Forum › Posts by luinthoron

luinthoron
Image Comments 27 Jul 05:18
Ykn1
joined Dec 20, 2018
91427309_p0

Nice. ^_^

luinthoron
Image Comments 27 Jul 05:16
Ykn1
joined Dec 20, 2018
E7mocbwvgai4y7n-orig

Nice. ^_^

luinthoron
Image Comments 27 Jul 05:15
Ykn1
joined Dec 20, 2018
46887216_p0

Lovely. ^_^

luinthoron
Image Comments 27 Jul 05:15
Ykn1
joined Dec 20, 2018
E6wjx3duuamvkk--orig

Yes.

luinthoron
Image Comments 27 Jul 05:14
Ykn1
joined Dec 20, 2018
1418856095129292800

Exactly. :D

luinthoron
Image Comments 27 Jul 05:13
Ykn1
joined Dec 20, 2018
Dva-oxlwsaiuqvq-orig

Nice.

luinthoron
Image Comments 27 Jul 05:13
Ykn1
joined Dec 20, 2018
78042859_p0

Cute.

luinthoron
Image Comments 27 Jul 05:12
Ykn1
joined Dec 20, 2018
Kruuqb5

Nice.

luinthoron
Image Comments 27 Jul 05:12
Ykn1
joined Dec 20, 2018
75447889_p4

Something's fishy about this...

Cute.

luinthoron
Sisters discussion 27 Jul 04:36
Ykn1
joined Dec 20, 2018

That sure escalated...

luinthoron
Ykn1
joined Dec 20, 2018

Less panic than I expected from getting naked after that doujin, but I guess the previous experience from bathing together helped.

Ranbara... Well, you're not strictly wrong, but you'll certainly never be as close as Sakurako is. Now let's see whether they'll flirt enough for her to realize this next... :D

Ykn1
joined Dec 20, 2018

Always nice to see a fox.

Ykn1
joined Dec 20, 2018

Cute.

luinthoron
Ykn1
joined Dec 20, 2018

That begs the question of how exactly does a non-specialist differentiate elemental tungsten from, say, elemental tantalum in her imagination. I somehow doubt that she's picturing nuclear structures and electron shells...

I guess it's just her imagining the material's properties known to her and magic doing the rest. It's not all that different from imagining a "rock" for usual earth element magic without going deeper into its composition, or for that matter a water mage summoning water without knowing anything about its chemical composition.

uh... pretty sure Wolfram is Tungsten, not Tungsten Carbide.

That mistake did hurt my brain, yes.

luinthoron
Ykn1
joined Dec 20, 2018

One would assume that, as usual, mages simply summon/create their respective elements. Less noticeable with air users or earth users who create walls like that, possible even to explain away with water and fire to an extent, but certainly noticeable at the very least with earth type projectiles. Well, never a good idea to think too much about most magic systems in any case.

Indeed, as long as specific chemical elements aren't a plot point, I have no trouble switching my brain off and enjoying the fireworks. But in this instance, Rei specifically lampshades that she is using advanced technical knowledge from modern Japan (why does an ex-office lady know so much about metallurgy, by the way?), so the author has deliberately brought real-world chemistry into their magic system and willingly invited a critical examination thereof.

She does know a bit more than one would expect from a dead OL, yes, although I suppose it could have featured in one of her games... On the other hand, this also may explain why she can do something others can't - most mages can only imagine the magic elements as what they know them as, while she uses her advanced knowledge to use specific materials covered by that element.

luinthoron
Ykn1
joined Dec 20, 2018

Favourite moment was Relaire joining in with the Princes doing their Rei impression.

This, absolutely. :D

Relaire has had a lot of funny little background gags in the manga that never would have been possible in the LN

Definitely. I already declared Relaire one of the best parts of the previous chapter as well. :D

I loved the part where she made the tungsten carbine walls. In the novel she also makes bullets to take out the fire balls is I remember. She could revolutionize the whole kingdom right there with making that stuff. Make furnaces out t and walls that no monster or enemy could break through, Tools, weapons and just so many more.

I was actually kinda bothered by that moment. Because as long as they just stick to the Aristotelian four elements as the base of their magic system, I am fine with not looking too deeply into it, but once Rei starts pulling composite alloys out of her ass, I am starting to have questions. For instance, tungsten is a rare metal on Earth, but Rei is able to haul at least a ton of it out of the floor of the arena -- does this mean the arena is composed of chunks of rare metals (and if so, which ones?), does a geode of a tungsten-rich ore just happen to run under it, or is tungsten just naturally abundant in this universe? Or, the most heretical thought: do Rei's earth-based powers just let her nucleosynthesize tons of precious metals on a whim? If so, can she also synthesize gold, like a living Philosophers Stone? If so, is this capacity unique to her? If not, what does the society use as the monetary standard instead of precious metals?

Circling back to the alloy, how did she actually carbide all that tungsten? AFAIK that substance does not occur in (our) nature, so does it mean that it is naturally abundant in this world's soil? Or does she pull the carbon out of the earth or air (less likely, given how she is not an air mage) and let it react with elemental tungsten? If so, how does she achieve the necessary temperatures of 1000+ degrees without having an affinity for the fire element?

One would assume that, as usual, mages simply summon/create their respective elements. Less noticeable with air users or earth users who create walls like that, possible even to explain away with water and fire to an extent, but certainly noticeable at the very least with earth type projectiles. Well, never a good idea to think too much about most magic systems in any case.

luinthoron
Ykn1
joined Dec 20, 2018

That was indeed the most fun sports match I've ever seen. :D

Ykn1
joined Dec 20, 2018

Oh god, THAT is the worst possible timing to have a panic attack. Poor girl...she must have been hit by stage fright really badly.

I guess that's one possibility, although considering her rejecting the offered food before, it may simply be because she hasn't eaten anything the whole day out of nervousness.

Ykn1
joined Dec 20, 2018

This manga sure shows us the worst in people, mostly in the comments...

luinthoron
Ykn1
joined Dec 20, 2018

If Miku buys chocolate cake does that mean Kyouko has to do lewd things to miku so they both fulfill their agreement?

Only if she buys enough for every month she's missed.

Ykn1
joined Dec 20, 2018

Not only do the parents not have a problem with their marriage, they get much better along with their daughter in law than their actual daughter. :D

luinthoron
Ykn1
joined Dec 20, 2018

Favourite moment was Relaire joining in with the Princes doing their Rei impression.

This, absolutely. :D

luinthoron
Ykn1
joined Dec 20, 2018

These silly baka...

luinthoron
Ykn1
joined Dec 20, 2018

Irrefutable.

luinthoron
Image Comments 24 Jul 06:55
Ykn1
joined Dec 20, 2018
E63kuiivkaettfv-orig

Beautiful. ^_^