Forum › Posts by ---

joined Apr 20, 2023

Technically speaking, as humans are currently driving a mass extinction event that would actually work...

---
joined Apr 20, 2023

From the comment section I did good getting out early (see the 15th message on page 1).

joined Apr 20, 2023

regarding chapter 133,
that's pathetic

joined Apr 20, 2023

There's an ongoing Sargent exhibition at the Met that was really cool.

joined Apr 20, 2023

Noko no Tabi? that's the title of the book she recomended. See, Airi is an otaku of culture! No wonder she couldn't get along with glasses guy.

Yeah, the Kino no Tabi reference is peak.

joined Apr 20, 2023

This is so good
Feels like the type of romance you’d see irl
OL yuri is so good
Most ppl don’t understand that the majority of people who smoke started or only do so for social reasons

I think it's the other way around, most people know that smoking is bad but started because they wanted to fit in or thought it was cool, or were curious about it. That's exactly what they teach in school. Same thing with vaping

Isn't that what the person you quoted said?

joined Apr 20, 2023

Honestly didn't expect the tutor to have actually done something to her. I wonder if it's a serial thing or if she got found out and ghosted her because "it'd be for the better" (which might leave the avenue open for her to reappear as a dreaded love interest of the past...)

When I was reading comments in the earlier chapters, I was always wondering why everyone thought something didn't happen. My assumption was always that it was exactly like this.

joined Apr 20, 2023

Most psychopathic behavior we've seen from Hinami yet.

Also, that's savage upstairs.

joined Apr 20, 2023

Really cooking with the volume covers.
https://files.catbox.moe/wngy9j.jpg
https://files.catbox.moe/56ya59.jpg

the uh.. details though

joined Apr 20, 2023

Impressive, if true. :D

Nah, that password would take only a couple minutes with a dictionary attack. Super weak password.

---
joined Apr 20, 2023

The whole game development part is too unrealistic, this ain't it. Suspension of disbelief can only go so far.

joined Apr 20, 2023

Did the scanlators originally have the impression that it was yuri before reading ahead and finding out that it was het?

Yeah, the tags changed.

I feel baited :'(

joined Apr 20, 2023

;_;

;_;

;_;

;_;

;_;

Real^

Had a small laugh seeing the tear on the marriage registration at the end.

last edited at Mar 29, 2025 9:37PM

joined Apr 20, 2023

These are clearly gnomes.

Exactly! It does seem like the author has mixed up a bunch of things, there's some element of household spirits in them. Something like the wights 'vættr' in Old Norse, and 'wicht' in German, all cognates. If you remember The Elves and the Shoemaker, from the Grimm stories, the 'elves' in the story fall into the above category. Gnomes fall into the category of nature spirits, so this is quite the mix-up. I do hope it's intentional and not like the rest of the Japanese butchering of Western folklore which is, howbeit, quite entertaining.

joined Apr 20, 2023

How do we know all those accounts are the same person? It seems like two different people to me? 'Cause if they're the same individual that would be crazy. Also, this is the author of Witch Guild Fantasia which was ... underwhelming tbh, and got axed before it could live out its potential.

---
Walk Wit Me discussion 24 Mar 16:18
joined Apr 20, 2023

I must say, this story is so American it's pretty incredible a Japanese mangaka can depict it so powerfully. Haven't seen anything like that since Stone Ocean...

I'll be honest it comes off as more British to me. Lot of coal-mining there in the post-war period, and they'd be more likely to call Russia "easterners" than Americans would.

At first, I was looking at architecture for clues, but thankfully there was something easier. http://dynasty-scans.com/chapters/walk_wit_me_first_part#25 I'm not an expert in 20th century newspapers, but I'm not sure a British front page would read "Pitt Beats Trojans 20 to 14", "(Bob?) Turley Today in Third Game of Series", and what might be "Teamsters Elect..." Of course, we never know if the author just put random english text in there, but I'm inclined to believe this guy put serious effort into depicting a specific time period. Whatever the case, the themes covered seem applicable throughout the world (and throughout time).

I think the mangaka just peeled a whole newspaper page off of an archive. The game between USC's Trojans and the University of Pittsburgh Panthers happened on October 5th, Sputnik was launched on October 4th. The one car I recall seeing looked like a Volkswagon? Not very common in the US at the time. Also you obviously couldn't see Sputnik's launch from the states (or from most anywhere honestly). The Korean War was mostly US involvement, but there were some English ground troops involved. Some French troops as well, not really any others. It feels very British for some reason, but I think it is meant to be American.

Edit: Okay, nobodyJones did the much better job sleuthing around. Even identified the newspaper. I agree with their assertions.

Love the art style, find the prose a bit too awkwardly florid.

last edited at Mar 24, 2025 4:21PM

joined Apr 20, 2023

I hate these endings so much.

joined Apr 20, 2023

Imagine my confusion when I reached chapter 18. I thought I was on chapter 3 or something.

joined Apr 20, 2023
71044209_en

@victim is a squirming pile of dung
the gif has a total of 59 frames and a duration of 7.5 seconds

---
Maple Love discussion 09 Mar 19:52
joined Apr 20, 2023

Since it's featured again, might as well pitch in and praise this yuri one-shot as one of the greatest of all time.

joined Apr 20, 2023

Re: Chapter 5:
The author overestimates the weight of a pig in those days. Due to poorer diet, and less advanced breeding techniques, the typical hog weighed in at somewhere between 68-90kg (significantly less than the author's estimate.) Even if you keep as much of the meat as possible, around 28 percent of the animal is just inedible, (hair, bones, etc.) Yes, you can save the bones for broth, and the blood for blood sausage/black pudding, but you can't count that in the estimate due to different nutritional value (it's not meat). So you're left with somewhere between 43 and 56 kilograms of meat for the year. Not to mention that preservation techniques can alter the nutritional profile, the amount eaten from one pig is probably less than the author's estimate. It is probably true however that a family might slaughter two pigs instead of one.
In any case, it is true during the late medieval period, families ate far more meat than they would in the following centuries (due to a population boom, the rising popularity of grain, economic difficulties etc.)

joined Apr 20, 2023

Speaking of germ theory, I was surprised to see the reference to hand washing in the chapter, since as far as I'm aware that's also centuries into the future. They might rinse their hands to remove obvious dirt but using soap is far off as far as I know. Typically proper handwashing is credited as a 19th century invention, and looking it up just now I learned that at least in America it wasn't until the 1980s that it started to get promoted to the general public as important, rather than primarily being for doctors and such. Which is rather dismaying lol. I guess this helps explain why as recently as the 2000s I've heard American men insist they don't need to use soap after peeing.

Anyway that sure was a hell of a lot of bread Rachel made all by herself. Could 3-4 cartloads of bread be feasibly made in one day by one person using these intense practices? Should we assume she's got some apprentices of her own just off camera, maybe?

Oh yeah, Missed the handwashing part. As for the bread, the baking process usually only takes a couple dozen minutes at most per batch (most of the work would be advance preparation of the dough), so baking could, in theory get wrapped up quickly enough. There were legal regulations (assize laws) regarding how much bread a baker is supposed to produce per baseline amount of flour (not very sure about the Holy Roman Empire). Because of this, the size of loaves fluctuate based on the determined flour standard, but a medieval bakery (from what I know of England) could easily go through 240lbs of flour in a day, and by the time we have proper census measurements (17th century) we know that it wasn't uncommon to have one bakery for about 500 people with each adult eating about a pound of bread per day. Considering that the baking technology hadn't changed much by that time it isn't unreasonable for Rachel to feed a village. Typically a baker would have an apprentice and a helper to stoke the fire though, but I guess Rachel is just super amazing.

joined Apr 20, 2023

Bullying?: Verdict is still out on whether bullying is happening and/or how bad it is, but I would say that it probably is to some degree, in a badmouthing way at the minimum. Potential escalation timeline (in terms of how "undeniable" the proof of bullying is), from 536-39 showcasing Yura's reluctance to talk about school (but possibly just due to not fitting in well), to 543 being a potential push or similar that'd cause a fall onto her face (or just her falling by herself, as happened exactly on 535, and would also mean that she directly lied in 546, which seems unlikely) to 557 with the girls talking about her (clear exclusion), and last, 564 with a wound on her neck that couldn't have been caused by a fall (though also not a common area to target unless the hypothetical bullies were really violent).

Was under the impression that it was domestic abuse. I think the phone pic on page 558 might be a hint. Also on page 565, there's a scar peeking out from under the uniform next to the neck bruise in the reflection. Also visible on page 570. But it might just be indicative of the restrictiveness of her family situation.

The sea: Both a herald of change and Koma's feelings toward Yura which she won't admit, as they would break the normal. Not just her normal, but also the normal. This feels most evident in the scene with the girls from Yura' school, where Koma comes closest to actually doing something on Yura's behalf and "dirtying her hands", as the sea rises, and she wonders why she would even consider it when she doesn't want things to change.

The sea definitely takes on a symbolic role, but I feel that it is more representative of Koma's feelings of helplessness than of her romantic ones. Reminds me a bit of the feeling of paralysis thematic to James Joyce's Dubliners. The sea is drawn throughout the latter half or so of the oneshot, often as an atmospheric effect (see pages 557 & 565), it's only at the end that the sea is shown as swallowing her whole. I suppose there's a rather dramatic reading that there's an example of synecdoche (totum pro parte), where the collapse of the world is used to refer to the end of their relationship. The fact that Koma's speech bubbles end with her affirming that having Yura by her side is all she could ever ask for lends that interpretation some substance. Very dramatic though. It might be worth noting that Koma doesn't finish that though, breaking up into an internalized scream. So it could be that there's some kind of implied divide between Koma and Yura's feelings. It's possible that Koma thinks her romantic feelings aren't requited and that her wanting to be together is different from Yura's. There's a lot of room for interpretation.

Coward: Koma's inability to join Yura in leaving that world behind and embracing the sea. She couldn't say that having Yura by her side was also all she could ever ask for.

Well yes, but I think that the implication of Koma's 'cowardice' is a little broader than that. It could refer to Koma's unwillingness for their relationship to change, or her unwillingness to interfere with Yura's personal life. It refers I think to all aspects of Koma's stasis. If you recall Koma's conversation with her classmate, Koma lacks the dreams and romanticism her classmate possesses. So it's definitely a developed commentary about Koma as a person, and not an individual accusation by Yura. The author put that in there with consistent intention. I like the word 'stasis' because the word also has the meaning of describing a civil war, so I think it neatly implies Koma's internal struggle, which reaches its apex only after Yura is gone. (From the train of course, I'm sure she's fine). I guess this struggle, is also symbolized by the encroaching sea.

Anyway, just wool gathering. I hope it was somewhat useful.

last edited at Dec 19, 2024 7:56PM

joined Apr 20, 2023

The suggested BGM is really good. Funny that I actually knew both the works. That's a first. Never heard the Nikolayeva recording before, but it's probably my favorite interpretation.

joined Apr 20, 2023

Only read up to chapter two at this point, but I have to say that I'm surprised by the level of research here. It's remarkably accurate. The afterword of chapter one is more or less correct in saying that people treasured cleanliness. Most of the prejudice today comes from slanderous clerical texts (regarding peasants), although germ theory wasn't solidified yet (though there was some understanding of correct protective measures,) and as was glossed over in the after-notes, bloodletting and treatments for scabies, leprosy and the like did occur in bathhouses. By modern standards, that's fairly unhygienic.

Tellingly, while the after-note for clothing in chapter two is correct (though the kirtle was actually less close fitting in the 14th century, that's a 15th century development,) the clothing Rachel is wearing throughout the chapter is anachronistic, and closer to 17th century clothing. The idea of front lacing as in a bodice didn't occur until centuries later, and it's highly unlikely that they'd cut off beneath the breast as in Rachel's garb (because the purpose of the lacing was supportive). (Also the neckline is a bit low-cut.) Given that every other character is dressed normally, it's clearly for titillation.

Nice way to expose your tastes author.