I guess in a way it's kind of interesting to me how much different experiences contrast here. Maybe it's because I genuinely really like Takeshima Eku, and while I think she has her issues her I do think she's a good writer in my opinion. I might be one of the few people in this community that loves Whispering You a Love Song. Other people seem to think less of her, and that's fine.
As I've said previously we all have our opinions, same with how some people think this work is extremely shallow but I thought the depth was good. I didn't think it tried to make me feel sad and I thought it delivered the backstory well. I thought the couple's chemistry was fantastic. I also thought we got good fluff with the hug, the kiss, plus the way they smile at each other. Those are all reasons why I really enjoyed the work, and as I said in another comment it's like I'm reading an entirely different work than the people that didn't like it, since the reactions are so opposite in every way possible. I never expected this work to be so divisive, especially with how happy it made me feel when I was reading it from start to finish. It is what it is though, and I suppose I'll be a bit more mentally prepared for this kind of split with Takeshima Eku's future works lol