Who are you responding to? If you are responding to me, I don't think Yuu is aro or ace. I'm simply disagreeing with the idea that Nakatani isn't LGBT conscious at all. I think the manga presents plenty of evidence contrary to this.
The people who said it of course. I cant be bothered to quote them all.
It is good writing, but it's also making a clear statement. The two things aren't mutually exclusive. Sayaka's entire backstory is kind of a take down of the old S-class stories. Heck she even threw in some scenes to emphasize that Sayaka's attraction to girls is physical in nature, which is something that even some modern Yuri still don't do. I just find it hard to believe that at least part of Nakatani's motivation for Sayaka's arc wasn't to create a realistic teenage lesbian character. Like I don't think Nakatani is some LGBT scholar or anything, but judging from the manga it does seem that she has at least some awareness of these issues. The scene that most convinces me of this is actually not a Sayaka scene, it's when Yuu's dad makes that little joke about how shocked he'd be if she dated a girl and Yuu gets this brief downtrodden look. To me that demonstrates some awareness of how casual homophobia works.
P.S. I'm really getting tired of auto correct changing Yuu's name to you.
(Sorry for butting in)
With the way you put it, it is literally impossible to write a realistic lesbian character without making a statement. Rather than not being mutually exclusive you made them synonymous, which is also wrong.
Nakatani writes the characters realistically and a realistic lesbian deals with these kinds of things, but that doesn't exactly mean she is trying to make a message about the situation of lesbians in general. Some stuff just comes with the territory.
That bit about Yuu and her father for example, I did not interpret as a reaction towards the idea of her father being uncomfortable with a girlfriend, but rather Yuu just being troubled by Rei's suggestion itself. Just remember, when you go in reading with preconceived notions, you often see things that aren't there.
Now to be fair, I'm ambivalent towards the idea of Nakatani trying to send a message about lesbians in this story, that might be the case. It's definitiely not the point of the story though.
PS: Physical attraction in Yuri is far from rare these days.
last edited at Dec 7, 2018 7:30AM