Forum › Posts by Eukene

joined Jul 26, 2024

Regardless of whether this got cut short by the magazine or the author, this one really needed a little more time for the reason you say.

I think it makes sense here with Remu / Niji. They, unlike Meguru / Azuki, never had a romantic relationship, but Niji was in denial about that pretty much right up until the end. Niji needs more time to process her feelings, even by the accelerated ending standards, but seeing her start to doubt herself and feel remorse suggests that process is starting. It would make sense if they reconnect as friends after a time skip where Niji gets some space, as their friendship was real at the end of the day.

I'm not sure what's going on with this author or if it's possible to get more content. Question for those who read Japanese: Has there been any Japanese language activity from the author? Are they generally doing okay?

last edited at Nov 15, 2026 8:49PM

joined Jul 26, 2024

Not sure how the mom went evil (assuming it's really Io's mom) instead, but it's easy to see how she could if she goes from being isolated and mistreated to being famous in a cutthroat environment.

That's not Io's mom. Time doesn't add up, Io was already born. I don't know if we are aware of their age difference, but it's not that much, maybe 12/13 years?

I remember seeing the ages somewhere and I believe it's around a decade difference in age. However, it is still not impossible that Io was born but not with her.

If it's not literally Io's mom I still would expect them to be sisters or something like that based on the similar appearances, but we will find out.

last edited at Nov 13, 2026 8:12AM

joined Jul 26, 2024

Aikosaurus posted:

I hope she is not mixing wishing for maternel love with being in love.

I'm hoping she is

I'd think it's pretty common that someone does mix them to some extent. And, with Io, Misa loves getting to take on the caretaker role herself and give Io what neither of them received, while Io gives Misa the sense of acceptance Misa wanted.

Not sure how the mom went evil (assuming it's really Io's mom) instead, but it's easy to see how she could if she goes from being isolated and mistreated to being famous in a cutthroat environment.

last edited at Nov 12, 2026 10:28PM

joined Jul 26, 2024

it's not her mom it's her dads girlfriend.her mom ran of with another man.also way to dump it on us Misa

I think the author just didn't want to go full incest and have Misa be Io's sister or half sister. But it's about as close to Misa's mom that we're likely to get.

joined Jul 26, 2024

A very flowerchild plot point

Agreed. Despite some of my incorrect predictions, I'm not surprised about this one going where it sounded like it would.

If you look at early chapters, Misa has a strong, atypical for her reaction as soon as she sees Io. This was unlikely to be based on much besides Io's appearance. We also know Misa has some major commitment issues. Then we get the flashback to this Io like person in Misa's past.

last edited at Nov 11, 2026 1:05PM

joined Jul 26, 2024

In English, I think it's more that most people don't have a good sense about what is a surname versus first name in Japanese. With something like "Johnny" and "Smith" we intuitively know which is which, but "Hazuki" sounds like it could be either.

I notice that, in discussions, people tend to use whatever names were used most recently. Suppose we have two arcs, Arc 1 and Arc 2, that are equal in length. Arc 1 involves A and B who are on first first basis and Arc 2 involves B and C who are surname basis. Readers will switch to calling B by the surname during the second arc. A lot of times readers can't remember the name at all and will describe the character instead, like saying "glasses girl". If a reader makes a mistake with the name, sometimes other readers will copy the mistake in discussions.

I imagine Japanese discussions are pretty different and might reflect the level of familiarity readers feel with the characters. In a military series where we mainly get the perspective of soldiers, "the general" feels formal and so they wouldn't use the surname. We even do this in English, like referring to Captain Picard as Picard. I'd therefore expect Japanese readers to use Sendai and Miyagi for the reason you say.

Though of course, in the webnovel version, their first and last names get drilled into us a lot more than they will in comic version with monthly updates.

last edited at Nov 3, 2026 11:01AM

joined Jul 26, 2024

Now we've seen the face of true evil and that face is Tsukasa. Or at least, Tsukasa is admitting that she's messing with them. That's a change from giving some not-quite-plausible excuse that Hajime can use to delude herself into interacting with Tsukasa more.

I think Tsukasa is just that desperate for attention and validation? I'm not sure what else could be going on here. It reads like Tsukasa wants Sayama to chase her more, but also wants Hajime around as a backup. Tsukasa hasn't shown a strong attachment to either of them insomuch as Tsukasa wants a void filled. Maybe that was the reason for the breakup in the first place.

joined Jul 26, 2024

Did they kiss on this page?
https://dynasty-scans.com/chapters/weve_been_reincarnated_theres_no_way_im_giving_you_my_mana_again_ch22#8

Rachel seemed pretty against kissing in chapter 9. I thought their first kiss was gonna be a bigger deal for them, or did they already kiss in a different chapter?

I'm pretty sure they didn't. Rachael's head is above her, but we see why in the later panels.

joined Jul 26, 2024

Oh, you're definitely jealous. And finally starting to realize your own feelings as well. ^_^

hmm if only that was the case fr

Laughs hollowly, stares into distance

What. How could things possibly not escalate from here. What are you even doing, Miyagi.

It turns out not even Miyagi knows the answer to that question.

joined Jul 26, 2024

I hope there aren't misunderstanding so that Yuni can claim fuuko back :v idk I hate that glasses girl. Hopefully it's just as I described it cause i wanna see more yuni abd fuuko

If the author wants to go for the happyish ending, they could go with Mashiro reevaluating her beliefs when Fuuko finds someone. Since Mashiro thinks she and Fuuko are the same, either she can decide she was wrong about them being the same or she was wrong about them being able to be loved and chosen by someone. Maybe she also realizes she did love Fuuko and was just afraid to admit to herself and risk Fuuko's rejection.

Her whole ploy could end up being weak and short lived if it begins and ends with that no one would ever choose Fuuko or herself. She doesn't seem like that much of a mastermind in reality, just someone with emotional issues.

joined Jul 26, 2024

The author did a very natural feeling progression with Yuni here. She is still being wishy washy, but is becoming more self aware. A lot of stories, the MC would go "I need to save Fuuko after all" with no setup and then we get a cheesy-but-cute ending.

Yuni being mean and dishonest while trying to help both Nanase and Fuuko feels new while still being believable. It's a good setup for her to call Mashiro out. Yuni doesn't have to portray any of them morally righteous when she can say "So what? Aren't you worse?"

joined Jul 26, 2024

I think the idea is that Rachael was being careless by not trimming her nails. Since people are very fragile compared to what Rachael is familiar with, she needs to be extra careful to avoid killing or seriously injuring someone.

Going the domestic violence route in response does feel mean spirited. The execution is similar to the older "violence against boys is funny if a girl does it" trope, where the idea is that they couldn't really damage the boy physically or emotionally. There is a similar physical power imbalance here. It was never a good style of humor, though. I don't care for it here either.

joined Jul 26, 2024

I do think it makes sense that people who like reading those types of explanations and discussions would feel frustrated that this is so rarely a focus in bdsm fiction. Certainly it's a valid preference to have, the same way someone could like reading characters discussing detailed plans before they execute them.

We also probably shouldn't entirely eschew author responsibility for how readers react to their story. Stories matter because they have some type of impact on the reader, which is bound to have some sort of social impact in turn.

In this story, we do see Io and Misa getting better at communicating and reading each other. If we compare to earlier chapters, it was much more of a mess between and we have at least a couple instances of Misa just going way too far. Despite some criticisms toward Io, like that Misa is the one doing everything for Io, I think Io also tries to encourage Misa and show Misa that it's okay for Misa to be herself. Misa has a lot of fears around disappointing Io that Io has tried to alleviate.

The story isn't some kind of relationship manual, but there is good info in there.

rainbow8 also pointed out some people say there is more of a focus on intuiting the other partner's needs in Japanese BDSM:

https://dynasty-scans.com/forum/topics/20745-a-face-you-shouldn-t-show-discussion?page=18#forum_post_971396

Emphasizing that doesn't seem entirely bad to me. Compared to what we see in the story, I would definitely hope there would be more communication beforehand, as well as an agreed upon way for either partner to communicate to stop everything (ie a safe word or similar). Otherwise, what we see seems to be getting closer to what a healthy relationship dynamic would look like, at least in between all the pre-communication and safe wording.

last edited at Sep 28, 2026 5:36PM

joined Jul 26, 2024

There can be some real world harm from some readers thinking they can skip communication irl. On the other hand, it would be boring for every story to devote months of updates to asking around dungeons and being taught the same US centric BDSM terms and ideology.

It's also common for people in stories to not explain their plans until the last possible second, even though that makes no sense at all. Stories are not real life and follow different conventions, at least most of the time.

I know nothing about SM relationships, so I actually felt bad for Io when she ran up crying to clean up. How is that supposed to be adorable? (Genuinely asking, not being sarcastic).

Also, I didn't find that part particularly adorable on an emotional level. However, it was good characterization in terms of showing Io has these hangups around getting things dirty that she is willing to push past for Misa. The implication is that's why she was licking the floor earlier, for instance, as she felt bad about getting the food Misa gave her on the floor. We also see Misa acting in a caretaking way toward Io, so it's mutual from both of them that they are trying to act in each other's welfare.

A person's willingness to deal with difficult things for the sake of one's partner is generally viewed positively. It can lead to the couple feeling closer while trusting each other more. Part of why people like BDSM is because they can intentionally create these types of situations in a safe way. It can be moving to the dominant that someone would trust them that much, while the submissive can have a sense of safety from feeling it's okay to be vulnerable and trust someone.

There is this whole dynamic of Io getting to experience that she doesn't have to be like the perfect person she was raised to act like and Misa learning it can be safe for her to get attached to someone and open up to them. That really can be adorable.

Re: pee and Io specifically, Io has been shown to react to this in a sexual way in the earlier arc where Io peed herself and Misa cleaned Io. Io generally reacts to embarrassment in a sexual way, at least when it comes to Misa. It's also possible that someone might like something even if they didn't react to in a sexual way for the reasons I described earlier, but that's very much not the case here. Then the earlier comment does apply.

last edited at Sep 27, 2026 4:40PM

joined Jul 26, 2024

@Ennesan

can we please not

Too late. As readers we are already trapped. By the time they start vomiting on each other as a casual greeting each morning, we will have no escape.

last edited at Sep 26, 2026 4:02PM

joined Jul 26, 2024

Shitposted too close to the sun...

At least MrEngenious was magnanimous enough to allow amnesty for existing shitposts.

Though yeah, it's way too easy to cross the line where it stops being funny to someone and starts being uncomfortable. That's why I limited myself to attributing an opinion that wouldn't get me banned if it were my real opinion. I laughed too though.

last edited at Sep 20, 2026 10:25AM

joined Jul 26, 2024

Hanasaki Manio got a new manga out with a pretty similar vibe to this one.
It's called "I Like the You Who Bullies Me"

Hopefully I don't regret reading this, but if anything this is an even more aggressive start than Kitanai Kimi ga Ichiban Kawaii. The bullying scenes are like something out of To Not Die (https://www.webtoons.com/en/drama/to-not-die/episode-1/viewer?title_no=3787&episode_no=1) and we have the "victim" assertively peeing themselves in chapter 1. I think I can say that without it being a spoiler since that would get a watersports tag on here

joined Jul 26, 2024

oh no, it's ex-gf time

Oh yeah? I'm thinking it's Misa's mom whovh mean biiig trauma income. That's why she locked Io up in a panic.

nah it's her ex-lover. she showed up in a brief flashback ch17

It wasn't established whether it was her mom, her lover or someone else entirely. We can only hope it's not both, but, with this author, we can't rule anything out.

joined Jul 26, 2024

I feel there's three possible points people who defend Nanase miss:

Not quoting the entier post but the more backstory we got from Yuni and Fuuko, the more we got to understand them. Even though they act in a shitty way, we can at least understanding why they act that way. They both had difficult/traumatic experience and despite they awful action, they both have a lovely side. Fuuko is very caring and seems to truly love Yuni, and the way Yuni loves and cares for her mother is also very touching.

On the other side, Nanase is just super self-centered, and doesn't have anything good to balance that. So sure, she is not as bad, but she has nothing going for her, really. Honestly, she looks like a NPC with no inner thoughts. Enhanced why I think of her as just a plot device.

I think this is just to get us to empathize with Yuni more. A series were people cannot imagine themselves as the protagonist at all, even subconsciously, won't be successful.

Since Yuni is cheating, Nanase needs to feel like the worst and hardest to empathize with. At least, she needs to feel like the worst for Yuni. Otherwise people would just hate Yuni like they did early on and not continue with the series. Yuni and Fuuko don't need to feel "justified" to avoid that, but readers need to sympathize with them the most to balance out the discomfort caused by their misdeeds.

Nanase is loved by the volleyball team so, logically, she can't be all bad. They've made it amply clear they appreciate Nanase and enjoy spending time with Nanase even outside of sports. We don't see what Nanase does to make the team like her so much because this story is POV Yuni. The social dynamic around the team is a weird disaster like phenomenon that makes no sense to Yuni.

Even though we've been shown enough to understand Nanase has a positive impact on some people, the way the story is written makes the sports social dynamics feel like a natural disaster to the reader too. That is one well written aspect of this story.

last edited at Sep 19, 2026 9:39AM

joined Jul 26, 2024

Nanase is horrible but in a very mundane way. It’s not her fault she’s just a bit of an idiot fratboy cursed to be a lesbian who let’s be honest are usually pretty insane. She wouldn’t be like an officer or anything but if it came down to it Nanase would probably be a Nazi

That uh sure took a twist

It's even harder to stop myself from posting fan fiction Nanase going on fascist adjacent "just asking questions" rants while pretending to be clueless than it was to avoid ball jokes.

Anyway this is now canon. Sorry everyone. Nanase is alt-right. As we speak, is probably posting some screed online about how affirmative action is discriminatory and people should earn sports scholarships through own effort if they want to get ahead.

There's a reason why we don't see Nanase's twitter account.

last edited at Sep 18, 2026 11:01PM

joined Jul 26, 2024

Yuni really hates balls. The jokes write themselves, so I won't do so.

Totally possible that Nanase just did not even register her as a person until middle school and Yuki thought they were besties cuz Nanase defended her from bullies.

Given Nanase's personality, I could see it being the case that she would not remember what was a very big deal for Yuki. I believe this is the real explanation.

Yuki unmasking makes me think we are near the end. It's abrupt for her to suddenly do it with no set up after many years of masking, but it would fit if we are wrapping up.

They could end this next chapter and it would be a better set up than so many yuri, so it ending in the next few chapters wouldn't surprise me. It's been a good run. We just need a little setup for Yuni to rescue Fuuko rather than continuing with Yuni's passive self defeating behavior.

joined Jul 26, 2024

It's the second most wholesome pee arc after Yuri SM de Futari no Kimochi wa Tsunagarimasu ka?.

joined Jul 26, 2024

And here we having a loving callback to the day Io peed herself in front of Misa, leading to their current relationship. The difference is that, this time, Misa is the one asking Io to pee herself and thereby demonstrating the strength of their relationship.

Okay, even I'm not totally sold here, but it probably makes sense to anyone who likes pee as much as the author and Misa seemingly do. Otherwise it was a cute chapter. Of course Misa shouldn't do this long term without breaks, but I'll be surprised if she intends such.

joined Jul 26, 2024

Seeing the dog's reaction to Rachael will be interesting. Either the dog will be afraid of her or else the dog will be very impressed with this super dog who stands above wolves.

joined Jul 26, 2024

I was thinking of reading the LN of this it's up to three volumes so far. But I heard by the third volume they're is basically some weird ass love pentagram with a bunch of people and that kinda put me off on it so I'll pass on that for now lol.

If that's true, I'm likely not to keep reading it. This type of thing is rarely executed well. Usually "dueling love interests" happens because the author is not going to develop the character and relationship of the main interests and resorts to throwing in some external conflict from another surface level character.

So far it's been well written, so I'll stick around to see where the comic ends up for now.