Forum › Posts by kingtiger

Rise192_78
joined Aug 22, 2013

Huh. I think this is the first chapter where one of them hasn't mentioned the villainess's ability to go at it for 3 days and 3 nights. They were surprisingly consistent with that particular line.

but I feel like they reverse mentioned it when the dude just pumped and dumped and it didn’t even last three minutes XD

kingtiger
Rise192_78
joined Aug 22, 2013

Awww I loved this last chapter with Mayoi… obviously love all the romantic couples and interactions but somehow these non-romantic moments where people connect are my favs. This chapter with Mayoi, the one where the Kanae goes to the beach with everyone iirc and is kind of sulking off to the side then grumbles about how everyone is being so childish but then like Miyoshi or someone calls her over to join and she comes out of her shell because she feels included, and then the one where Honoka and Kaoru are making pancakes together… those moments are probably my favorite memorable moments.

Rise192_78
joined Aug 22, 2013

So does this mean I should make a plant as my wingman?

Rise192_78
joined Aug 22, 2013

Cute, but do people really match up on dating apps just looking for friends? And also hide their gender?

In China a lot of straight woman use Tinder to find female friends.

kingtiger
Rise192_78
joined Aug 22, 2013

this was made on the 10th this year... idk why people are making assumptions

Because they are Sinophobes.
You can find comparable poppycock in the comments section for every manhua in the forum.
It's sad.

It's not sinophobic to be worried about a government attempting to restrict LGBT representation. My worry is for the Chinese people that write & read this stuff. Apparently the government there has implemented new laws restricting LGBT representation in entertainment.

I don't know whether this was a Chinese or Taiwanese publication or how far those laws extend. I just wanted some context as to where this was published and it's relation to the new Chinese law.

I get that you're coming from a good place, but your concern would be much better placed on irl LGBT rights NGOs rather than creators of gay manhuas on the internet. FYI, censorship is rampant in China and it's bad, but it only affects "mainstream" stuff like published books and TV series. But even then it just removes the explicit and steamy parts, the gay is still retained.

Just look at the sheer number of BL animations and manhuas that get published each year and you'll understand. (They bring in huge money) They can never kiss explicitly on screen, but every single audience knows that they're gay through keywords and tropes.

Also, it IS kind of irritating to see "China is bad and has banned all gay stuff so how can this exist?!" in every GL manhua in here so I hope you'll understand where our frustration stems from.

My worries are on the actual people, I just didn't think that was relevant to this Manhua's comment thread in particular. But I know Chinese law would be and I really don't understand it much. I asked hoping someone here would know about the publish location & how Chinese law affects production of these works, as that's relevant to the work itself.

I believe the strip is posted on their weibo aka the Mainland Chinese equivalent of Twitter. So it’s not so mainstream as say a physical book published by a publishing house or say a tv show on broadcast TV (but not really sure how relevant it is because most of the popular shows are online shows only). Does it need to abide by local law yes, but at the same time it’s kind of like is anyone paying any attention to it (this strip)? It’s probably fine until as someone else has said, it becomes mainstream and or a billion people are following, commenting and discussing. Were the comic to take place in real life, a child holding up a fan that has a heart with two women in it would not be enough to be censored, it’s not as someone else has said “explicit” enough. It’s not like you display gay and then you’re whisked away to prison… if that happened in Mainland the camera operators (if they knew what it meant) may not even focus on it, and even if they did it’s “innocent” enough to not really flag on anyones radar.

To add more nuance to the background information there’s online comic readers like Kuai Kan that have Yuri (both Chinese and translated from Japanese and Korean), and they seem to be fine (probably because it’s a comic so it’s more niche). There’s a comic called Shuang Jing (which also has an online series, not sure which one came first) , about a female assassin and a female writer… I think it’s pretty obvious for those in the know but it would fly over other people’s heads for those not in the know (most other people)

TLDR, it’s more nuanced than display gay and go to jail.

kingtiger
Rise192_78
joined Aug 22, 2013

KT really knows how to frame a shot both for foreground and background characters

kingtiger
Citrus + discussion 20 Dec 18:21
Rise192_78
joined Aug 22, 2013

Wait I’m so confused… I thought Glasses-Senpai was the same age as Mei Yuzu and Harumin/also in the student council… I also got the impression that Harumin and her sister had a bigger age gap like 5+ years……. did I miss something or did Citrus+ retcon that/make a new plot hole?…

kingtiger
Rise192_78
joined Aug 22, 2013

Ngl, I think this is too good to ever be adapted into an anime. It just couldn't be done enough justice I think.
Probably my favourite yuri manga of all time.

I can't disagree . . . but at the same time, I'd really love to see a clip or two of certain characters in action. For instance, I gotta feel Mahi-Mahi would be even more of a force of nature if they were moving and making noise.

Haha agree with both of you but definitely agree about the Mahi-Mahi comment… I feel like the manga club chapters might be good too, when we see their concepts drawn out and also when they’re the manga trope themselves…

That is some highly advanced flirting right there

Riiight? How did he even come up with this concept and the way he executed it is amazing. Also are we to infer that each color shot was a snap on Michiru’s phone? Sneaky sneaky

Yuu is calling out all your asses. Not me of course. I though it would be under bra.
think
Nah, I did not. This manga is too cute and (oddly enough) pure for this type of location. I expected somewhere on the back of her legs or something.

Im not sure if the time Ayano and Miyoshi painted pubic hair on their underwear supports or disproves the manga being oddly pure Hahaha… on the other hand yeah, that location would have been too direct for Airi…

Also loved the goodnight moon reference haha

kingtiger
Rise192_78
joined Aug 22, 2013

Just listening MAMAMOO-Destiny while reading it, because I thought they would go well together.

I think "I Miss You" works very good as well.

Also, good art but "ugh" at that first chapter. So tired of seeing this storyline. But, I am going to read it. Sometimes I like pain.

Wow never thought I’d see fellow Moomoos in my yuri lol

kingtiger
Rise192_78
joined Aug 22, 2013

Wait, did the series low key say that Anna (the granddaughter) was in a relationship with a woman? In the beginning she said she was moving in with another divorced mom and then in this last chapter Riri says her mom and the other mom fight a lot…

Thematically, not sure how that plays out? I’m all for more yuri, but I wonder if Anna’s relationship is also meant to be a mini foil to her grandmother’s relationship with Kiyoko?

kingtiger
Rise192_78
joined Aug 22, 2013

That rain chapter though… as much as I like stories about the couples, the group chapters are my fav. Externally I’d probably be more like Kanae and check the weather, but internally I’d definitely be Team Adventurous Spirit… especially Miyoshi lol

last edited at Oct 10, 2021 7:39PM

kingtiger
Rise192_78
joined Aug 22, 2013

Does anyone have the problem where they get to the last page of chapter one and they click next but it goes to chapter three?

kingtiger
Rise192_78
joined Aug 22, 2013

YESSSSSSSSSSSSS I Love these sisters together! And you know what's the best? is like the honey and wieners, you wouldn't think they would be good together but once you get a taste, you can't stop! (but I won't try the recipe, I want an oneesan to feed me).

But yeah, emphasis in these sisters, they have totally different styles and taste, only thing in common would be their sexual orientation xD and yet Kaoru loves her sister so much! that's so cute! still waiting for the moment she sees Eli with her sister, she will realize immediately what's going on and that moment will be great.

Thank you very much for the chapter!

I just commented on their relationship myself, lol- I totally agree! As I mentioned before, the only time I really care for Kaoru is when she's shown with Honoka. And I totally agree about Kaoru picking up on things right away- she's got a sixth sense for those things, after all.

Also: can you imagine the chaos if Kaoru and Eli teamed up to get Honoka to admit her feelings? I have a feeling those two would hit it off IMMEDIATELY- which would of course be a disaster for Honoka.

I wish someone compile a list of Kaoru&Honoka chapters, they’re fun to see

When the tags were originally being set up I was wondering if there should also be individual character tags… sometimes I feel like when Character X shows up as background to another couple’s story it adds to Character X’s development/shows another side of Character X and/or you have non romantic interactions like with Honoka and Kaoru.

Also has anyone tried this? I feel like with Chinese/Japanese hot dogs it would work because they tend to be more sweet than savory… i wonder how it would be with American hot dogs which tend to be more savory…

kingtiger
Rise192_78
joined Aug 22, 2013

I’m okay without the cleanup. Whatever is easier for you! The translations are already greatly appreciated!!!

kingtiger
Kill Switch discussion 13 Aug 09:16
Rise192_78
joined Aug 22, 2013

Actually, what she's feeling is Envy, Jealousy is feeling like something you already have is under threat, whereas Envy is wanting something that you can't have.

That's an interesting distinction that I can see being useful, but I don't think those words actually are distinct that way in either dictionary definitions or usage.
I have a similar thing--I like to see a distinction between ethics and morals, where ethics are grounded in some kind of philosophical principle, while morals are based in community standards, religious strictures and similar authority-based foundations, and may from an ethical position be completely arbitrary. Note that religious texts can contain ethical principles, like "Do unto others as you would have others do unto you". So in this scheme, for instance, disapproving of gays is a moral position, not an ethical one, since all the justifications for it ultimately come down to "God says" or "That's what the community thinks", but nobody ever advances any actual reasons why gayness is a bad thing.
I think it's a useful distinction and I think there's some basis for it in usage, but in the end I can't really defend it. Pity.

I completely agree with you on the separation of these concepts. There is also morality and spirituality. Many people also confuse these words. Sometimes morality and ethics are used interchangeably. I recommend looking at examples on this topic on [link removed] where, in addition to essays, you can read summaries and research papers on ethics. When a distinction is made between the two terms, speaking of morality, they mean mainly external behavior, and by morality, a system of intrinsic motivation. For me, ethics is a discipline that studies morality and ethics, and spirituality in secular vocabulary often means a person's cultural life.

How can we thumbs up a thread?

last edited at Jun 29, 2023 9:54PM by OrangePekoe

kingtiger
Rise192_78
joined Aug 22, 2013

but what happened to Ise-san’s dog?????? Haha

But I’m kinda conflicted. On the one hand the way they live with each other is such a cute married couple vibe… on the other I really appreciate how they can be that close with each other (without the closeness being driven by romance… it’s like even more romantic that it’s not being drive by romance but something else… common goals? Similar outlooks on life (curiosity and wanting to explore new things)… Some of my best friends are straight (myself being gay) and there’s just no waaaaay I have that kind of relationship with them…. I don’t think I could ever live with any of them (even though similar life values… I don’t think similar life habits so we probably wouldn’t be good roommates and I don’t “love” them enough to make exceptions lol)…… and as I’m writing this out I wanna see conflict between the and how it gets resolved lol… I feel like that’s the biggest indicator of whether a relationship makes or breaks…. The last chapter seemed to add in a foreshadow so maybe I’ll get my wish haha.

Until then I’ll reread from the beginning…. Knowing what we know now about Shima and the fact that Ise knows puts everything else in a different perspective.

kingtiger
Rise192_78
joined Aug 22, 2013

I’m sorry you lost your buddy. May your memories of him live on through you and may he Rest In Peace.

kingtiger
Rise192_78
joined Aug 22, 2013

I think if they were younger it would be cute (and either both were not knowledgeable and/or one of them was knowledgeable enough to guess that it was impossible/but not sure……

But as it stands…. I don’t think it’s cute because it reminds me of this news about an adult couple in China who thought they could get pregnant just by lying on a bed together… and that just made me sad because it’s a huge sex education fail

kingtiger
Rise192_78
joined Aug 22, 2013

Just marathoned this whole thing… if I had read it chapter by chapter I’d probably be teetering on frustration at the glacial pace of development between Kurokawa and Fujishiro, but being able to read it all in one go, it’s left me with the impression that the series isn’t just about them but also relationship dynamics.

I like how this series explores the relationship dynamics between each of the characters. It’s almost like the relationship dynamic is it’s own character. Since it’s yuri it’s usually about whether character A gets with character B and the obstacles they have to overcome (between them). But I like how we get to see how one person getting close to another affects the relationship dynamic with the people that get “left behind”.

The series does a good job of portraying each character’s motivation on its own (even though they’re all sort of directly/indirectly connected to Fujishiro, with the exception of maybe Iroha)

it’s also amazing at how all the characters have grown since. looking forward to some hopeful development from Miki and not just a foil to Kurokawa/Fujishiro

kingtiger
Rise192_78
joined Aug 22, 2013

In the chapter 7 4koma was the original pronoun of the Sempai gender ambiguous or was it just translated that way?… too hopeful to be a female sempai?

kingtiger
Rise192_78
joined Aug 22, 2013

I would like to remind to everyone that Mio have always had these tendencies as visible in ch9
https://dynasty-scans.com/chapters/virgins_empire_ch09#12
Trololol

By the way I love this pair so much

The shift in art style going back this far is almost strong enough to give me whiplash. It's like going back a console generation. Also there's somebody's underwear like every third panel.

Lol what an apt metaphor... can’t believe it’s been almost 10 years since the first chapter!! But even back then with everyone’s underwear I think it was still a pretty realistic slice of life for high school girls... I remember reading it and thinking wow reminds me of the silly antics my classmates used to get up to back in the day.. I’d say the “fan service” has leveled up too... if before it seemed like the underwear flashing was meant for the reader, now it feels like it’s more earned for the characters/the characters enjoy it too vs the reader just being a voyeur.

Rise192_78
joined Aug 22, 2013

Jesus, that jumpscare on the credits page... Warn me next time.

Loooooool I was looking through the comments section to see if anyone would comment on the credits page... too adorable

Rise192_78
joined Aug 22, 2013

We certainly are getting a lot of “trouble in paradise” style slice of life yuri lately. Are the lesbian mangakas ok?

Maybe regular day-to-day "relatable" stuff seems marketable now.

Maybe it’s a sign of the times? Ex, lesbian relationships becoming more normalized/mainstream. I kind of like how we’re getting more adult life Yuri instead of just school girl Yuri (lots of but it’s forbidden love, figuring out your gay (but the ones where they just go for it are refreshing))... it’s nice where it’s already established they are a couple, since previously it was a lot of will they/won’t they/confessing.

kingtiger
Lily Marble discussion 14 Apr 08:46
Rise192_78
joined Aug 22, 2013

I wish there was an “MVP mom” tag or something so I could just read all the chapters with awesome supportive moms lol... I came out to my mom after I broke up with my ex and her supporting me was one of the best feelings ever... I know it doesn’t work out for everyone, but here’s a shoutout to all supportive parents everywhere! It really means a lot to your LGBTQ+ kids to be loved unconditionally

kingtiger
Rise192_78
joined Aug 22, 2013

Sanrai posted:

I hope we see more of miss crazy eyes. Even though this is meant to be a series about the troubles of high school days. Maybe a spin off?

Yes! we now know that Torajirou has a lot of potential for adult life too

I'd say not just adult life, but this chapter shows how Torajirou is awesome at capturing slice of life... this was pet owner life, pet life, and sibling life all rolled into one... I loved it!

hmmm Yuu... I wonder where Pearl gets here tsundere habits..... lololololol :D