Forum › Posts by Kazu-kun

10466e3de
joined Oct 25, 2014

Is the term "Dark Lord" gendered in the original? If not I'm entertaining the idea of the older magical girl actually having become the Dark Lord.

And how would you explain Junna having the charm?

Junna also said she has never met the Dark Lord, so the option of the Lord giving the charm to Junna is out of the picture.

10466e3de
joined Oct 25, 2014

I imagine the major part of their relationship will involve thrid party mediation. Junna clearly does not understand that Hane is in crisis, and that her plan to become the final boss for Hane will probably send her over the edge. Meanwhile, Hane is guilt over the possibility of hurting Junna again is keeping her from having the necessary hard, painful conversations they need to move forward. I imagine the other magical girls are going to be the mediators for this situation.

Do you seriously think this author would settle this matter with a civil conversation with mediators and whatnot? Not a chance. This is gonna blow up and shit will hit the fan. And I'm really convinced the Dark Lord will get involved too. The foreshadowing for that is way too thick.

10466e3de
joined Oct 25, 2014

So Junna trying to be a replacement of the older magical girl for Hane (which is very ironic because Junna's most likely the magical girl herself) has filled Hane with negative emotions like guilt and shame. I think that's why her thorn-looking scars are growing up her neck.

My prediction is that this will make Hane an easier target for the dark lord. Junna recently confirmed the lord is constantly watching the magical girls from far away. That has to be an important piece of information. So I think he probably will pick up on what's going on with Hane. My guess is the lord will manage to control Hane's mind and Junna will have to fight to save her. And in that battle the lord will reveal to Junna that Junna is actually the older magical girl. Imagine Junna's guilt when she finds that out. It'd mean she pushed Hane into a pit of darkness out of a stupid misunderstanding.

last edited at Nov 16, 2026 12:26PM

10466e3de
joined Oct 25, 2014

So in Navia's comics Kaguya (in artificial body) and Yachiyo share one consciousness? hmm

It's that way in the movie too.

This is pretty much the most accurate manga about Kaguya I've seen.

last edited at Nov 6, 2026 9:14PM

10466e3de
joined Oct 25, 2014

okay how did Junna put up the barrier she again? does that mean she can do some magical girl spells? evil general tricks or genuine article tho?

Hane made it to protect Junna. Notice that it's pink.

Junna destroyed Hane's barrier in chapter 23:

https://dynasty-scans.com/chapters/former_evil_general_is_crushing_on_the_magical_girl_ch23#11
https://dynasty-scans.com/chapters/former_evil_general_is_crushing_on_the_magical_girl_ch23#12

Junna must have made a new one afterwards so Hane wouldn't find out.

10466e3de
joined Oct 25, 2014

More importantly, we now know that all the female members of the evil organization are former magical girls. So Junna was a magical girl. That much is confirmed.

What? ALL female members? I thought it was just the ntr guy servants

The NTR guy said their evil lord has been capturing magical girls for a long time. NTR guy's servants are just a few or them he managed to "save" from their lord.

Also, even underling-chan just revealed she had a compact, which is the brooch that magical girls use to transform. So as of right now, all the girls from the evil organization that we know of are former magical girls.

last edited at Nov 2, 2026 11:27PM

10466e3de
joined Oct 25, 2014

The problem is the charm is the only solid evidence we have, and it points to Juna being the magical girl. Not only she has the charm, but in chapter 26 the charm responded to her feelings and started glowing:

Yeah, if the author plans her to not be despite the only evidence pointing to her, the author would probably have made a chapter explicitly reminding us that that isn't enough evidence... oh wait

Think about it. All the girls working for the evil organisation are former magical girls captured by their evil lord. This was confirmed in chapters 27-28. This means Junna was a magical girl. That much is confirmed. Junna was a magical girl.

So that's evidence number one: Junna was a magical girl in the past.

In the past, Hane gave a magical girl a charm, and now in the present time Junna has the charm.

So that's evidence number two: Junna has Hane's charm.

We also know that Junna doesn't remember her past. She claims NOT to be the magical girl who saved Hane, but she actually doesn't remember that. In fact, if Junna wanted to prove she's not the magical girl that saved Hane, she could easily do so by explaining how she got the charm. But she didn't, because she doesn't remember.

So that's evidence number three: Junna doesn't remember her past so any claims about her past coming from her POV is unreliable.

Finally, for some reason, we see in chapter 27 that the charm responds to Junna's feelings.

So that's evidence number four: Hane's charm responds to Junna's feelings.

On the other hand, we have no actual evidence suggesting that Junna is NOT the magical girl who saved Hane as far as I can see. Hane's friends doubting that Junna is the magical girl doesn't constitute actual evidence.

last edited at Nov 2, 2026 10:03PM

10466e3de
joined Oct 25, 2014

I don't think Junna is the older magical girl, there could be so many reasons on why she has the charm.

The problem is the charm is the only solid evidence we have, and it points to Juna being the magical girl. Not only she has the charm, but in chapter 26 the charm responded to her feelings and started glowing:

https://dynasty-scans.com/chapters/former_evil_general_is_crushing_on_the_magical_girl_ch26#10

More importantly, we now know that all the female members of the evil organization are former magical girls. So Junna was a magical girl. That much is confirmed.

last edited at Nov 2, 2026 12:18PM

10466e3de
joined Oct 25, 2014

Okay. So the mysterious unkown magical senpai is the Dark Lord, right?

What? No, Junna is the magical girl. She has the charm. If the Dark Lord was the magical girl, the Dark Lord would have the charm. But Junna has it.

last edited at Oct 30, 2026 7:33PM

10466e3de
joined Oct 25, 2014

We learned something really interesting in this chapter. It looks like all the girls working for the evil organization are former magical girls.

This supports the theory that the older magical girl who saved Hane in the past is actually Junna.

10466e3de
joined Oct 25, 2014

We just have strong evidence...Just not 100% percentage sure...I was initially banking hard on the theory and idea but then other people began to doubt it claiming their ages don't match or something and you know author can suddenly change the story-mid way and makes the older purple magical girl not be Juuna (Red herring trope)

I see some people insisting Junna's not the magical girl but not a single one of them has a good explanation as to why Junna has the charm. If anything, the charm is the strongest most solid evidence we have on the matter, and it points to Junna being the magical girl. Heck, in this chapter the charm started to glow as if it was responding to Junna's feelings.

10466e3de
joined Oct 25, 2014

My only hope is the lord is not the actual older magical girl she liked

Why are we so sure Junna is not the magic girl? She has the charm, right? Even though she claims she's not the magic girl, we know for a fact that Junna's memory is spotty at best so we can't take her word for it.

last edited at Oct 12, 2026 7:32PM

Kazu-kun
10466e3de
joined Oct 25, 2014

Right, but that still gives us two separate Yachiyo's with distinct streams of consciousness/experience after the split, as opposed to one Yachiyo puppeting the robot from Tsukuyomi while also controlling her avatar.

Which is fine! But seems some people prefer one Yachiyo to two.

Yachiyo doesn't puppeteer the robot from Tsukuyomi. Yachiyo is inside the robot. And she made a copy of herself to manage Tsukuyomi in her place. The copy is just that, a copy. It doesn't really have a separate consciousness. In fact, Yachiyo was able to create many copies of herself at the same times, as shown when she's performing a show at the beginning of the movie. And all of them share the same consciousness. They are just extensions of the real Yachiyo who is actually Kaguya (the Kaguya that crash landed on Earth 8000 years ago).

last edited at Oct 2, 2026 10:32PM

Kazu-kun
10466e3de
joined Oct 25, 2014

I feel that this interpretation / misunderstanding(?) of the film's ending comes from the final shot of the three of them being together. While it would have made more sense for the story to start with Kaguya × (Teenage) Iroha and then switch to Yachiyo × (Adult) Iroha, the director and the rest of the creative team wanted the three characters/actors to be all together in the end.

I think that can easily be explained thanks to these pieces of information we have:

1) Iroha made a Kaguya body for Yachiyo so the latter can interact with her in the real world.

2) Yachiyo can make copies of herself in Tsukuyomi

With just these two facts, we can piece together the ending easily. Yachiyo probably takers Kaguya's form whenever she's hanging out with Iroha, because Iroha prefers it that way. I mean, if she didn't, why would she make a KAGUYA-looking body for Yachiyo instead of a body that looks like Yachiyo? Iroha clearly has her preferences and I assume Yachiyo would be happy to comply. But, while Yachiyo is screwing around with Iroha while looking like her former self, they need someone to take care of Tsukuyomi. So Yachiyo would make a copy / clone of herself to do just that while she's fucking around.

So that's it. At the end of the movie we see the three together because we have Iroha, Yachiyo (looking like Kaguya), and the Yachiyo copy / clone. This fits the information we have without contradicting the plot. Yachiyo and Kaguya are only one person, not two. The other Yachiyo is a copy, a clone.

last edited at Sep 28, 2026 7:24PM

10466e3de
joined Oct 25, 2014

Wait, wasn't the hair of the older magical girl that saved Hane light-purple? And now so is Junna's new transformed version...

Yeah. I'm pretty convinced Junna is really the older magic girl. She probably just doesn't remember her past from before becoming an evil general.

Kazu-kun
10466e3de
joined Oct 25, 2014

I honestly dislike all these doujin that portray Kaguya and Yachiyo as separate entities. It's a gross misunderstanding of the movie.

The one in the Kaguya body is Yachiyo. And Yachiyo is Kaguya who ended up crash landing on Earth 8000 years ago. Kaguya and Yachiyo are one and the same. There is no one else.

last edited at Sep 27, 2026 8:50PM

10466e3de
joined Oct 25, 2014

Japanese publication seems to have stopped at chapter 5. There hasn't been any updates since April. Don't know if it was axed or it's just on hiatus.

10466e3de
joined Oct 25, 2014

First thing first, I don't think there's even a tiny chance that Junna will team up with her ex-colleague to fight Hane. That's not happening.

On another note, I still don't buy that Junna ISN'T the magical girl that saved Hane. I think she just doesn't remember. We know she doesn't seem to remember her life before she joined the bad guys.

last edited at Sep 14, 2026 1:28PM

10466e3de
joined Oct 25, 2014

「I'll let my soul be stained black if that's what it takes」

Poor Hane :( but hahaha, she slept hugged Junna for 3 hours and then apologized in dogeza, probably to hide her beat-red embarrassment. Also Hane's love language is hugging huh? I guess it's obvious upon rereading it but yeah, she do like hugs.

Now that I think about it though, upon rereading Chapter 1 because I wanted to check if her comment on "being the only one allowed to defeat Hane" has a double meaning on freeing her from the magical girl stuff but it seems ambiguous. I guess if I were to just read it at face value is that going by Chapter 1, Junna very much likes Hane, and is positively influenced by her but she is still seeking to regain her powers seemingly to get a rematch? Or maybe it's for something else? I guess old habits as a villain in a magical girl show dies hard even if it will likely be for love.

I wonder if it's less about freeing Hane from the magical girl stuff and more about freeing Hane from her self-hatred, though it doesn't seem like Junna is very aware of that. But it would be nice for Junna to reassure Hane that she isn't helpless and that she doesn't blame Hane for almost killing her - they were enemies after all.

It's not that simple, because Junna is also the magical girl who saved Hane's life. So Hane's guilt is way deeper than she lets on.

This situation probably won't be resolved until they open up to each other. Hane should tell Junna she was the little girl Junna saved in the past. Junna should tell Hane how she fell to the dark side. Then they can help heal each other.

10466e3de
joined Oct 25, 2014

Giftnova posted:

I really don't think the age thing is such a mystery? they already established Junna is a year older than Hana, why would they lie about that xD

And we already know that Junna used to be taller before Hana had her growth spurt too. Nothing we've seen contradicts any of that, i don' think?

yeah but they're only one year apart yet purple magical girl is gigantic compared to 6-7 year old hana

As Giftnova said, that's probably just the angle of the shot.

All in all, there's no reason to overthink this. Even Hana seems to believe Juna is the magical girl who saved her, which explains why she likes her so much.

I don't think it's just the framing just look at the size difference with their hands. Junna looks like her high school form while Hana looks much MUCH younger.

We know that Hana grew up a lot in just one year. And as for Juna, she actually looks a bit younger as a magical girl compared to her current self.

Besides, if Juna is not the magical girl, then all of Hana's odd behavior around Juna can NOT be explained. The reason Hana feels so guilty and why she hugged Juna and said she won't make the same mistake again. All of that makes sense ONLY if Juna is the magical girl.

10466e3de
joined Oct 25, 2014

Giftnova posted:

I really don't think the age thing is such a mystery? they already established Junna is a year older than Hana, why would they lie about that xD

And we already know that Junna used to be taller before Hana had her growth spurt too. Nothing we've seen contradicts any of that, i don' think?

yeah but they're only one year apart yet purple magical girl is gigantic compared to 6-7 year old hana

As Giftnova said, that's probably just the angle of the shot.

All in all, there's no reason to overthink this. Even Hana seems to believe Juna is the magical girl who saved her, which explains why she likes her so much, why she feels so guilty and why she hugged her while saying she won't make the same mistake again.

last edited at Aug 12, 2026 7:03PM

10466e3de
joined Oct 25, 2014

What if Junna defeated the older magical girl and took the charm and Hana's shock comes from realizing she wasn't able to protect that older magical girl?

If that were the case, Hana would hate Junna. But she loves her. That supports the idea that Junna is the older magical girl that saved her life.

last edited at Aug 12, 2026 4:26PM

10466e3de
joined Oct 25, 2014

It looks like everyone forgot that Utao is impervious to vampire charm. She could resist even Shirotae's charm, so of course Miu's charm would never work on her either. This is the reason the Chairman recruited her for this job to begin with.

Why she has this resistance to vampire charm hasn't been revealed yet.

last edited at May 3, 2026 6:52PM

Kazu-kun
10466e3de
joined Oct 25, 2014

i enjoy seeing the iroyachi takes, but there's something about kaguiro that tickles my fancy a lot

What I like about this movie is that there's only one pairing but it counts as two. lol Such a genius move.

last edited at Apr 11, 2026 9:17AM

Kazu-kun
Melody discussion 31 Mar 10:03
10466e3de
joined Oct 25, 2014

Is anyone else wondering why Iroha insisted on Kaguya appearing that age...?

There are two different Kaguya bodies during the ending. The one she awakens in which is the same teenage body she had when she spent the summer with Iroha ten years earlier, and an adult body that seems to match Iroha's age seen in the concert, the various photos on their kitchen table and in the Ray music video. This doujin and a lot of fanart prefer to go with the younger body anyway, which I get because it differentiates Kaguya and Yachiyo further.

The one who created Kaguyachiyo's body was Iroha, and she either made it so it could grow somehow, or she just makes a new body every few years to simulate Kaguyachiyo's growth.

last edited at Mar 31, 2026 10:05AM