Forum › Posts by grinseb
I think this should not be looked into too much. Imo it's just harem housou with drama =))) And it's not like the characters are dynamics or anything. The author just wanna tell a harem housou story with some spice and fetishes, that's all there is to this actually.
Even if you consider the drama, it's not a really compelling story. Well, the drama is just an excuse for the harem anw.
I hate how she said she was a virgin. You are clearly having sex with your girlfriend so you are indeed not a virgin -_- to think you need a penis or anything phallic shaped to lose your virginity is absolutely insane
This is old so the mangaka might had some misconceptions, the topic wasn't really discussed into at that time anw.
All in all this one is nice, good moral cute lesbians what not to like?
I know that I'm probably gonna get hate for this, but I always like to think the doujin aren't related to the anime. It's not the hymen part that gets me tbh. It's just... ...the incest
That is exactly how I feel too. The incest makes it disturbing and sickening.
We just crave for something different from the typical schoolgirl characters and the typical school settings that are overflowing the genre. That's pretty much why Tamamisu's stories are interesting, with adult characters and awkward, odd pairings/ situations.
Can't say anything about this one if this is the ending though. There was no conclusion, I guess I'll wait for a sequel, or just put it away from my mind.
I can't really disagree with transbikes's caution. I've seen enough stuff on trans and other issues in manga to trust the average manga author to understand the issue they're talking about enough to present it well. Now as neversung said, early signs are good that they know what they're talking about. But I've been burned on stuff like that before, so I'm taking a wait-and-see attitude.
My personal caution is based on authors typically only having a cursory knowledge of their subject and filling in the blanks with assumptions. I'm hopeful that won't be the case here.
Sound like a good strategy to go around this one. I've known enough how hyping and expecting too much can ruin everything for one's enjoyment. This seem worth following and all, but keeping a level head and having no expectation is really the right way to go.
I get the appeal of this kind of relationship, all's good in fantasy.
I really like the first page, that's pretty stunning tbh. But if there were less close-up panels, it would be better. I can't really tell who from who in those panels and they just looks awkward in the pages.
Judge for yourself. Here's an easy link for the raw.
I cried.
So the verdict was....?
It's pretty grim. The MC and her BFF exchange good luck charms. MC gets raped by someone who asks her for directions. Afterwards, MC looks at her own 'filthy hands' when touching her BFF, which causes her to break from her BFF out of self-disgust / time skip / MC drops out of school and works as a call girl. One day, she sees her BFF, healthy and happy with the good luck charm. MC cries because the good luck charm she made, while she was still her 'true self', is by her BFF to this day. The ending's a little amiguous, as to whether the sight has pulled her back up, or permanently confirmed the division between her 'broken self' and her 'true self'. The last words are 'Thank You'. There's a little bit of elision/interpretation on my part, but the one thing I can definitely say is that I wouldn't read it last thing at night if you're feeling blue.
I originally don't wanna ruin the thrill of having your hopes on edge and then regain them and feel fucking happy. But now it looks like ppl are plotting a master troll plan or sth, and I enjoy the trolls =)))
Judge for yourself. Here's an easy link for the raw.
I cried.
Sadly, the author's next work is darker and guess what, she got raped forcefully by men at night (that's the truth). The ending is bad. You can check it in yuri project. I'll choose to abandon it.
I guess some congratulations are in order, since you succesfully baited me into looking. WP.
So it's not true?? I deleted my comment because I thought it was false hope. It's not true right? I can't find the sequel in question.
[...] and finally get to do their tribalism the right way.
They do... what? Sorry, couldn't resist.
=))) I meant "tribadism". But hey, there are tribes with lesbian rituals, right?
Yup, lesbian sex is definitely one of the requirements to be a true princess.
I somehow liked this. It's actually pretty tamed for a rape porn, but why can't it be more like this: http://dynasty-scans.com/chapters/if
last edited at Mar 5, 2016 4:57PM
Asami turned from being cocky to downright asshole level... How can it even be? Minato has some interesting problems and places for character developments, but a drama like this is definitely not the solution. Later on, she just seems bland and typical shoujo girl.
I'm really tired of this cheesy "girl refuse but think over when got ignored", and also how horribly quick a seemingly straight girl turns into a lesbian after forced sexual encounter...
Aren't they both vocaloids yet Miku called Luka "human" in the first page?
?_?
Probably because it's an alternate universe where Luka is a song writer and Miku is still a vocaloid.
Anyway, this version of Miku and Luka's relationship always makes me feel good. If only there was a conclusion to the problem at hand, but I'm content with what was given.
Considering what you just said boils down to "I liked Penny, she's dead, I'm mad and don't care anymore" I think its safe to say nothing you just said was true. You can have your opinion but don't go around acting like its absolute fact.
Nah, don't go guessing things just because I have Penny as my avatar and joked about it. Since you gave me motivation to talk some more about the show. Here you are.
Well and you said you were absolutely crazy about Penny. Don't forget that.
Hey, that's the joke =))) The sentence means that the only way someone can feel for Penny is if they like her just because a dumb one liner, which is why I like her, which is dumb. I guess it's my bad since the joke was too personal. Well joke on me then.
Let me make it clear, I don't care for Penny's death enough to shit on a show. I'm not that irrational. I was just pointing out the plot holes in the show. So it would be nice if we don't get personal and just regard each other's opinion as it is.
It's a fact that Ruby didn't know how Neo's umbrella works. She just pushed a random button and it sent Neo flying, it could be the button that activates Neo's umbrella to shoot or stab her right in the face. Ruby got out of it because, well, luck (and plot armor).
...Its an umbrella. It isn't hard to figure out.
You didn't really explain anything here. This umbrella is also Neo's weapon, which we saw in last ss how dangerous it can be. Ruby still use her guess, and Neo lost. One of the cliffhangers last ep built up was destroyed by a ridiculous resolve.
It's a fact that there is no explanation to why Ruby knew the ship which Neo and Roman was in. She just went to that exact ship deliberately. And it was a jackpot, because luck \ (^o^) /
There was literally one one military ship left cause Roman and Neo had destroyed all the others.
No, there was the White Fang's ship too.
It's a fact that Ruby== killed off a mighty Grimm with a kick strong enough to change its flying direction, when she was on air, with no stable stance.==
Wait, so out of all the crazy shit on this show, thats what bugs you. Alright now I know your just nitpicking.
Excusing a flaw by saying the show is crazy isn't valid, because up until that point the show was very carefull with its action scenes. The characters always have proper stance to use forces and the impact they leave are logical. RWBY's charm is its action, so when an action scene with the cost of Ruby's life on the line was played out that badly, I have reason to be disappointed.
It's a fact that Jame's military system is super easy to hack into, despite him trusting it so much.
That's cause they didn't hack anything, they just boarded his ship and connected to an open terminal. I actually can't really blame you for this one cause thinking that taking over a computer requires "L33t Hakzor skillz" instead of just "find a PC that someone forgot to secure properly" is probably one the most common misconceptions about computing.
The computer would have a protection program, like most did. They would have to break through it. And since it's from the military, someone forgeting to secure the system, risking the robot going off killing people is unlikely. Cinder even had control over all of the news system. It's really convenient for the villains.
It's a fact that Adam didn't slice Yang in half even though he could do so easily.
He explicitly states he wants to torture her. Can't torture a dead girl.
He said he wanted to destroyed everything Blake loved, starting with Yang. He said destroyed Yang, not tortured her.
It's a fact that Adam's motivation went from revolution to torture Blake. What was he doing there with her when he should be out leading the White Fang?
He was established from the moment he was introduced to be a fanatic and extremist. People like that don't let go easily. You leave or betray them, even for good reasons and they'll move hell and high water to come get you and hurt you.
No, he wasn't established like that. He barely said anything that clearly show his personality (beside hating humans and crazy about revolution) up until the time he met Blake. Last time we saw him, he didn't seem that crazy about Blake when he tell his goons to "Forget it" and putting his revolution plan on first.
It's a fact that Yang getting disarm didn't serve as her character development, or Blake's, but just so we can have lots and lots of puns.
It fits her character perfectly. She's a deconstruction of "manly aggressive" anime characters who charge in and attack people head on. What happened to her is simply what realistically would happen to someone who resolves every problem with "punching things". Sooner or later, you run into someone who you can't deal with by punching them, as seen when she gets framed by Cinder, Emerald and Mercury or when Adam mutilates her.
And what puns? The show never treats her wounds as anything less than serious. The puns I've heard have come from the fandom.
It isn't a deconstruction. What Yang did was trying to protect her friend, it's perfectly reasonable for her to barge in since she didn't know how strong Adam was and was really worried about Blake. The show can't cut off her arm because she did the right thing. It would be a deconstruction if Yang did something wrong by rushing into it without thinking. But as you can see, it wasn't, so the suffering Yang get was unreasonable for her, and didn't serve any purpose beside feels for fans.
The puns part was a joke about the fandom overflowing with arms puns.
It's a fact that Mercury showed himself in front of Ruby for no reason. Cinder doesn't even seem to care about Ruby, why did he do that is unexplained, it just happened.
...Cause he's an narcissistic ASSHOLE. Well, that and with Cinder's plan already in motion, its not like Ruby could stop it.
He was ordered by Cinder herself to stay low, and he resisted the order (which is out of character for him) just to scare Ruby and then did nothing to her when she was completely defenseless in front of him. He just left her there and went away. Why he showed up, risking Cinder's anger? No explanation.
None of the main characters get anywhere in vol.3. Yang still got her anger problem, Blake just got more mental torture and Weiss's problem is unresolved, Ruby don't even have a flaw. And the cliffhangers get really bad resolve in the form of deus ex mechina
Yang went from a proud, happy aggressive girl to basically a shell shocked war vet with PTSD, Weiss has continuously gotten less bitchy as the show has gone on to the point were she was willing to sacrifice herself to save Velvet. We also got to see her interact with her sister and after a fair bit of effort she finally managed to summon. Blake is still being all "Blakey", yes but now we now more about her past and also that she really does care about Yang. Like, a lot. And Ruby does have a flaw. She thinks she can save everyone. I'm just going to ignore your cliffhanger comment, as by definition cliffhangers don't resolve anything, so therefore your comment on "cliffhangers, bad resolve and deus ex machina" is irrelevant.
Becoming sadder isn't a character development, Yang didn't learn about thinking up ahead.
Weiss's problem in my book is her insecurity and her pride getting over her decisions (which the show didn't really touch in vol3). Being bitchy wasn't really her problem, but more like her gimmick. She just got new problem about summoning stuff. Nonetheless, I should have gave more details about Weiss here. If her summoning was her problem to you, then Weiss is ok. But since I liked RWBY, I expected more.
Blake's past in vol3 was all we have already know, she's with the White Fang, did missions with Adam, etc. Her caring about Yang isn't a character development though, it's not about her personality, it's about the shipping.
On Ruby's case, saving everyone is a good belief and can't be considered a flaw. It's a heroic trait. Unless she is acting all crazy about saving people, even if they don't need her help or something.
Cliffhangers are thrilling situations happening when the ep end. What I meant is that the cliffhangers at the end of an episode didn't get good resolves. The dangerous situations were solved by deus ex machina.
It's weird how you accused me of shitting on the show for petty reason like that. Since I no longer have any feels for RWBY and its characters. The execution got rushed, everything was convenient for the protag and it was trying to hard to dig out the feel from fans, even though it means risking logic and pacing.
You are shitting on this show for petty reasons, half the shit on this list is just pointless nitpicking.
Look RWBY is far from perfect but doesn't mean you get to go around being dick about. Don't spread your opinion like its absolute fact and don't try discourage people who take an interest in the show simply because somewhere along the lines you decided you didn't like it anymore.
Maybe you didn't like it when Penny dies or maybe you really are as nitpicky and irrational as this list or yours suggests. I really don't care either way. Just stop being such a dick about it. Just say you disagree with where the show is going and leave it at that.And I know you disagree with the way the show is going but others may not and they may not be finished watching the show so spoiler tag you shit.
Yeah, it's my fault for forgetting the spoiler, I'll go fix that up. I thought disarm can cover the spoiler since noone outside the fandom can really know what it means.
And I don't see what is the problem with warning people about what they would get out of this show, my list is backed with the scenes from the show. It's what happened on the screen.
My words are by no means full of rage. They are perfectly thoughtout and rational. Why I even listed all this was because you told me that I "liked Penny, she's dead, I'm mad and don't care anymore" and therefore nothing I said was true. I wanted to prove that I'm a rational person and should clarify why I said that, then I listed the flaws.
I see that you insulted me a lot. I don't insult you one bit, you know.
Anyway, I think I won't ever comment on this again. I have said all I need to say. This will be considered spam eventually so whatever is ok.
By the way, you are wrong all along because my one true love is Cinder Fall, the one and only. And I ship her with Penny (^o^)/
last edited at Feb 22, 2016 1:57PM
Considering what you just said boils down to "I liked Penny, she's dead, I'm mad and don't care anymore" I think its safe to say nothing you just said was true. You can have your opinion but don't go around acting like its absolute fact.
Nah, don't go guessing things just because I have Penny as my avatar and joked about it. Since you gave me motivation to talk some more about the show. Here you are.
It's a fact that Ruby didn't know how Neo's umbrella works. She just pushed a random button and it sent Neo flying, it could be the button that activates Neo's umbrella to shoot or stab her right in the face. Ruby got out of it because, well, luck (and plot armor).
It's a fact that there is no explanation to why Ruby knew the ship which Neo and Roman was in. She just went to that exact ship deliberately. And it was a jackpot, because luck \ (^o^) /
It's a fact that Ruby killed off a mighty Grimm with a kick strong enough to change its flying direction, when she was on air, with no stable stance.
It's a fact that Jame's military system is super easy to hack into, despite him trusting it so much.
It's a fact that Adam didn't slice Yang in half even though he could do so easily.
It's a fact that Adam's motivation went from revolution to torture Blake. What was he doing there with her when he should be out leading the White Fang?
It's a fact that Yang getting disarm didn't serve as her character development, or Blake's, but just so we can have lots and lots of puns.
It's a fact that Mercury showed himself in front of Ruby for no reason. Cinder doesn't even seem to care about Ruby, why did he do that is unexplained, it just happened.
None of the main characters get anywhere in vol.3. Yang still got her anger problem, Blake just got more mental torture and Weiss's problem is unresolved, Ruby don't even have a flaw. And the cliffhangers get really bad resolve in the form of deus ex mechina.
It's weird how you accused me of shitting on the show for petty reason like that. Since I no longer have any feels for RWBY and its characters. The execution got rushed, everything was convenient for the protag and it was trying to hard to dig out the feel from fans, even though it means risking logic and pacing.
last edited at Feb 22, 2016 1:51PM
It's okay to have personal opinion regarding vol 3, but I saw people complaining about it since the very beginning, even about the opening saying "The absence of Monty is obvious" when it we were told that he gave instruction to keep ahead long ago so...I don't get it.
it got kind of better in the later episodes, and i LOVED the dark turn of the show, but... everyone else didn't? if anything, it made the show worth while in my opinion.
It's not about the dark turn or Monty left that causes people (or me in particular) to dislike vol.3, it's just that the show got bad.
It's how Ruby has plot armor and how everything is solved with deus ex machina. And they should have waited until the characters and their relationships are properly developed before throwing them on the line for cheap thrill. How could viewers truly worry for Penny or sympathize with Ruby losing her friend properly when all the time they see the two together are just, like, 3 scenes? Unless you are crazy for Penny like me, but that doesn't excuse the poor execution. They really rushed it and it turns sour.
Please, don't discourage potential new fans into the series just because you didn't like the latest chapters, and less if you're most probably going to watch vol 4 too.
I just spoke my opinions, ppl are cool enough to decide on their own. And what I said, sadly, is true about the show.