Forum › Posts by Silveda

Silveda
joined Feb 1, 2013

Apples and oranges. Girl Friends is a romance drama, Octave is a coming-of-age story and SK is primarily a romantic comedy.

This.

Loving the three of them by the way.

joined Feb 1, 2013

Never read it, being put off by the title. But I'll maybe give it a try, if you say that it isn't an indication of what's inside.

Silveda
joined Feb 1, 2013

Interesting. I'm not a fan of this author, far from it, but she can do good works. And here we have a good start, so I have hopes.

Translation and editing are indeed far better than in the first version of your first work Fly by Yuri.
On page 3, did you increase light ? Because it's too shiny. And on page 9, bottom left panel, I don't understand what the people in class are talking about, but maybe it is intended that way by the author.

Silveda
joined Feb 1, 2013

I love this seris so much. It makes me laugh, stress, blush and kyaying like a fangirl. >_<

Silveda
joined Feb 1, 2013

I agree that the message given by this one is totally stupid. I said it, it makes me rage each time I read it. But alas, shit like this happens in reality. And this one shot touches me, it conveys fellings, which most aren't able to.

joined Feb 1, 2013

If memory serves, it has been suggested during the creation of the new reader and new forums, and the idea has finally been rejected.

last edited at Apr 13, 2013 9:52AM

Silveda
joined Feb 1, 2013

This one always get to me. >_<

I stumble upon it, remember havig read it before, but doesn't remember what it's about.

Then I read it, rage, and am sad. Then I force myself to forget it in order not to be sad. And it's all starting again.

Just goes to show that's it's really well written I guess.

Silveda
Citrus discussion 13 Apr 09:47
joined Feb 1, 2013

Chapter 2 was better than the first. Still not extraordinary in my totally not humble opinion, but better. Art is still neat and cool, and the story becomes a little bit interesting. Still, the problem is that it's cliche like crazy.

I haven't been surprised even once by this manga so far.

joined Feb 1, 2013

I... won't help. Not enough free time, being already moderator on two forums. But I'll welcome the chosen guys & gals with open arms. ^^

joined Feb 1, 2013

Maybe omnescient0 can make it so that people can blacklist certain tags??

This is actually a good idea.

To get back on topic (yeah, I love going sidetracked), I'm gonnay say pretty much the same things as the people above.

I don't want Dynasty Reader to become juste another reader like every other, because for that I have batoto.net, which is awesome, and don't need a simple copy. I come here for yuri, and I like that I don't have to search for it when I arrive on the site. I look at the lastest released/added stuff, and I'm happy that it's yuri (mostly).

There are some things that I don't like. Be it genre (hentai-ish lolicon yuri...) or series (Happy jets, to name a recent one). But, hell wathever ! I don't read them, and I'm perfectly happy.

joined Feb 1, 2013

This is a really interesting and i think fujiwara should have long hair! >w<

If you think that, you are missing the point of the story.

Whait, what ?

What does hair lenght have anything to do with understanding the story ?

Silveda
joined Feb 1, 2013

No discussion for this one ?

I really love this autobiographic manga. It's interesting, cute, the art is really special (I love it, but it can probably be off-putting for some people) and most of all it's a real sighting of the LGBT community in Japan.

Silveda
Girl's Ride discussion 10 Apr 20:31
joined Feb 1, 2013

Yay new chapter ! I really love this serie. It's simple, well drawn and somewhat touching. I couldn't really define it, but I really love the ambient feeling it gives off.

Thanks a lot Lililicious for your work. Not only on this one, but for all that you did for yuri fans in the past years. You're the first yuri scanlation team I stumbled upon, a few years back (2006 ? 2007 ? I don't remember) and I've been actively checking on your scanlations since then. I love your work, you made me discover so much great manga, I love you. Thanks again.

Silveda
joined Feb 1, 2013

I dismissed this one based on the cover, thinking it was just porn. But your comments made me curious, so I decided to give it a try. Just finished my read. It's not great or whatnot, but it's a cute, nice and a little touching serie. I liked it.

Silveda
Citrus discussion 07 Apr 11:08
joined Feb 1, 2013

Well, I love the art but the story... not so much for the moment. It's all over the place, somewhat cliche, etc.

But it's just the first chapter, so I'll continue my read for now, hoping for it to become better.

Silveda
joined Feb 1, 2013

@Seravi : machiavelous plan indeed. If this works, they will be able to proudly say "All according to Keikaku".

Good news. To support this commendable effort, I hereby announce that I will... well read it all eagerly like all others leechers out there. Except maybe Happy jets, which I personnaly do not like. But well, I'll leech with love for you all.

Thanks a lot for all your work Dynasty Scans. For an officially inactive group, you do very well indeed. ^^

joined Feb 1, 2013

Sad chapter. T_T

And I think I won't like the old geezer that appeared out of nowhere.

last edited at Apr 6, 2013 5:19PM

Silveda
Collectors discussion 04 Apr 16:15
joined Feb 1, 2013

Same here. Thanks a lot Lililicious !

I love this serie

joined Feb 1, 2013

Thanks for answering. Alas I'm not in the US, so it wiil be difficult for me to find them.

joined Feb 1, 2013

Didn't know there were animated series. Are they any good ? Are they subbed in english ?

joined Feb 1, 2013

Don't get me wrong I like this serie just fine, but I don't really understand all the love I see in this topic.

Yeah, it's fun and all but... that's it for me. Nice little read, a little boring at times, somewhat okay art, and a story which would be better without cliche characters. I enjoy it, but I'm not waiting impatiently for the next chapter, and I certainly couldn't compare it to a masterpiece like Girl Friends.

joined Feb 1, 2013

I looked through the pages on this topic and didn't see it so...

Might I suggest:

An Authors addition to the list options or a way to bookmark favorite authors/circles/groups. Currently I'm just using the browser to do this.

Nope, never suggested. Except maybe just 4 post above yours. :D

Silveda
joined Feb 1, 2013

Can't really say how long it'll be. There are 7 or 8 chapters so far and it's still ongoing, albeit bi-monthly for the moment. The buildup is a steady but slow so it may or may not reach Girl Friends levels. Scanlation will continue in the next few weeks, we were stuck with really low quality raws for a while.

Those are really good news. ^^

joined Feb 1, 2013

I think it would be nice if it were possible to add authors to the reading lists.

This.

Really nice work on the new reader BTW

Silveda
joined Feb 1, 2013

WHEREISTHENEX.... Oops, wrong start. :D

I liked it too. Was nice and sweet. And a fast developpement would have felt too unnatural.

BTW, are you (as in Dynasty Scans) officially active again or what ? ^^