and she is defended with feminine pronouns and the end of the story swaps to gender ambiguous pronouns "I just can't see this person as a friend". This seems pretty clear cut. I do love gender nonconformity, but please be for real. That character is transgender.

I mean, that's definitely my interpretation, but the story doesn't actually get into it and I've been disappointed in the past by how the author later developed things. They've left some ambiguity here. That could be used to explore how for trans people the gender identity process, expression, and support for it involves a lot of ambiguity. It could also be used to move the story down a cis crossdresser path. He may "just like cute things," "like crossdressing, but still wants to be a cis guy," "just cried tears of joy from being amazed by getting to crossdress," "just have been embarrassed about crossdressing, not feeling dysphoria." I would be surprised if the author was intending that route, but there's also publisher interference to consider.

Personally, I don't think the third person pronoun usage is evidence of anything from the text bc they're based on the translator's best interpretation of what it would be like in English, not a feature of the story in Japanese. Also, "crossdressers" famously may use she/her pronouns when crossdressing. Additionally, I've definitely seen a manga before where a crossdresser faced some transphobia but the mangaka decided to make it into "noo, actually this is the noble art of crossdressing, please don't make such defamatory accusations." Can't remember what it was precisely.

last edited at Sep 8, 2026 9:35PM

Dynastyscans
joined May 24, 2022

Homare would probably be most comfortable with GNC demiboy if introduced to Eurosphere gender theory.

There's a lot of really big assumptions in this statement that aren't really be supported by the text. I don't think it's worthwhile to argue if a character is trans in this or that way or a crossdressing guy, especially when there's just not enough material to really get that specific. But if we're really just talking probabilistically, there's far fewer gnc demiboys like this in the North American gender context than trans women. There's more gnc guys like this that aren't demiboys tbh. Significantly though, these things are fluid and we can't say what Homare would be drawn to in one moment of the story would be what they want later on.

Missing the trans tag

Submit a tag request if that's all you have to say (button right next to the forum under the title).
I agree though, both crossdressing and trans tags so it's findable by either. If the one-shot turned into a series and it was resolved one way or the other then that might change it, but crossdressing at least on this chapter since that's what's depicted (the characters are thinking about it as such).

last edited at Sep 8, 2026 5:45PM

commiecat
Dynastyscans
joined May 24, 2022
134378887_p0

Have you ever played goo goo babies with your life on the line?

Dynastyscans
joined May 24, 2022

the abusive and manipulative pedophile is the antagonist? too rare a sight, but a welcome one.

and yeah the way michiru was killed was a little too over the top... coulda just had her get hit by a car in a normal way.

commiecat
Dynastyscans
joined May 24, 2022

Hmmm I'm worried about the physical trauma but that was cute I guess??

Yeah like blunt force has a lot more inherent damage than the alternatives.

last edited at Apr 12, 2025 1:28AM

commiecat
Dynastyscans
joined May 24, 2022
Gmkt7f3boaazifn-orig

I was thinking Mitsumi too! She likes making a :D face and having dot eyes a lot.

Dynastyscans
joined May 24, 2022

I hope for her own sake that Lin Luxi's mom can begin to accept her daughter's sexuality and independence.
She's clearly reeling from being confronted with the contradictions between her views of filial piety and family control vs. her daughter's new capability to resist them. Before, she was unwilling to reconcile her own prejudices with Lin Luxi's sexuality and had all the power to not do so. Now, she has the same prejudices, but has unexpectedly lost her power—she failed to force her will upon Lin Luxi, and will now have to answer to her (or at least negotiate) if she wants them to continue having a relationship.
It seems like the both want a relationship, and I can't imagine the mom will cope very well without Lin Luxi since she's structured her whole life up till now around her daughter. My childhood experiences with my mom were rocky to say the least and while my parents have all been very supportive of my queerness, I feel like I can relate to the situation a lot.
It's very reasonable to draw a line across which you don't feel obligated to consider someone else at the expense of yourself (socially, mentally, materially), but I think people can lose some nuance with antagonistic characters. Obviously stories can overplay this with "tragic villain backstories." There's always nuance—the nuance doesn't always matter. Here though, it's family, it's her mom that she still loves and cares about. Cutting all contact is an option, but it's a simple solution to a complex problem.
Is it worth Lin Luxi's effort to keep some contact in the hopes that her mom comes to accept her, however begrudgingly? I'm excited to find out as the series continues :]

Dynastyscans
joined May 24, 2022

Asako is so sweet. I remember when abiding by the rules was all I knew how to do too, girl. It can be a little isolating. For me, I wanted to change a lot and I did. Asako seems to truly believe that her professed ethos is what works best for her, but she also doesn't want that to make her seem condescending or unfamiliar. In going out with Nagi (and before that hiding a manga collection), she's implicitly chosen a more moderated stance, but the words have yet to catch up to her feelings. I think she'd be happy to live in the middle ground that most people end up in: following the rules is good, but it makes sense to bend or break the rules once in a while and the rules don't work for everyone.

Dynastyscans
joined May 24, 2022

Really cute, though you do need to overlook the fact that they probably started dating when Minato was still a minor.

Not in Japan, where age of consent is 16 since 2023 (used to be 13).

Age of consent =/= age of majority. When the former is lower than the latter, a minor can legally consent.
The age of majority in Japan was lowered from 20 to 18 a few years ago. Minato was a legal minor, Minato was able to legally consent. Which is also beside the point; I don't think the original commenter was considered with legality, only ethics.

Not sure people want to make this forum about issues of consent, grooming, and age-based power imbalances though. Because I can't resist, I'll leave my opinion at: I think making a manga about a real 20 yr old/30 yr old couple is weird.

Dynastyscans
joined May 24, 2022

just noticed Hikaru's cute hime cut. She's serving Heian realness

commiecat
Cat Love discussion 23 Jan 16:41
Dynastyscans
joined May 24, 2022

Bit of a jumbled ramble. Anyway, final thoughts is that Mao wasn't cheating but Hikaru is still valid for feeling hurt.

then try to live in a more open circles? like this is cheating for the majority of the world you know?

your also taking the idea that Mao didn’t say I love you in the kind the MC perceived as! how do you know that? and that gives your garbage excuse to say it was not cheating LMAO any one that starts with love confessions and DOES not tell others that they are not in a monogamy relationship takes advantage of how the world works, and that not many people WANNA be in a open relationship, this is manipulation like wtf? how are you excusing such behaivour?

Not classifying it as cheating doesn't necessarily endorse the behavior. Missteps, mistakes, miscommunications, and being inconsiderate are not exclusive to cheating.

last edited at Jan 23, 2025 4:41PM

commiecat
Dynastyscans
joined May 24, 2022

I like the different background shades to denote farther back and less farther back in time. I don't know if I've ever noticed a manga use more than "white for present, black for past," though I'm sure it's been done.

Dynastyscans
joined May 24, 2022

wow... tongtong naturally hitting all the right buttons for lin luxi. If only all smut was this good LOL.
Time to see how lin luxi squeezes out an explanation under such conditions... it would even make sense for her to explain her needs in bed at this point. I expect that plot will take a little longer to wrap up though.
My next-chapter predictions:
1. Lin Luxi has some difficulty explaining her history in middle school, but gets out a sufficiently detailed answer for Tongtong to understand what's up between her and Baiyan.
2. Tongtong then gets frustrated with Lin Luxi about her avoiding the issue earlier making...
3. Lin Luxi only able to muster a very minimal explanation for her being flustered and horny before...
4. They finish where they left off.
Out if this, Tongtong is maybe still slightly concerned about Baiyan, but generally reassured and now mostly interested in what's the deal with her sub gf. But... Baiyan blackmails them about being lesbians and school drama distracts the couple from making much progress in the bedroom.

In a different, more "toxic yuri," series, this could lead to some infidelity from Lin Luxi, but that's not gonna happen here.

last edited at Nov 29, 2024 8:35PM

Dynastyscans
joined May 24, 2022

I like how this one has the senpai that's eager to get closer be, like, semi-oblivious to how hard she's crushing. and then when her kouhai has her pinned she's overcome by blushing. It's pretty open to interpretation, but senpai seems kinda closeted here, that's my headcanon at least.

Dynastyscans
joined May 24, 2022

Good luck, babe!

Dynastyscans
joined May 24, 2022

Does this really need the age gap tag when it's only 6 years and it seems like they are both adults? There's no mention to indicate school age or anything which is usually what I associate with age gap.

Cute story although I feel like Tamaki shoulda made a move earlier instead of right before she left since she was interested too? 6 months of waiting is a long time especially since she knew about the crush for months lol.

Approaching deadlines are good motivators. Thinking back to when I asked out my first ex... On the night I had planned to ask them out, I waited until the last flight of stairs preceding our splitting before I inviting them to dinner.

commiecat
Dynastyscans
joined May 24, 2022

This sucked tbh, really did not do the topic justice. just using it for a shallow plot element

commiecat
Dynastyscans
joined May 24, 2022

speedrun the sex, which failed (and amazingly she didn't force Mion), so they speedran the breakup.

You can publish a lot, but idk if the magazine would've wanted to publish a graphic depiction of date rape.

Dynastyscans
joined May 24, 2022

Let's see what insights about Blondie this manga will give us. Curious, as someone who has at times been closer to Blondie than Glasses in my relationships...