Wtv posted:

Well...the action scenes are still pretty bad. It could pass as a professional work without them. But...
Anyway, I went to the page and saw that this manga was as "honorable mention". So the contest was over. I thought it weird that there wasn't one "winner", except by the big Murcielago image. Then I saw there's actually a 20th contest (this is the 19th).

http://www.square-enix.co.jp/magazine/yg/wanted/goldenegg/index.html

There's actually a 21th:

http://www.square-enix.co.jp/magazine/yg/wanted/

So...very old news? Unless I'm missing something.
This should be from the time Murcielago won.

I also didn't notice the contest was over, "honorable mention" , so much for "it won't win anything" and " worse than most doujins" xD, not complaning, I don't think it was so bad, but would never change winner for it or any other manga, Murcielago was definitely the best choice~~

Nezchan posted:

Now who's the one with the over the top hyperbole?

Well I am a yuri fan too, so of course I need to be exaggerated and dramatic.

koneko posted:

of course yuri fans are biased they are YURI FANS!

A true yuri fan is always a biased drama queen! So of course I'm the same, I just restrain myself.

True, lots of non-yuri fucked up mangas are considered shitty by some, but it's not only about mangas, people love to say how something they don't like is shitty, in the end what is shitty or not is more about opinion than anything else.

Wtv posted:

There's no way this will get a series or this mangaka will get work in the future.
They probably didn't anything more to put in the contest, but if all the others works aren't better than this, I fear for Japan's mangas future.

No way this will become a series or the mangaka will get work in the future? Okay, now that's just plain ridiculous, not only you, but pretty much everyone here is giving extremely biased opinions, you're all judging based on visuals, cause we don't have any idea how the story really is without translation, this is from Young Gangan, the same magazine of Murcielago, so if this won the contest it actually means that not only the art was considered good but the story was too, so it actually has high chances of becoming a series.

Really, in the past I wondered why a lot of people hate yuri fans, but I learned why here on Dynasty, it's because a lot are drama queens who act entitled as if all yuri belongs to them, who whine at any subtext that is crushed because it ended in het even though it was obviously never going to end in yuri, who whine when it had lesbian or bisexual character who could have ended with another girl even though yuri was never promised, Working and Stretch are good examples of that, not to mention the simple fact that people hate how fucking biased yuri fans can be, so what, just because this is yuri it can't have rape? Can't have tragedy? Can't have a bad ending? A lot of non-yuri manga have it, there's no reason yuri can't have too.

This manga is nothing special, there's countless of non-yuri mangas that are as fucked up or more than this, only reason most of you are hating is because it's yuri, this is not a bad or shitty manga, the fact that it won the contest is more than enough proof of that, there's mangakas who live only doing mangas that are extremely fucked up, not to mention mangakas who do hentais that are even more fucked up, I really hope this becomes a series, not only because it has potential, but because yuri need to stop being cliche, all other genres have more variety of types of stories, why yuri can't have too? Of course yuri will never stop being niche if all mangas we have are pretty much all the same shit, some of you might not like it, but we need different types of yuri manga, even the ones like this.

And I'm only mentioning mangas, there's also a lot of visual novels, ovas, animes, light novels and other media that is more fucked up than this.

last edited at Jan 8, 2016 6:17PM

I'm not sure it's necessary, all readers use the magazine version so the order they have in the tankobon don't really matter, you would just lose time to kill my curiosity.

last edited at Jan 8, 2016 1:22PM

Now I wonder if they only inverted "Tsuruga's Story 2" and "Tsuruga's Story 3" or if they changed the numbering of other chapters too, did you have a look at the chapters I posted link if they have the same numbering for you? As for the order in the tankobon, guess they decided to not leave the stories too spread out, which must be why there's chapter 1 and 2 together of some characters, next volumes follow the same pattern? Like for example, it has Kiyosumi 3 and Kiyosumi 4 together? Guess you don't really need to look if you don't want, I doubt someone will scan and translate or make typeset of the manga so it doesn't really matter for now, thanks for it anyway. o7

I think Corvus is spot-on here except for the fact of that hand. If Yuriko's meant to be holding Koro here some part of her should be visible there, unless Yuriko's got Kawhi Leonard's arms. And the way her hair's spread out suggests to me she's lying on her back.

I don't think Yuriko is holding Koro, it looks more like she's just lying on top of her, we can see clearly on page 29 that Koro is holding Yuriko, who have her hand on Koro head or just near her head, as for the middle panel it makes me think she's more or less in this position, like you said what make this panel confusing is how her hair's spread out, but if we ignore that we can easily assume she's still on top of Koro.

last edited at Jan 8, 2016 11:48AM

The author recently wrote some interesting stuff, and confirmed some endings and the yuri. If you can read Japanese, take a look if you like. Scroll down to tweets from Jan 3.

https://twitter.com/siraume_nazuna

Could someone translate those tweets?

last edited at Jan 8, 2016 8:52AM

Oshikko-sensei Starting From 3 Years Old - I - http://exhentai.org/g/888882/7941e81b82/

Alternate name in the back cover is Oshikko Sensei Zero-1st

YOUMU vs UDONGEIN - http://g.e-hentai.org/g/711380/f5041c1ff9/

KILL GEPPU COMPLETE - http://g.e-hentai.org/g/791241/73c75bbdaa/

Reitaisai 11 Report Manga - http://g.e-hentai.org/g/886050/269ee903bf/

Gerisa - http://g.e-hentai.org/g/886677/1860c8acb2/

ZuljinRaynor, I had a look again since you said in the manga chapters have different order and it seens they also changed the name of some, it seens they actually releseased YG and BG at the same time but had to stop releasing in YG.

You said chapter 1 BG is 11 "Tsuruga's Story 2" in the manga, but if we go see from magazine release chapter 1 YG is "Tsuruga's Story 1", chapter 15 YG is "Tsuruga's Story 2", chapter 1 BG is probably "Tsuruga's Story 3" (2 in the manga), chapter 21 YG is "Tsuruga's Story 4", chapter 19 BG is "Tsuruga's Story 5" and chapter 32 is "Tsuruga's Story 6".

You also said "Kiyosumi's Story 1" is not on Dynasty, it's because it have the same problem, half the story was released in YG, chapter 2 YG is "Kiyosumi's Story 1", chapter 9 YG is "Kiyosumi's Story 2", chapter 6 BG is "Kiyosumi's Story 3", chapter 20 YG is "Kiyosumi's Story 4", chapter 15 BG is "Kiyosumi's Story 5", chapter 24 BG is "Kiyosumi's Story 6" and chapter 44 BG is "Kiyosumi's Story 7".

If you look in the manga I believe you have a different order? Shame probably no one will ever scan the manga version.

Either way I still wonder why we don't have on Dynasty the 23 chapters of YG, especially because they have been translated by /u/ Scanlations who also did the first 11 chapters of BG that are uploaded here.

I'll do it then, thanks GendoIkari.

I never tried a different client as I don't know anything about IRC, so it probably is because I got caught in his IP range, I'll just wait then, as for the link in the banner, I still see link for IRC, but I remember it had at least one more link at it's right for Twitter or Facebook, don't really remember which one, all I know is that one day it disappeared and there's only link for IRC now.

last edited at Jan 7, 2016 5:28PM

All it says is == #dynasty-scans Cannot join channel (+b), the problem is not me cause I know others that have the same problem.

last edited at Jan 7, 2016 3:38PM

Kiena posted:

You're welcome Thiaguinho-sama, just don't end up like me. A few stories like that ate away my remaining hope for humanity. I hate it when fiction tries to compete with reality at which one can be more horrible. (Reply to the next post, just got in a time loop here.)

I don't really mind when they're horrible, it actually makes things more interesting and fun depending on the manga, guess I'm just a horrible person, and sorry for the post being out of order, kind of got distracted and deleted my post instead of editing it...

last edited at Jan 7, 2016 4:15PM

Kiena posted:

Also, did you find any other fucked up manga in your search...? I would like to have their names if you found any, sorry, I just can't resist xD

I was just looking for it here. If you look for the categories associated with it, you can easily come across those I encountered during my search. The sheer number of the results was creepy. Even the scanlation group is familiar, that's how I may have found it in the first place, and everything else seems to match, too, so I'm about 97% sure it's that one.

Right, I forgot that Mangaupdates have categories for this kind of thing, the number of results is both creepy and awesome, you also made me remember I need to find more mangas like Murcielago and Trash, it's fun to see main characters being fucked up, but it's more fun when they're the ones fucking up others, I already knew the cover of the manga but didn't expect it to be fucked up, I should have looked at it sooner, anyway, thanks for everything o7

And Serenata, about your question before, guess I am one of those who enjoy this kind of fucked up shit~~

Awesome, thanks, you're so nice~~

Also, did you find any other fucked up manga in your search...? I would like to have their names if you found any, sorry, I just can't resist xD

And I tell you later if it really is that manga, since you're not completely sure.

last edited at Jan 7, 2016 2:10PM

But serious now, I don't really care if they show the rape or not, I can see all rape I want in hentai, I'm just curious about what it is about and how it ends, same for Wolf Guy that I will definitely have a look later, if anything what get my interest is not the rape, but the character suffering and being subject of fucked up situations in general, so thanks for searching for it and for explaining the joke.

I didn't ask because of the rape itself, but because I'm curious about the manga where it happens, if I wanted manga just for rape I would search for hentai, what kind of person you think I am?

Okay I admit it was in part because of the rape, but I have a wide range of interests~~

And I didn't get the D&D and dice joke, a little explanation please?

last edited at Jan 7, 2016 1:41PM

There is nothing wrong with liking Boku no Pico... (>_>)

Reminded me of a manga I ran into in the past, in which young girls were sold then given to prisoners to mass rape and kill.

What manga it was? You remember the name? And I don't think having a heroine is some sort of fan service, it depends on how it's done.

last edited at Jan 7, 2016 1:09PM

Yeah, there are people who enjoy this and worse, if it becomes a series, either the first chapter will be a tragic beginning like this, or will be completely different without one of them dying, but I won't be surprised if it becomes a series cause it's the same magazine that publishes Murcielago.

I don't see what the problem with double standards, especially in a Yuri manga lol

I didn't say it was a problem, was just comparing to Mnemosyne, the only problem with double standards with this kind of setting is that it's going to have rape, which means lesbian main characters will definitely be raped too, like it just happened, double standards are not always good to us.

Also, I don't think she's more powerful, she just have self-control so she can fight, unlike male werewolfs who only want rape.

last edited at Jan 7, 2016 1:06PM

So it's a story about girls being sacrificed to rapist werewolfs, not only was she raped by that werewolf, but also mutilated and eaten by the girl she loves that turned into a werewolf too, what a happy end! Might not be so bad as a series, but definitely not for everyone, also, is it just me or it gave some Mnemosyne vibes? Male werewolfs are irrational monsters while female werewolfs are cute monster girls.

And what is the name of the mangaka? Does he/she have any other manga?

last edited at Jan 7, 2016 12:51PM

But Yuriko is using a long dress, to me what we see below her waist is her dress, she's still using it, if it was pulled up it would be obvious, and I agree the sex doesn't change anything, I don't get why some are making a big deal out of it.

Thanks ZuljinRaynor.

A little question about Saki Biyori, ins't Dynasty missing 23 chapters? Cause from what I remember those chapters on Batoto are not part of Saki Biyori BG uploaded here, what I know is that it was originally published in Young Gangan and then they changed to Big Gangan, so we have two Saki Biyori uploaded in all readers except Dynasty, at least from what I remember comparing with Batoto the first 23 chapters are not here, so if you could confirm that it is actually 67(23YG+44BG) chapters instead of only 44 that we have here...

last edited at Jan 7, 2016 11:11AM