Forum › Posts by Pyoro

Sena
joined Jun 27, 2017

Back on topic with the manga, Mari san could've seriously got mad in this chapter, I mean, I WOULD! like "YOU GOT TO TALK TO ME ABOUT STUFF LIKE THIS BEFORE YOU DO IT!" but I guess it doesn't fit the manga's mood.

Ya, I had a similar impression. Just felt a bit disrespectful, practically dismissing her partner's concerns and wishes ... buuuut, like you, I then decided it's just comedy, so whatever. ^^

Pyoro
Sena
joined Jun 27, 2017

The author’s notes indicate that they had come up with a very elaborate backstory as to how the world became the way that it is, but their editor axed it because it’d be too boring

I get that too many info dumbs are boring, but it takes a special mind to jump from there to "well, then we can only do rape to show this!" ^^;;;

Pyoro
Professor? discussion 15 May 05:54
Sena
joined Jun 27, 2017

The dialogue in this thing is genius. For example
"I'll fall for you." "What?" "Thanks."
Or
"Were you waiting for me?" "I'm going to kiss you for that." "Your lips seem pretty soft."
etc

last edited at May 15, 2018 5:54AM

Pyoro
Sena
joined Jun 27, 2017

Is statutory rape not a thing in Japan? Isn't this girl supposed to be in Middle School?

This topic has come up quite a lot in various topics here ^^;

Age of consent in Japan is 13. Then there's some other stipulations that depend on where you are, which could for example require a "serious relationship" (which could mean parental approval. Other countries have some similar cases, like Germany). So effectively it can often be 16 or 18.

Maybe that's why it's set somewhere in the middle of nowhere ... it's in 18 in Tokyo.

Pyoro
Sena
joined Jun 27, 2017

I don't know. I'm not yet buying that Kousaka is deliberately malicious. We'll see, I guess.

Pyoro
Smile Style discussion 14 May 05:03
Sena
joined Jun 27, 2017

Something about the style seems a little ... well. Unpolished, I suppose, to me.

But otherwise a fun enough first chapter.

Pyoro
Sena
joined Jun 27, 2017

Huh, didn't expect it to go there this quickly. Somehow, in mangas it's almost always "nothing ever happens" or "let's rush everything!"

Isn't it common in japan to have sex right away in the countryside? It's less to do and the more bored you are the more hands you hold.

It's actually a law. You can be banned to the cities if you refuse to do it.

Sena
joined Jun 27, 2017

I'm assuming it's taking the traditional white geisha make-up idea and taking it to extremes.Note they also made up their eyes in similar manner.

That was my first thought too, but going by his other stuff he's into ... clown paint? Well, I suppose that doesn't contradict that this one is geisha inspired ...

Don't really get what's particularly creepy about that, though. Can't say it does anything for me but out of the billion odd fetishes the Internet delivers this is a rare one that could actually be done irl with no harm to anyone ^^

Pyoro
Sena
joined Jun 27, 2017

I'd never thought the day would come that people in comments on Dynasty, would talk how they want more rape in their yuri story ;v

Why not? Rape is clearly the purest expression of yuri. Just imagine a world where everybody rapes everyone else ...

Pyoro
Sena
joined Jun 27, 2017

Well, it's Japanese. Everyone's an alcoholic there anyway #stereotypes

Anyway, just re-read the entire thing and came to the conclusion that after school/college they should just all move in together.

Pyoro
Sena
joined Jun 27, 2017

Why you so boring?

Well, it's what the chapter did to me ;) My impression was that she was fairly genuine about being nice - maybe a bit of a pervert - but I don't think she's some type of psycho character. I didn't get the impression that anything supernatural was going on either. And I don't expect some tense action/thriller/... messed up scenario.

So, yeah, I simply think the backstory is going to be something fairly mundane ^^

Pyoro
Sena
joined Jun 27, 2017

I'm bored, so I'll try and come up with some theories on the "what's the 30-year old single woman doing in this place and how is she supporting herself" question:
1. She's from some stuffy, rich family and after messing around with another woman/possibly women was essentially banished to the country-side.
2. She herself dated some older woman, and once her quasi-wife died, inherited the house and enough money to support herself.
3. She writes porn (or possible something else) and prefers doing so where rent is cheap.
4. She's sickly and somebody thought living in peace and quietude would help.
5. She's really into historical re-enactment and feels the countryside is closer to her ideal.
6. She's running from a violent husband and hiding out in that village.
7. She's a former idol/model/actress and moved to a place where nobody knows her.

Hm. I genuinely can't decide. Such mystery.

Pyoro
Sena
joined Jun 27, 2017

... suddenly, random exhibitionism.

Pyoro
1 x ½ discussion 09 May 06:14
Sena
joined Jun 27, 2017

Not ITF-8 compatible text document ... or maybe you are supposed to calculate the actual chapter number? If c = 2, h = ...

Pyoro
1 x ½ discussion 09 May 04:40
Sena
joined Jun 27, 2017

Ayako didn't seem particularly invested in her marriage, romantically, if that was her reaction to getting proposed, I have to say. Feels more like "goes along with the pushy guy because she can't be bothered to say no" ^^;

But the rest is pretty cute.

Pyoro
Sena
joined Jun 27, 2017

Author gets brownie points for at least having put some thought into the nitty-gritty of the matter instead of just handwaving it.

To be honest this is one of those cases where I feel handwaving might have been a better idea (see: midi-chlorians). But I haven't quite decided yet. I guess it depends on what's done with these ... mechanics.

Pyoro
Saki discussion 08 May 06:35
Sena
joined Jun 27, 2017

... goes polish every floor meticulously
I'm inspired.

Sena
joined Jun 27, 2017

Always struck me as quite telling that a relationship where neither partner has to do anything beyond being "the fated one" is considered to be more romantic than one where the partners actually have to work for their love ...

Sena
joined Jun 27, 2017

And since when do comedy manga ever "go anywhere"?

That's what so many of them get wrong and why for example Majyo to Houki to Kurobuchi Megane is so brilliantly awesome.

Pyoro
Sena
joined Jun 27, 2017

Boob-overhang panels are a travesty and should be illegal.

Sena
joined Jun 27, 2017

Flawless victory.

Pyoro
Sena
joined Jun 27, 2017

The art style is so pretty! and I love that the author is obsessed with flowers.
I like the idea of a world only inhabited by women, if only because it serves as a guarantee that none of the characters will end up trapped in an impromptu "no homo" het ending lol

There are a bunch of those novels around ... more often than not they are about a male being born / created / etc and the tension this causes.

So, no, even with stories that seemingly don't even offer any possibility of het there's no safety ^^

Pyoro
Tapestry discussion 04 May 11:11
Sena
joined Jun 27, 2017

Agreed. Humans are creatures of routine. No doubt immortals would get bored with some things and annoyed with others, but if you enjoy a nice cup of coffee on a mellow spring day for half a century there's really no reason why you wouldn't do that for ten centuries, too ...

So can anyone explain why "Tapestry"...?
I can't seem to connect it to the story. Just thinking of a textile variant like "veil" as in Maggie keeps on "hiding her real self" but what do you think...

Tapestries were often used to record stories or memories so sometimes they are used as symbol for remembrance and such in fiction; I'd personally have suspected that the title comes from that direction, but, who knows ...

e: also page 2 has a bit of an explanation in the top panel ^^

last edited at May 4, 2018 11:13AM

Pyoro
Tapestry discussion 04 May 06:34
Sena
joined Jun 27, 2017

Forgetting regularly is the only viable type of immortality.

Because otherwise, the weight of memories becomes unbearable and you'd become insane.

I think a "normal memory" as everyone else has is perfectly sufficient. I know it's part of the immortality trope that it comes with thís downside of being sometimes more and sometimes less depressing because everybody else dies, but if I ie look at my great-grandmother who died at 95 and had lost literally everyone in her life expect for the younger generations and even there not all of them, then how's that different from the typical "immortal"? She certainly didn't go insane with grief.

People die, you are sad, and then you move on. It's perfectly possible for a human to cope with that with no special mechanism involved ^^;

Pyoro
1 x ½ discussion 04 May 03:07
Sena
joined Jun 27, 2017

That's no theory, that's at best wild speculation. And you can do that sort of thing for any manga as nothing about it is verifiable or even relies much on anything that actually happens in the plot ^^