Forum › Posts by White Rose

White%20rose%20index
joined Aug 16, 2018

I hope little bro can find himself a nice boyfriend by the end of the series.

Indeed

There are already two candidates. Maybe you don't remember them, because their only appearance came in the beginning of chapter 1... but it's transparently obvious that they are both crazy for Futaba. And who wouldn't, right? He's so cute, honest and girly. (灬 ͡♥ 3 ͡♥灬)

The first one is a sporty boy, strong, mischievous, energetic and a total tsundere:

https://dynasty-scans.com/chapters/ill_cheer_on_my_yuri_onee_chan_ch01#5

The second one is smart, polite, adult-like for his age, and a typical "nice boy" all around:

https://dynasty-scans.com/chapters/ill_cheer_on_my_yuri_onee_chan_ch01#6

Were you in Futaba's shoes, who would you choose? ・:*:・゚( ͡ºั ͜ʖ ͡ºั )。・:*:・゚

Out of those two I feel like Sui is the stronger candidate, though I'm not quite certain Sui is a boy, has that gender ambiguous look.

Oh? I hadn't considered that. You may be right. Sui has an androgynous look and an androgynous name. Could be a tomboyish girl...

Although, taking everything into account, I think I'd like it better if what we have here is the typical shoujo manga choice between classic standard boy-types. :P

White Rose
White%20rose%20index
joined Aug 16, 2018

Ah, this was a good one. The mom looks much better and prettier with her hair tied-up.

Don't be fooled! It's a trick!

Okaasan revealed her true Sadako nature when she started cooking.

White%20rose%20index
joined Aug 16, 2018

I hope little bro can find himself a nice boyfriend by the end of the series.

Indeed

There are already two candidates. Maybe you don't remember them, because their only appearance came in the beginning of chapter 1... but it's transparently obvious that they are both crazy for Futaba. And who wouldn't, right? He's so cute, honest and girly. (灬 ͡♥ 3 ͡♥灬)

The first one is a sporty boy, strong, mischievous, energetic and a total tsundere:

https://dynasty-scans.com/chapters/ill_cheer_on_my_yuri_onee_chan_ch01#5

The second one is smart, polite, adult-like for his age, and a typical "nice boy" all around:

https://dynasty-scans.com/chapters/ill_cheer_on_my_yuri_onee_chan_ch01#6

Were you in Futaba's shoes, who would you choose? ・:*:・゚( ͡ºั ͜ʖ ͡ºั )。・:*:・゚

White Rose
Image Comments 16 Jun 00:55
White%20rose%20index
joined Aug 16, 2018
D7xffnduiaabekw-orig

^ Those are conclusive arguments. I have been convinced.

White Rose
White%20rose%20index
joined Aug 16, 2018

I feel so bad for the younger girl, even though did the do with the wife. Its shown that she's accidentally drawn to these people and have always ended up doing the do with married women. She actively has methods to avoid these women but still got stuck being attracted to the wife.

Younger girl? Oh? You caught my attention there.

Y'see, all this time, I was of the impression that Akari was the older one.

We can only guess, of course, as, even though we know Ayano is 35, we are never told Akari's exact age. But my guess was that they were very close in age, with Akari being slightly older.

My reasons? Well, mostly little details, like in chapter 2, page 13 - Akari: "I thought I'd found some sweet, innocent girl and seduced her." So Akari seemingly thought Ayano was the naive younger one in the couple?

In point of fact, she does act most of the time like she's way more experienced, and talks like she has a long history of broken romances behind her.

What makes you think Akari is younger? The difference in jobs?

White Rose
White%20rose%20index
joined Aug 16, 2018

Yeaaaaah okay you all if you like yuri with likeable girls in a relationship then drop this series. Cheaters are the absolute worst human beings and Ayano, one of the girls in the yuri pairing of this manga, is just a shameless cheater, while the other girl, Akari, who is honest and sincere, falls for this terrible person anyway. And then she decides she doesn't mind the infidelity of the skank and wants to keep having secret encounters with her anyway and it blows.

I guess it's time for you to stop reading this manga, then, and move on to stories that don't have the 'cheating' tag
The tags are not there just for show, ya know, they're supposed to be there to help you detect the themes & tropes you like and don't like, and dodge the stories you can tell from the start you won't enjoy

I can't believe that when we're finally done arguing, in another manga thread, against some guys who hate Age gap and all manga that feature it... now I come here to find people who hate Cheating and are damning this manga to hell. >_< It's like we are overrun by angry zealots who keep bashing every new series in the Dynasty reader to promote their particular brand of political correction! ʕ ͡° ʖ̯ ͡° ʔノ︵┻┻

One wonders what's the fun in constantly writing rants against stuff you dislike... you'd think fandom should be about finding something you like and enjoying it together with other persons who share your taste...

Look at the tags, for Pete's sake, and, if you don't like what you see, do yourself a favor and don't read that manga! Save yourselves a lot of time and angst...

last edited at Jun 15, 2019 7:15PM

White Rose
Image Comments 14 Jun 23:40
White%20rose%20index
joined Aug 16, 2018
75222281_p1

For a fraction of a second, I thought Yuu was a mermaid, lol.

That's because her swimsuit bottom kinda looked like fish scales. :P

White Rose
Image Comments 14 Jun 22:57
White%20rose%20index
joined Aug 16, 2018
D8yujatueaawfi8-orig

Aww, surprised Tifa is moe.

White%20rose%20index
joined Aug 16, 2018

Every time I look at Marika, I wonder if she was the most popular girl in her class in HetWorld (before her transfer to YuriWorld).

I mean, look at those boobs!!! (˵ ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°˵)~♡・゚:*✧

White%20rose%20index
joined Aug 16, 2018

Hahaha when I saw the ch3 in spanish I thought "Oh no, Dynasty won't survive this cuteness"

Hehe, you and me both. I just LUV seeing the effects of extreme cuteness on the readers, as reflected on the comments.

That said, in this chapter, Aki turns out to be... not so cute. >_< When I read it in Spanish, I thought: wait, she knew about the "misunderstanding" and didn't tell Yori, WTF??? And then it turns out it was because she thought it would be more fun to shut up and watch the crash. The English translation confirms it. Why that little...! Grr. Talk about a pal.( ͡ಠ ʖ̯ ͡ಠ)

White Rose
White%20rose%20index
joined Aug 16, 2018

This story reminds me of "Instinct and a Chromosome", a really good manga I read 10 years ago. Maybe some of you remember it, too.

"Instinct and a Chromosome" is a 60-page oneshot about a lesbian girl in a relationship with a bisexual woman. I won't tell too much, but, in a nutshell: they are living happily together, then they break up because the bisexual lady decides she wants to marry a man and have children, then they get together again because this lady realizes her lesbian girlfriend is the one she really loves after all. The reactions in the comments were surprisingly similar to the reactions here: there was a lot of hate against Bi Girl (for pulling that shit and hurting her gf ) and a good deal of disapproval against Lez Girl (for accepting again the other chick after what she did ). Even though the conclusion was supposed to be a happy end, readers weren't very happy with what had transpired.

I'm seeing the same patterns in the comments here. Ayano and Akari start dating, yay! Ayano is married with a man, boo! Ayano wants to continue her affair with Akari, hurr?

If Ayano ever dumps and divorces her husband to be with Akari, we will have completed the circle! (ง͠° ͜ʖ ͡°)ง

last edited at Jun 14, 2019 11:31PM

White Rose
White%20rose%20index
joined Aug 16, 2018

(psst you prob shouldn't accuse people of being passive-aggressive and then immediately say you'd report them to the mods if you weren't such a nice person)

Lmao don't try to reason with BugDevil, she won't listen. It ain't her thing.

If she annoys you, just stop paying attention to her.

last edited at Jun 14, 2019 11:27PM

White%20rose%20index
joined Aug 16, 2018

I'm not sure if this is considered appropriate to discuss here, so if it isn't just feel free to remove my comment, but I found the typesetting/translation of pages 21 and 22 to be a little awkward.

First, it's strange that her friends lead with "Thi?" Yori isn't the first one to say this; Aki is. "Thi?" or even "think" seems to come out of nowhere here.

As you can see in the raw Japanese:

https://i.imgur.com/neKUDi5.png

What her friends are actually saying is "su?" They aren't exactly trying to prompt Yori to finish a sentence she had partially began, at least not in the sense that they had some clue to what she was going to say next, but rather they are coercing her to say "suki" or in English, "I like her", the articulation of which is suggested by Aki herself. To me, this makes much more sense, because her friends are trying to insinuate that she likes the girl, not that she thinks that she likes the girl, which would be a somewhat strange thing to insinuate in the first place.

Then, when Yori actually says it, "suki" is alone in the first, large bubble, and it is followed by "kamo" in the second, smaller bubble. This puts emphasis on the "I like her" part of her sentence, and adds the "maybe" or "I think" part as a trailing afterthought. It's subtle, but I feel like it slightly affects the impact of the scene. If I were to translate it myself, I would have done something like have Aki say, "I? Li...?" followed by the other two girls saying "Li-?" and finally have the first bubble from Yori say, "Like her..." followed by the smaller bubble with smaller text say, "maybe..."

Again, I'm not sure if this is considered appropriate or on topic discussion, so if it isn't I apologize. The only reason I brought it up is because I recently took an interest to how the typesetting and formatting of manga/comic layouts affects the dramatization or comedy of scenes, and found this to be an interesting example of those subtleties that may go unnoticed, so I thought I would leave some constructive feedback. Either way, I'm grateful to the scanlators for the work they do, but find this kind of topic interesting, so I just wanted to throw in my two cents.

This is 100% on topic and not only that: also an extremely interesting contribution to the discussion. Thank you! d( ͡^ ͜ʖ ͡^)b

I mentioned before that I have read up to chapter 4 in Spanish. Well, the Spanish scanlators (team Rainy Devil) did a perfect job of translating that bit. When Yori's three friends demand that Yori speaks out loud her feelings for Himari and Yori starts stammering, it goes on like this:
Yori: "No... a mí... pues..." (In English: No... I... err...)
Aki: "¿A tí qué? ¿Te gus...?" (In English: You what? You li...?)
Mari: "¿Te gus...?" (In English: You li...?)
Kaori: "¿Te gus...?" (In English: You li...?)
Yori: "Me gus..." (In English: I li...)

Then, when Yori actually says it, "Me gusta..." (I like her...) is alone in the first, large bubble, and it is followed by "Creo..." (I think...) in the second, smaller bubble.

Which is exactly what you said was the correct, literal way of translating Yori's words.

White%20rose%20index
joined Aug 16, 2018

I think the definition of love will be a major focal point of the manga. I predict that different characters will have different perspectives on and definitions for love.

As one who has read up to chapter 4, I can vouch that your prediction is dead on. ^^

Coming next, different perspectives on and definitions for "going on a date."

White%20rose%20index
joined Aug 16, 2018

Chapter 2 was quickly released so I hope thext few are the same

Just yesterday, I read the first 4 chapters in Spanish. v(^.^)v I reckon the English versions will be here very soon.

And, really, Himari is dense.

White%20rose%20index
joined Aug 16, 2018

When I heard that the band's name was SS Girls, I was really surprised.

I kinda expected 'em to look like this:

¯⧹_(⁰͡ ͜ʖ⁰͡ )_⧸¯

last edited at Jun 11, 2019 12:00PM

White%20rose%20index
joined Aug 16, 2018

This needs to end in a glorious foursome. Maybe even fivesome with the mother.

That one's been done already. They call it: F³ ~ Frantic, Frustrated & Female

White Rose
Image Comments 08 Jun 16:30
White%20rose%20index
joined Aug 16, 2018
43744009_p0

@GrimEater, you are so right, lol. The OGs of the Yuri Gang!
Everyone, respect!

White Rose
Image Comments 08 Jun 16:28
White%20rose%20index
joined Aug 16, 2018
Pokeball

Fastest ship ever, or close.

White Rose
White%20rose%20index
joined Aug 16, 2018

The lesson here is that you've been too quick to apply an an unwarranted homophobic interpretation to lines that actually have a perfectly fine sentiment. She is talking about how even feelings that at the time were about missing out can be looked back on and appreciated.

Aah so that's her angle... I see... my interpretation of the dialogue was linear and literal, so I missed the implied jump of meaning...

In my defense, it really was an ambiguous way of wording it. :P

White Rose
White%20rose%20index
joined Aug 16, 2018

^Hard mode: drink once for every SFX in the background.

Just chug the whole bottle now, it will save time. ^_~

White Rose
White%20rose%20index
joined Aug 16, 2018

There was a strip that left me kinda confused.

When Haruko tells the teacher about her feelings of wanting to be with Natsuko, the teacher replies that "when you grow up, those feelings will all become good memories" (of her youth).

Now, I may be mistaken, but aren't those the exact words people normally use to tell a girl that her crush on another girl is just a phase and that she will grow out of it?

But that teacher is, of all the characters, the one person who knows better... so it can't be that... ┐( ? ʖ̯ ?)┌

White Rose
White%20rose%20index
joined Aug 16, 2018

I recommend that all who want to question the ethics of the 'age gap' trope just go read the 21 pages of discussion for that story:
https://dynasty-scans.com/forum/topics/13833-kimi-wa-shoujo-discussion

You'll see, all the arguments are already there :)

Alternatively they could just stop reading the stories tagged Age gap (since they already know they don't like the trope).

White Rose
White%20rose%20index
joined Aug 16, 2018

Looking at it from a scientific pov, we should all agree on this:

Puberty is nature's way of telling you that you are ready for sex.

Everything else is arbitrary social convention.

White Rose
White%20rose%20index
joined Aug 16, 2018

Me encanta este tipo de historias!! Es tan dulce y bonitooooo. Me gustan los personajes~

Jeje, estoy contigo en eso. Estos dos personajes son adorables...