Forum › Posts by Pulsar

joined Feb 10, 2022

I mean if she trully loves her, and she's been doing that job just for fun, all she need to do is quit, become girlfriends and be by her side instead of having that kinda relationship.

Pulsar
joined Feb 10, 2022

Not a fan of tomboy but that was kinda sexy I guess

joined Feb 10, 2022

What?? Is that really the end? Did they d!3??? Bruh
I always thought this was not gonna get a happy end but never expected this. I hope there is an epilogue. Something like... idk like reborn, reunite and this time being happy??? Tho I dont thinks gonna happen. I think maybe everyone in the school is gonna know about it soon. And idk maybe the gloomy girl is gonna get schizophrenia and hear their voices since everything was her fault tho anyone could have found them doing that tho things could have been different if so idk

last edited at Feb 25, 2022 8:58AM

joined Feb 10, 2022

I wish the author could have made them confessed tho we can figure out they did it eventually

Pulsar
joined Feb 10, 2022

After checking the raw of chap24 seems that things are gonna get complicated. I hope they do the sandwich before anything happens:D

joined Feb 10, 2022

Better than citrus lol jk

Pulsar
joined Feb 10, 2022

I really liked the manga. I see the point that the poly came out of nowhere cause there was no romantic development between Kou and Amane. We can say that Kou actually liked Amane and of course Nene.
Nene well she did not deserve Amane's affection after all she did to her but even after that the love between Nene and Amane is stronger than the one Nene has for Kou.
The could have paired Kou and the club president since they have the same dream of being a pro photographer. But I didnt like the prez' toxicity tbh. If she wanted to make Amane fall for her then she would have done in another way rather than throw in her face the fact that Nene and Kou were dating.
I guess the author made Amane choose that decision cause Kou likes Nene, and probably thought Kou was gonna be sad cause of breaking up. For Nene, Amane knew she was in love with both of them and probably thought Nene was gonna be sad for giving Kou hopes for a relationship after all the time they spent together and the fact that Nene liked her.
I dont think Amane hates Kou after dating Nene. In the end I can say that Amane knew that this type of relationship will work and Kou would not decline. It's a win-win so Nene can be with the girls she loves, Kou can be with both and same for Amane who eventually fell in love with Kou and viceseversa.
Kinda jealous in the extra chapter and Amane gave a nice solution so no one can feel left out whenever they sleep together, bath, dates, etc I guess but it was kinda funny somehow cause Nene knew that includes seggs xd
But yea, like I said at the end they love each other I guess they eventually trust themselves and there was no more jealousy. I wish there could have been two more chapters, one with a time skip where they are living together and going on dates and see more how their relationship is going, and another one for their wedding and see if the prez found someone who was able to reciprocate her love some kind of redemption for her.
All I can say is that I love this manga and I'm gonna try to find the physical copies. I really like the art style for how outstanding it is. Even thought the poly relationship came out of nowhere, and I know because of that some readers were not satisfy, for me this is the manga with the best poly ending. I mean I know about other but they are H, and I know about Canno's manga tho that one was better the mono end rather than poly. Anyway it was a great manga for me at least.

joined Feb 10, 2022

I have the new chapters if you want I'll send them to you so you can translate them.

Bruh.... they literally explained the situation so where the heck did you get the idea that they are not translating because they don't have the chapters.

Do you have to be rude bro?

joined Feb 10, 2022

They added censor-chan to the next chapter:[

joined Feb 10, 2022

lmao at first I heard people complained about the manga going poly route, and now I hear they're disappointed with its rather non-poly end.

Well, for me, the manga ended nice and well. Just the right satisfaction I would expect to call it a good manga.

The ones who complained maybe they are the ones who are satisfy with this ending. The ones that are complaining now are the ones who wanted the poly ending ya see. It's a quite decent manga but another of those there.

Pulsar
joined Feb 10, 2022

Plot twist idea: Nana and Seto continued their "poly" relationship even after Older Nana has disappeared, and now they have a harem in the future with all the previous club members seduced by them.

Nah, her future self went back to the future for a while and then back to the past. Maybe her time there is almost finished(This is what I guess after looking at the miniature of chapter 25)

joined Feb 10, 2022

So disappointing. As someone that really liked this manga from the start, Its so sad to see an abrupt ending like this. I'm not really bother about how it ending. I just wanted to see more developing.

To register: A W for the childhood friend. Even if the author was forced to. Lmao

Yea. Also I've been looking foward this manga since it had 4 chapters. Maybe the manga wasnt that popular and for that reason they decided to axed with this ending. But even if that were the case I think they could have managed to make this ending with a poly relationship but anyway. I dont dislike the ending but I dont like it either. I'm just disappointed it didnt ended as I wanted

last edited at Feb 16, 2022 9:18AM

joined Feb 10, 2022

Idk. One of them is another I have to choose one manga that comes from a light novel where the mc is gonna choose 1 out of 4 girls. The other I think it's about a girl that "bought" another girl for 100 days in which the one who bought her is gonna show her that love between girls is possible or something like that but idk if it is from a LN.

so one is generic harem anime 100 but yuri and the other one is rent a yuri girlfriend?. Yeah, that doesn´t sound that interesting honestly, i don´t want to be too harsh on teren mikami, but their stories are kinda meh at best, this one had a somewhat interesting premise and gorgeous character desing and artstyle (god i love sayo mei and rinna so much) and somehow manages to be underwhelming

Well the first one it's kinda harem tho I dont think its gonna end like that. I think the light novel is gonna at volume 5. Tho I see who's gonna win. The other is not a rent thing. Basically the MC wanted to sell herlsef for money but the other girl bought(we can say also rent) her for 100 days in exchange of 1 million yen. The reason why she got her for 1 million yen is cause the MC says that love between girls is impossible. Dye to this reason the other girl is gonna spend those 100 days to show her that yuri love is possible you can check it here in dynasty it has like 5 chapters.
https://dynasty-scans.com/series/a_yuri_story_about_a_girl_who_insists_its_impossible_for_two_girls_to_get_together_completely_falling_within_100_days

last edited at Feb 16, 2022 9:09AM

joined Feb 10, 2022

Um, did Sumire suddenly age 10 years between pages?

Sure looks like it, huh? lol

From 7 to 13 then to 18.

Is just the expressions lol it's kinda the author made her at first like a "chibi" style tho it isnt but that's the idea

joined Feb 10, 2022

Well, I'm sad that this apparently got cancelled and all, but at least we've got Teren Mikami's two other yuri stories that are essentially the same thing but a little different... well, the other two are pretty similar, but this one's a lot more distinct. I preferred this one since I liked the unique premise, but those two are based on LNs, right? I guess they probably won't be axed then...

Idk. One of them is another I have to choose one manga that comes from a light novel where the mc is gonna choose 1 out of 4 girls. The other I think it's about a girl that "bought" another girl for 100 days in which the one who bought her is gonna show her that love between girls is possible or something like that but idk if it is from a LN.

Pulsar
Semelparous discussion 15 Feb 11:54
joined Feb 10, 2022

Is this series still being translated?

Probably yeah, series is ending at chapter 20 so TL may wait until its over or close to being over to send me the scripts to edit.

It ended with 20 chapters? I've read until chap18 where final battle is gonna happen. As far as I know it has 3 volume tho

joined Feb 10, 2022

I'm wondering... did Rinna have a chance from the beginning? since earlier chapters, the series screamed Sayo. Even every moment happened lead Mei to think about Sayo's feeling. Of course, Rinna made Mei flattered here and there, but compared to Sayo, their relationship was so underdeveloped I didn't even think she was a rival to Sayo. Somehow, it feels like Rinna was just there for a plot device of love triangle with no chance to win.

Also, I don't think poly route works since Sayo clearly didn't want to share her love (hence there was no arrow grow from Sayo to Rinna ever. she even got jealous when Mei and Rinna were cleaning the bath together). People started to expect poly ending only when there was a poly chapter. Even that chapter ended with a small and frail arrow from Rinna to Sayo, then never developed after.

There was sometimes where Mei said she wanted to be with them, and that she likes both of them. Even in 14.1 she was doubting whether to choose both or no one. Rinna just sacrificed herself for the sake of Mei and Sayo. That's how I felt 14.1. The story was focused on both at first, them on Sayo, so I thought next one was gonna be Rinna but no suddenly she was friendzoned twice. That's why I wonder what happened. She didn't got jealous, she felt left out. I never saw she wanted her for herself. We will never know just the author know whether this was gonna end in poly or mono since the beginning. Like someone said before maybe the manga wasnt popular in japan and that may be the reason the rushed the story. It's not the first time tho "seifuku no vimpireslod" wasnt popular according to the author and the editorial forced him to axed it. Author said it was gonna be 7 volumes, but reduced the story and managed to draw a quite decent end in 3 volume. So... sad but we can just speculate

joined Feb 10, 2022

Sigh. Another disappointing ending. Maybe one day we'll get a good one.

Hopefully someone decides to drawn a proper wholesome manga with a poly ending. I mean we have the "an easy introduction to love triangle" tho the ending was... eh. That manga would have been better wuth Rin and Mayuki. The author forgot to make Akira to be a better character. We also have Luminous blue tho that manga never developed a romantic relationship between the MCs tho it's a quite decent end. There are other but they are H. But anyway.

last edited at Feb 13, 2022 7:26PM

joined Feb 10, 2022

Say, I noticed one thing about the last chapter that, unless someone corrects me, really underlines for me a certain "trying too hard" going on. That is, didn't the MC stop being able to see the love arrows after she fell in love? But now, after the time skip, just to reassure us that the triangle/poly is off and there's really no hard or lingering feelings, suddenly she can see the other love interest's lotsa-little-arrows-but-none-really-pointing-at-the-MC.

So, why can she see that, aside from it being convenient for beating us over the head with "It's cool, no lost love to see here"? Did the ability come back and I missed it, or something?

The author didnt even explain the arrows thing tho some were easy to figure out, and I wonder the same... If the reason she stopped seeing the arrows was cause she found love according to the school prez, I wonder why she was able to still see them. We will never know.

joined Feb 10, 2022

It's funny that "An easy intro to love triangle" would have been better with a mono ending with Rin and Mayuki rather the 3some, and that this one would have been better the 3some rather the mono route lol Even the drama thing in luminous blue its ending was ok not expected but ok since it was a win win. Btw do you know of another manga with poly? I read futari to futari too tho its h

joined Feb 10, 2022

https://dynasty-scans.com/chapters/if_you_could_see_love_ch3_1#3

If anything, it support my view on Rinna liking everyone.

https://dynasty-scans.com/chapters/if_you_could_see_love_ch5_1#13

That means we had a poly-suggesting page in every second chapter before it became obvious it was going to go full on sayo (ch 10).

How many of this was interpreted as such BEFORE the poly chapter ? Almost none. You see as suggested AFTER the chapter. If it was really suggested, you would have pick up the hints before the poly chapter happen. Seeing this as poly hints is just people wanting a poly ending after seeing the poly chapter and squeezing every little hints they can, no matter how bad they are.

Forgetting the page before she talk about wanting friends.

https://dynasty-scans.com/chapters/if_you_could_see_love_ch5_2#5

Again, for her it's about friendship, not love.

https://dynasty-scans.com/chapters/if_you_could_see_love_volume_1_extras#11

I clearly see the two arrows going for the same person and for fuck sake, they're roommates. Of course they see each other in the morning

https://dynasty-scans.com/chapters/if_you_could_see_love_volume_1_extras#12

Again, they both think of the MC, not of the others.

https://dynasty-scans.com/chapters/if_you_could_see_love_ch6_1#4

don't even see what buildup you see here

https://dynasty-scans.com/chapters/if_you_could_see_love_ch7_2#30
https://dynasty-scans.com/chapters/if_you_could_see_love_ch7_2#32

Again, Rinna falling in one with anyone and ffs do you remember what happen to that freaking arrow at the end of chapter 8 ? Not existing.

If a story that has X chapters has a whole chapter dedicated to poly relationship in an older person with similar circumstances, the most common story structure does indeed imply the same thing will happen again.

Yeah and there was a whole chapter dedicated to aromantic, power balance. Why are they less likely to be the ending than Poly ? See that's my problem, there was multiples forms of love, yet peoples just focused on the Poly one.

The story did not end after the original confesion from Sayo, so people expected something new to happen

A lot of stories didn't end after the confession, doesn't mean they bring another route on the menu.

Like i thought, those are rather weak arguments for Poly and can be easily interpreted differently.

The whole story was weak that's why you feel it like that

joined Feb 10, 2022

For some reason, even though this was adapted from a novel the story feels so messy and meandering

No, the one you're talking about is the other manga were the MC have to choose one between 4 girls. As far as I know this wasn't adapted from a novel.

joined Feb 10, 2022

I liked this as a final chapter, I don't see why so many people are trashing it like this. Yes, it did feel like the last few chapters were rushed and I can understand the frustration towards the tired time-skip endings, but I liked how Rinna was handled tbh.

Thinking about it again, I'm not sure how a poly ending would have worked, since Sayo not only didn't show any romantic interest towards Rinna, but also got jealous when Mei hung out with other people. She clearly wanted Mei to herself. Perhaps it could have been done if Sayo and Rinna were given more time, but I guess that wasn't the author's (or the publisher's) intention. I definitely would have preferred if the kiss scene between them hadn't existed at all though... As I've said previously, that is a ridiculous trope and I can only understand its use when it actually helps progress the relationship of the characters involved. Otherwise it's just silly and unnecessary.

The prophesied incest 'arrow' finally made its debut in the last chapter. All's well that ends well.

Idk, I didn't read it like that. I went back to reread chapters 12.1 and 12.2 and it just didn't seem like that to me (or maybe it's because these types of incestuous relationships you see in manga seem completely absurd to me lol). I do have to wonder whether the author intended to hint at that with the panel of the two of them though, because it can be a bit hard to tell with this series...

For me at least, that kiss between Sayo and Rinna was the first step for then to love each other. Idk what happened maybe the authors just wanted to get rid of this manga and step back with the poly thing. Even they dont need to love each other to be in a 3p relationship with Mei. Sayo knew Rinna was in love with Mei and the authors could have easily make her share her love with Mei. Sayo didnt feel jealous, she just was feeling left out. Even Mei said she wanted to be with both in 14.1 but it wasnt ok cause of selfishness. If this was intended to finish like this since the beginning then those hints for a poly end and the accidental kiss were not necessary cause it made some of the readers to think of that type of ending. But we will never know. Seems mikami likes this type of manga where the mc have to choose one of out couple of girls so...

joined Feb 10, 2022

Well this manga lacked explaining the arrow thing. It was supposed that she stopped seeing it cause she found love but even in the end she could still see them. I'm disappointed tbh cause it hinted me that it was gonna end with a 3 way relationship. I'll never understand the reason of the kiss between Sayo and Rinna and the times where Mei said she wanted to be with both of them, and that likes both of them. At least I wanted to see Rinna dating someone, Akane for example. This could have easily been(for me) the best manga with a 3p relationship but it wasnt. It's a bittersweet ending.

Pulsar
joined Feb 10, 2022

Or maybe she went to the future for a while and went to the past... like a sign of her time in the past is almost done. Idk but I wanna see Aya getting banged by the 2 Nana lol Honestly I dont think this is gonna end with a 3p relation but I wouldnt mind. I think she will help aya to become an actress, help her past self to have a deep relation with Aya, and when time comes to go back to the future she will be dating the future aya who never got married and who succeeded as an actress. Maybe that future Aya will remember that Nana went to the past and everything I guess

last edited at Feb 12, 2022 11:09AM