Hum...Tell me if I'm wrong but , chapters 11 and 12(english) were already released sometimes ago right? Because I remember that I've read them .

That was a different scanlatison group doing a considerably different translation--I'm pretty sure the previously available English translation was from the Spanish translation (that's not exactly high-level linguistic detective work--the panel in this translation that reads "But, even so" was "sin embargo" in the other one).

The dialogue in the two translations is sometimes unrecognizable. . .

Yeah, the individual who did the "me lol" translations was machine translating from spanish to english.

Isn't sacrificing soul to banish your classmates to the netherworld a bit too much for high school bulies ?

Being evil (at this point, it's outright, stupidly evil) doesn't prevent you from having a brain, does they really think their action will have no consequences ?

The comically evil side girls definitely feel a bit incongruent with the relatively down to earth main pair, which is part of why I like that there's an explanation behind it. It's easier to swallow their shitty behaviour knowing that they are bound by magic to be heartless dickheads.

So, it sounds like the hearts of witches are destroyed or dead in some way, and Mari's AoE Revive spell from Chapter 2 accidentally revived Alice's heart

That's a good point. Witches having dead hearts would explain why all the side girls are such dickheads.

That's poetic, I guess, but it makes zero sense for biology. On the other hand, we're assuming magic exists, so screw biology, right?

Alice's theory is that she started feeling like this after Mari "healed her heart," so I think this is definitely a "screw biology" situation.

So, it sounds like the hearts of witches are destroyed or dead in some way, and Mari's AoE Revive spell from Chapter 2 accidentally revived Alice's heart, allowing her to fall in love (and then she fell in love with Mari).

Mari is obviously some weird special case. She doesn't seem to have a ridiculously traumatic past (unlike the other witches), so she had no special hatred of humanity and displays a much broader range of emotions. The demon calls her "tainted one", which could also imply something is different with Mari.

That's a good point. Witches having dead hearts would explain why all the side girls are such dickheads.

An office lady who is older than she looks offers to let her younger niece or cousin stay with her while she is in the country for college. The niece is taller now and much more mature looking and they begin to have a physical relationship, the older one starts it because she believes she is lonely and she doesn't want her to leave, but she realizes later that she is in love with her.

This.

Really brave of Kurumi to decide that once for all.
And, in the end, I do hope Nika stay with Jun. Seriously, she's not that into Kurumi, she's just a rebound, that's why Jun is the healthier and reasonable choice. If these girls get together in the end, depends how they make this story happens, it will be too unconvincing.

I really don't see where you're coming from here. There is still some ambiguity on what kind of love Nikaidou is feeling, sure, but I think it's abundantly clear that she has very strong feelings for Kurumi. It can turn out either way, and it'd still make sense to me.

Holy, that last chapter wasnt supposed to make me cry jsdbhasd

I definitely think it was supposed to make you cry. It got me too. Pretty heartbreaking.

Blessed. I love wholesome Kodama.

I still think it should end up polyamorous but y'all know my inclinations. I think everything should.

Same!

When you're poly it's hard not to see that as a resolution to a lot of love triangles lol

I guess I just don't see it here. Neither of them have any interest in Izumi.

I actually buy the magazine online (on Kindle, though I read on my phone mostly). This series and one other (nobody has translated it, Sorairo Melancholic) always get read first and I am always waiting for the next issue and checking to see if it's out yet like a month early.

I've actually been wondering about Sorairo Melancholic myself. I really liked Cotton Candy, so it has my interest. If you have the raws, you could post them on yuri-project and see if it garners any interest from a translator?

Though, it kinda feels like the story might be approaching it's climax, can't see how much you could stretch out the main story without some really contrived drama.

I think we're nearing the endgame too, though I haven't read any further than chapter 10 yet. That said, we also have to resolve Kyou-chan's feelings. I've failed to accurately predict anything that's happened so far, so really, I have no idea what will happen from here.

If you think the cliff hangers hurt now, wait till you realize that we're only 2 chapters behind the raws and the magazine it's in is quarterly.

last edited at Jan 1, 2020 8:57PM

Tsurezure Biyori - Ch 17 - One of my absolute favourite confession chapters.

Yuridori Midori - Kisa and Saki and the red thread of fate - fun premise, very fluffy.

Walk Wit Me - A two-parter with a very atypical setting for yuri and some pretty dark themes.

Her Tale of Shim Chong - I'd recommend this a thousand times over, but I'm not sure it's allowed to be uploaded here since it's officially licensed in English. However, the first two chapters are free to read on their site, so maybe they're allowed here as well? Not sure.

Oh I sort of like Izumi and Akazawa together

Same, but to be fair, I'd ship Izumi with literally anyone so long as it means she'll stop meddling with Kanade and Nanaki.

Also, I fail to see the point of bringing up "Bloom Into You", that was explicitly a series about romance, it called it such since the beginning, and the whole point was that the main couple went beyond mere friends

Have you ever considered judging a work by what actually happens within the text of the work rather than whether or not a scanlator places an explicit label on it to tell you how you're supposed to feel about it

Hagino calls the story "girlship" and prefers not to label it a yuri work because, to her, the story is about the feelings that exist between our two lead girls, and she doesn't want to confine those feelings by putting specific labels or expectations on them. That's all she's said on the matter as far as I'm aware. Maybe that means they won't ever come out and kiss, maybe it means that they will but that they don't want to be simplified to just that, maybe it means any number of things. Mostly it means we should judge the text by what the text itself does rather than obsessively parsing the occasional author's tweet or bookstore genre label to tell us what we're supposed to think about the story.

It's gotten really tedious to see every thread on this story go back and forth in a frenzy of "BUT SHE SAID ITS NOT" instead of ever actually discussing the actual manga IMO

What's there to discuss about the manga itself? Wow, another chapter of angsty drivel where the two girls wallow around in sadness and fail to communicate. Truly, the peak of drama writing.

SillieHonka posted:

Can we get lolicon and ecchi/NSFW tags? Really would have appreciated the warning.

They're clearly in high school. Ecchi/NSFW for 1 shot of panties? That's a overkill.

Maybe a chapter specific Ecchi / NSFW tag, only for the first chapter. It's not recurring, but one huge shot of it in a chapter with only 4 pages is still pretty significant.

should we be expecting lots of releases now that yuri project has picked this up?

That is the hope!

Hino totally knows Koguma is following her, and she's going to make her wear it out of guilt.

I love this manga so much. Hmm? Oh, that's all i wanted to say~ ^^
Hope it get an english physical release one day~

I don't post often on Internet but I'm also interested in an English physical release, and while browsing the website of Seven Seas Entertainment ( a publisher that ... published Bloom Into You; Kase-san;GirlFriends and others yuri manga in English ) and they have a poll on the upper right of their website where they ask for suggestion. Maybe if we are enough to ask for Hana Ni Arashi maybe they will publish it? They seem to listen to their community.

( Obligatory sorry for any mistakes, I'm from baguette land )

Link?

Seems to be this.

The first chapter has Tsutsuji as Kida and ch4 names her as Honda Tsutsuji. Which is the correct reading of her name?

It is in fact Kida. Sorry about that!

I kinda don’t get it. Why Satou thought she’s in love with Miki when she’s just asking her dress style?

I think it's more about how she hates the idea of Miki getting a boyfriend, and how she's always been unusually attracted to Miki's looks and personality (relative to other girls).

Nooo a hiatus! I get it. I was spoiled. I was enjoying these regular updates too much.

If you don't see it yet the raws are very interesting right now

Use spoiler tags when discussing content not yet uploaded to Dynasty.

@ironwolf69 Yeah, that was fantastic! I really appreciated getting to see Nanoha have a "god, I want to marry her" moment, especially since it wasn't played for laughs.

I love the idea of following the story of these two all the way until their wedding (and even beyond if we are so lucky).

Am I the only one who feels it's very unfair for Chidori to be the only one to apologise? She had done absolutely nothing wrong by having an innocent, platonic, private conversation with a friend, and Nanoha isn't entitled to knowing everything Chidori talks about with everyone she meets. If anything, Nanoha is the one who should be apologising and promising she wouldn't do it again. This sets a bad precedent in the relationship.

I think you need to reread. Chidori was not the only one to apologize. She first decided to apologize of her own volition here, and she apologizes to Chidori and says tells her should be the one apologizing instead of Chidori here. She also apologizes again and says she was worrying too much here.

Just for the sake of being open and transparent, I contacted White Garden about this series on Nov 4th, and had their version of Ch 11 fully typeset by Nov 11th. We've been in the "quality checking" phase since then. I'm not clear on what exactly is holding up the process, but if you have experience quality checking and are willing to help, you can contact them here.

Hayama Sensei To Terano Sensei Ha Tsukiatteiru

Wait... the translator is dropping it because it was licenced?

...

FUCK!

Well, Squiggles is no longer actively ruining it, so at least there's that.

last edited at Dec 19, 2019 7:54AM

And i'm one who get asked if i read comments.I never say that it's unrealistic to act childish, i ask if acting mature will have been less realistic.

The confusing part to me is that your complaint seems to be predicated on the idea that they're not going to talk to each other. Of course they're going to communicate and talk through their problems. They're just being stubborn and taking their sweet time about it. It's their first relationship; they're not equipped with the knowledge of how to deal with fights with their significant other (see: Nanoha in Ch 69, thinking about how she screwed up and she didn't expect it to turn out this way). In that sense, yes, it would be less realistic to immediately solve it, because neither of them have experienced fighting with their partner prior to this.

I think this is one of the many situations in life where you have to get it wrong before you can get it right.