Forum › Posts by othiym23

Butt
joined Sep 26, 2020

You all are being touching and sweet and I'm just here to say YUSS… THE TRIUMPHANT RETURN OF DOOMER MIWA!!!

Butt
joined Sep 26, 2020

I was looking at the character designs in this and thought to myself, "I need to see Umehara-sensei to a ChisaTaki doujin," and lo and behold, there one was!

othiym23
Butt
joined Sep 26, 2020

^^ cosigned with the previous poster

Butt
joined Sep 26, 2020

What a mind Sato has.

Butt
joined Sep 26, 2020

The Makoto Hagino???

Butt
joined Sep 26, 2020

This one cut deep. The emotional gradient from the top to the bottom of page 373 is brutal, a kind of emotional cuckoldry that permanently changes people (as the story demonstrates). This reminds me of some of the messier middle parts of Hana ni Arashi dealing with Chidori's past with her senpai. Kovachi is really deft at balancing fluff and heaviness.

As somebody who categorically refuses alcohol, is Whiskey+Cola supposed to be anything special? Like the sort of drink that knocks you out real good without tasting the alcohol (therefore implying our protagonist to be a high-functioning alcoholic)? Or is there nothing to read into?

Its significance in the title is that it's one of the few things she carried forward from her previous life and it's something that she started liking because of Ayumu, just like she picked up her preference for black clothing while shopping with her ex. Which to me says that our identity being derived from our relationships and interpersonal entanglements is inescapable. People are not self-created, no matter how much they might want or need to believe so.

Butt
joined Sep 26, 2020

…if Chokki made a yuri manga, it would be exactly like this.

Butt
joined Sep 26, 2020

Houkago Kitaku Biyori is one of my favorite het / "shonen romcom" series out there right now, so it's both unexpected and a delight to see a yuri oneshot from the same author!

othiym23
Butt
joined Sep 26, 2020

Is this yuri The Summer Hikaru Died????

othiym23
Butt
joined Sep 26, 2020

This is very cute and sweet but I was hoping that this would bring out Dark Yukiko. Yukiko in Blood Mode x kimishinu would be terrifying to behold.

othiym23
Slow Start discussion 12 Jul 18:34
Butt
joined Sep 26, 2020

I'm so happy to learn that Tama-chan is the way she is because her mother is a woman of culture too.

othiym23
Butt
joined Sep 26, 2020

Has kind of a similar vibe to Usagi wa Kaku Katariki, with androids instead of lagomorphic girls with big uh hammers. I like this enough to tag a copy onto my next physical order, but it's not clear that the mangaka is in control of their material enough to pull it off.

Butt
joined Sep 26, 2020

I bought like five of those furry doujins from Takemiya-sensei at the last winter Comiket, and I will say I like them a lot more than the omegaverse stuff she was doing for a while. I hadn't realized that she'd been taking a break from non-doujin work!

othiym23
Butt
joined Sep 26, 2020

I'm glad this got serialized so I could get it in print and support the author, but I prefer the simplicity of the original Twitter version of almost all of these comics. I liked the mystery of Sakura's background and the lack of an overarching narrative.

Butt
joined Sep 26, 2020

I'm not sure where that COMITIA was meant to be held

Oh duh, the end page is a drawing of Tokyo Big Sight (I mean, I don't think there are that many conference venues in Japan with ceilings that high, but COMITIA is held all over the place, so I didn't want to assume).

Butt
joined Sep 26, 2020

I have to admit too that the page about Ren didn't know what to choose to go for a bathroom is quite depressing..

Usually there will be a third toilet that allows for the disabled or unisex. It's in the middle.

I'm not sure where that COMITIA was meant to be held, but that's not how it works at Tokyo Big Sight – there are women's and men's bathrooms, and that's it. Also, using the bathrooms at Tokyo Big Sight sucks for everybody. The bathrooms are in weird locations, they're not particularly large given the scale of the event, and I've never found one that's accessible that's not a portapotty outside. It is a hope of mine that this will be fixed by the renovations that the complex is going through now. And that they add some of the "family" restrooms that are now ubiquitous in urban train stations. Both unisex accessible bathrooms and family bathrooms are so much more common than they were when I first went to Japan, and they've been a lifesaver for me.

I will say that Ren's struggles in this chapter instantly made them far more relatable to me, as I have had to spend far too much time at Comiket thinking about bathrooms and generally not feeling good about my choices. I've definitely ended up walking most of the way around the East Hall looking for a bathroom that doesn't have a line of dudes running out of it (as I lack the courage, as a balding enby, to even attempt a women's bathroom in Japan).

I don't want to engage in Discourse™ too much, but I will say that while we haven't been given a clear or final indication as to how Ren thinks about gender labels and what labels do or do not apply to them, I feel very comfortable labeling Ren as trans. When it comes down to it, "trans" just means a more expansive conception of gender that encompasses more than the cisheteronormative framework most of us were raised within. Ren may think of Ren as a boy, a girl, a nonbinary entity, agender, or simply refuse to be bound by gender at all, but regardless, Ren is clearly uncomfortable just inhabiting the space that other people assume or assign Ren into.

last edited at May 25, 2026 5:56AM

Butt
joined Sep 26, 2020

It's also worth keeping in mind that as more Japanese comic publishing moves to web-first (or web-only) publishing, sites like KadoKomi and even Jump+ don't really seem to be as beholden to demographic-based classification (although it's still relatively uncommon to intermingle seinen / shonen with shojosei series). And for ongoing series, especially those with subtext, they may or may not get the 百合 tag.

All I know is that this is an Ohsawa Yayoi series with her up to the tricks she got up to in the back half of 2DK G-Pen without the fluff and I'm here for it.

The Moon On A Rainy Night

Kuzushiro seems pretty allergic to having any of her major works tagged as yuri, for whatever reason. Living With My Brother's Wife stayed squarely in the subtext zone (while at the same time having an explicitly lesbian side character), and A Workplace Where You Can't Help But Smile is basically Fuzuroi no Renri if you filtered all the really gay stuff out and just left the subtext.

Run Away With Me Girl

Battan seems to be comfortable mostly being published in josei magazines and just happening to include a lot of queer themes in her work, in the same way that Tomoko Yamashita mostly publishes in josei magazines while also publishing a decent amount of BL (and when she does write queer female characters, they tend to be more grounded depictions of bisexuality or lesbianism than is typical in most yuri).

I think in general it's probably easier on your heart to just read a work and see where it goes and not worry about whether it's going to have a yuri ending by reading the tags. But I'm sorta rooting for Pinky Candy Kiss to go a poly route, so I suppose that renders my judgment suspect.

othiym23
I'm A Cat discussion 16 Sep 20:29
Butt
joined Sep 26, 2020

Neat to finally see something from CAUSTICSODA here. They / she (?) have a story in serialization in Japan that has really great art and has a pretty different vibe from other manga / manhwa I read. Most of it is not as heavy a bummer as this.

othiym23
Fatale Game discussion 21 Jul 05:56
Butt
joined Sep 26, 2020

Battan has had a couple volumes of (quite varied) one-shots along with the two other series she's had since Kakeochi Girl came out. She's also been steadily working as an illustrator and has had at least one gallery show in Tokyo that I know about. Also, she's never claimed to be a yuri mangaka. It's a little weird to see people extrapolating things about male characters and whatnot based on her other stories, especially given how those stories have ended.

As for this one, I am locked all the way in. A pushy, manipulative editor who uses her wiles on her stable? With black, unknowable eyes? I am enchanted.

Butt
joined Sep 26, 2020

It's really hard to read manga from between the fingers over my face.

Butt
joined Sep 26, 2020

This story is serialized both on the web and in Comics EXE, an eromanga magazine, and all I can figure is that an editor saw a preserialization of it and couldn't understand why nobody had picked it up. I bought the first volume of this immediately when it was published, and it's one of my favorite manga of recent years. College art students, immaculate vibes, and that tattoo! Also I really like the art style.

othiym23
Butt
joined Sep 26, 2020

Anyone confused about what makes this yuri, or indeed what the difference is between BL / yaoi and yuri, should (re)read this one-shot: https://dynasty-scans.com/chapters/this_is_bl_not_yuri

othiym23
Butt
joined Sep 26, 2020
Grace

That's a Tanjiu-level gag.

othiym23
Butt
joined Sep 26, 2020

Pandacorya manages to make her stories completely predictable (at least for her) without them ever getting stale. This was fun.

Butt
joined Sep 26, 2020

Whoah, Arai mentions Clueless!

So, is there an actual CD with licensed music? Or just a liner of song titles for you to seek out on your own?

It's an official soundtrack for the manga you can get on vinyl or cd. Released in Japan, but also found imported in the US at Kinokuniya bookstores. Both versions come with the same booklet content. Considering they had to get license for each of them not a bad selection.

There is also an official streaming playlist that has more songs. https://umj.lnk.to/TheGuySheWasMP

There is also a vinyl LP that I think is only available in Japan, which I have a copy of. Because I used to be a (techno / drum'n'bass) DJ, I have a fair amount of vinyl, including some pretty exotic things, and this is still easily the goofiest record I own.

It is kind of funny that this is the first time that "Heart-Shaped Box" has been included on a compilation.