…also am I crazy for wanting a poly ending where they include the boat lady?
No you're not, I immediately felt like there was some cute chemistry going on as well xD
Naaah, I’d rather it remain a couple in this case. Just a feeling I got. And honestly, they were much more forgiving of someone stealing their bike than I would have been.
I'd have been FORGIVING; I suppose it was an understandable mistake and she didn't take anything, including their so-essential wallets.
But they were acting downright GRATEFUL, and I wouldn't go that far. They're talking like it's thanks to her that they have their stuff . . . but sheesh, it's thanks to her that it was gone in the first place, so.
On the other hand, it's probably a good move. That girl is their first social contact on the island, and small communities run on social contacts. Cultivating her is a lot smarter than blowing her off would be, that's for sure. And she seems nice.
Yeah, they were definitely on the grateful side of things and that just feels wrong to me. Look, even if she sees this all the time, at least take it to the police or lost and found and let it sit for a day or two before claiming it. The only reason she didn’t keep it is because their belongings were in there. Otherwise she was going to do what she wanted with the bike, no questions asked.
I’m probably the only one that doesn’t think she’s incredibly nice, but that’s fine. Maybe she’ll warm up to me later on.
My interpretation of the line about being thankful was that they were thankful a nice well meaning person like her took it (and brought it back) rather than it getting taken by someone else who might have just robbed them and sold the bike.
I frequently ship poly but I'm not going to jump on this bandwagon quite yet, mostly because this couple is just too dang sweet and it seems like their relationship is pretty strong, based on the short background we have on them. Of course, this could be the high of doing something totally off the wall and fairly romantic and they could run into the cold hard realities of being an unemployed couple in a tourist area in the off-season VERY soon... And really, poly relationships are not for everyone and none of these characters have given any indication that they are poly.
I was really skeptical about the bike-taking diving instructor from the start. I don't care how often people dump working bikes on the beach around where you live, that really DOESN'T give you salvage rights to one that you found there without verifying that the owner isn't coming back for it in a couple of hours. Yeah, it probably wasn't in a legal parking spot, but she is also NOT a member of the police force and wasn't going to turn it in. She was making the assumption that it was a derelict vehicle that was only good for scrap until she found that there were purses with IDs and cash inside stored in it.
That said, I kind of understand why the two protagonists are soooo thankful to her for returning their own property... they were freaking starving and she showed up at just the right time to not only provide them with the means to purchase dinner but she also took them to one of the few open restaurants on her boat. She could have just left the bike in their front yard, knocked on the door, and run away (or hid). Then they would have opened the door, found the bike, and not known who it was that took it in the first place, but they also wouldn't have had any clue where to go to get food at that time of night and probably would have run all over the place until they found out that they needed to go to a different island to get food. So they probably would have ended up eating convenience store junk, if there was one available. For that matter, she could have just left the bike and not even let them know about it, figuring they'd find it in the morning.
Of course, having heard the exclamation that they were getting married while she was bringing their bike to them, she was interested in meeting these two anyway...
last edited at Jan 4, 2022 4:35PM