Forum › Posts by Ultraxion

joined Mar 15, 2015

Can the teachers end up together? I want the teachers to end up together

I'll second this. I actually started seeing them as a viable couple after their heart-to-heart talk.

Ultraxion
joined Mar 15, 2015

oh! I never knew this was here. Bought three volumes of it not too long ago.

The fourth volume recently came out. It nicely wraps up the Blume election arc, but unlike the first three, there isn't much of a hook to get us interested in what will happen in the next volume.

Ultraxion
New Game discussion 07 Aug 19:34
joined Mar 15, 2015

Yeah, it kind of feels like the author kind of gave up on Hifumi's character arcs lately. She felt like a more important character in the early chapters, part of the main cast. Now it feels like she's been demoted to a complete side character. :\

I still feel this even in this chapter that's about her. It feels like she doesn't have any presence anymore.

I thought she had a pretty fine presence, she's still her awkward self but it was nice to see Hifumi deciding to take on Hajime for the sake of keeping their job smooth. I think she is gaining confidence, I'll agree it's been a slow progress since there had been a distinct lack of Hifumin but I like the chapter and would welcome more like these.

The plus point in this was the minimal newbies' (Momiji and Narumi) scenes.

I mostly agree with this, but I actually like Naru. She makes for an interesting foil to Nene, since while Nene's a bit childish and sometimes has trouble focusing, Naru's more mature(I can't see Nene helping out around the house like that) and driven to a fault. She also goes through a good amount of character development, particularly coming to acknowledge Nene's skill and determination, and going from not wanting to make any changes that would potentially delay the game (thus possibly reflecting badly on her), to being willing to work with Hajime on coming up with a new idea even though she might get in trouble. I also liked the story arc with her and her mother, particularly how both have valid points, and while the disagreement isn't fully resolved by the end, they do make a little progress in coming to understand each other.

joined Mar 15, 2015

a somewhat long-winded story about a girl loosing nearly any match she playes? Was an ok read... a bit booring at times

I agree. Part of the appeal of the first Little Army was showing that Maho was a more complex and sympathetic character than she seemed like at the time of her introduction, and showing that Miho did love tankery as long as she could do it with her friends, so the sequel didn't really have what made the original so compelling for me.

joined Mar 15, 2015

I agree that it should be turned into a series. This has "Chapter 1" vibes to it, setting up the premise for the series and introducing the main couple to each other. In addition to the two leads falling in love, the series could show the ex-magical girl adjusting to her life as a civilian.

Ultraxion
joined Mar 15, 2015

At first, I thought this was a Saki doujin, but then they were talking about panties, so can't be !

Joking aside, Momo talking like some pseudo gangsta felt seriously weird :/

I'm guessing it's an attempt to localize her "~su" verbal tic, which comes off as a bit childish. The Crunchyroll subtitles had her randomly insert plurals at the end of words, which is a bit better.

I also like the "Two frikken' months line." If you read the Tsuruga bonus chapter, Momo laments that there's still things about Yumi she doesn't know yet, but Kanbara says Momo shouldn't be saying that, since she's only known Yumi for two months.

last edited at Jul 21, 2019 10:32PM

Ultraxion
joined Mar 15, 2015

It looks like this lost the top spot for "most viewed over the past week." Personally, I was hoping that Chapter 42 of Bloom Into You would climb to the top rank, but it wasn't to be.

As for this, I liked the twist at the end, regarding the dark-haired woman's identity, but it was a bit too heavy on the porn and too light on the plot for my tastes.

joined Mar 15, 2015

Can't say I ever enjoyed any Nanoha series, but this Vivid one seriously takes the top as the worst, so good riddance.

Did you read FORCE? General consensus was that series was the worst of the lot, especially with the overpowered and unsympathetic Huckebein, the uninteresting main character who just happens to have a connection to Subaru, and lots of other issues that resulted in the manga being put on hiatus since September 2013, one that is most likely permanent.

Personally, I watched most of the franchise (although I dropped ViVid after a while), and enjoyed A's the most. I may go back and read the rest of ViVid one of these days.

Ultraxion
Their Story discussion 01 Jul 23:05
joined Mar 15, 2015

Is anyone else seeing each chapter as a bunch of images put together in a long thin column on a single page, with each individual page too small to read?

Ultraxion
joined Mar 15, 2015

I hope Yuu comes out to her parents, since that's one plot thread that Girl Friends never explored. They had Mari worry what her parents might think of her and Akko near the end, but never actually showed her coming out.

Ultraxion
joined Mar 15, 2015

Regarding the use of first and last names, maybe the scanlator incorrectly used "Nanami-senpai," since that's what Yuu's called Touko for almost 90% of the series. On Page 13 of Chapter 26, Yuu refers to Koyomi as "Kanou-san" for some reason while talking with Sayaka, but she calls her "Koyomi" in the localized version. It seems a little odd that she'd suddenly refer to Koyomi formally in that one case (Koyomi does the same to Yuu earlier that chapter, but I think students are supposed to do that when talking to teachers), so the localized version seems more consistent. Maybe when the localized Volume 8 comes out, she'll refer to Touko as "Touko-senpai" in her thoughts.

Then again, it is definitely easier for Touko to switch to casual speech with Yuu than for Yuu to be casual with Touko- for example, when Touko says "Ohayo, Yuu," in response to Yuu saying, "Nanami-senpai, Ohayo gozaimasu." Maybe someday, Touko will drop a few hints that Yuu can speak casually with her, at least when they're alone.

Ultraxion
joined Mar 15, 2015

It's nice to see what Touko and Yuu are like as an actual couple, but at the same time, I wonder what this is all leading up to, since there's only three chapters left. A part of me wishes the series could go on a little longer, so we could see more of Yuu and Touko's relationship.

Ultraxion
joined Mar 15, 2015

I'm personally curious about what happened between Midori and Tsumugi in the past. They seemed like they were close during the flashbacks, but then 17 years passed without them speaking to each other, and Midori didn't even hear that Tsumugi had a daughter.

Ultraxion
joined Mar 15, 2015

I've read the first two volumes of this manga (titled "Yuri is My Job", which sounds like a more accurate translation than the one provided). Some people here seem uncomfortable with the café part of the premise, but I actually think that the roleplaying ties nicely to some of the themes I've noticed so far. A lot of the manga is about truth and lies, such as what it means to keep up a persona, whether telling a lie for a good reason is ever a good thing, and how difficult it can be to trust someone who doesn't always tell the truth.

A lot of people note that the main characters are jerks, and they certainly come off that way at first, but as the story goes on, they're shown to be a bit more complex than that. Without spoiling too much, Hime once made a well-intentioned but misguided decision in the past, and Mitsuki regrets some of her past actions. The latter half of the first volume is when the characters start getting fleshed out more and become more interesting, and the manga becomes somewhat dramatic starting in Volume 2.

last edited at May 6, 2019 12:29AM

Ultraxion
joined Mar 15, 2015

"I love how you're short, and how it bothers you"
LOL.
Is roasting someone mid-confession a thing now?

Maybe it is, but it's also probably a reference to the omake in which Touko meets Yuu's kouhais from her middle school softball team, who are already taller than her. It's also a cutely endearing flaw for Yuu, one that Touko wouldn't even consider expressing when in her "perfect" façade(even if she was short), so it's natural that Touko would like it.

Incidentally, the color illustration and what looks like an advertisement for Volume 7 being on sale seem to suggest that this is the start of Volume 8. Not only would this be a good time to update the volume divisions accordingly, but it seems as though there's at least a few more chapters left in the story, although the eighth volume will apparently be the last.

Here's a link to the story.

https://www.animenewsnetwork.com/news/2019-04-25/bloom-into-you-yuri-manga-ends-in-8th-volume-in-november/.146086

Ultraxion
joined Mar 15, 2015

While I have no desire to feed the troll, I personally don't get people who become so obsessed with hating something that they actively go to a site's board to stir up trouble (assuming Chicken actually feels that way and isn't just saying this to rile us up). If I don't like something, I simply stop watching it, maybe write a negative review, and then forget about it.

Going back to the talk about Yuu's decision and what she thinks about Touko now, my take is now that she knows she loves Touko, she's willing to see her and hear her out, no matter what Touko ends up having to say to her. She's getting over her romanticized (no pun intended) notions of love, and realized that it's more complicated and often more painful than she thought, but nevertheless, is sure of how she feels about Touko..

I personally think it wouldn't be in character for Yuu to be overly judgmental of Touko. While Yuu doesn't hesitate to speak her mind to Touko, she also sympathizes with Touko, and while she's often annoyed with Touko for doing as she pleases, she enjoys her time with Touko. I find it highly unlikely that Yuu would assume that Touko is using her now that she understands that Touko simply doesn't think that anyone would choose her "ordinary" past self over the seemingly perfect façade she puts up.

In fact, both Yuu and Touko don't understand what love really means- while Yuu thinks it's some sort of overwhelming feeling of happiness, Touko assumes that love won't allow the person to change. Just as Maki helped Yuu realize that she was in love with Touko, Sayaka helped Touko realize that it was possible for someone who'd fallen in love with the "perfect" Touko to remain in love with the "real" Touko.

Above all else, though, I think both of them simply want to be together again (even if Yuu took longer to realize this), hence why after they had their respective epiphanies, Touko immediately texted Yuu, then Yuu immediately set out to meet with Touko. With that in mind, I think that they probably will, at the very least, make significant progress toward mending fences next chapter, even if it might not be the final chapter.

Ultraxion
joined Mar 15, 2015

It's good that Maki helped Yuu understand that she does, in fact, love Touko, and that she's not as similar to Maki as she thinks. Of course, I wonder how things might have turned out if Maki had told Yuu that they were different back in Chapter 15, when he first realized it.

Incidentally, I'm curious about something- is there any particular reason why Yuu calls her older sister "Rei-chan" rather than addressing her as an older sister (like how Touko calls Mio "Onee-chan")?

Ultraxion
joined Mar 15, 2015

I enjoyed this chapter, particularly Touko coming to realize that loving someone can still allow them to change, Sayaka being able to move on from her love for Touko, and Touko taking the first steps to reach out to Yuu again. Of course, the latter will also probably require some thought and character development on Yuu's end, since she still has a somewhat romanticized view of love (her belief that she didn't cry after Touko's "rejection" like Akari did after she realized her senpai would never reciprocate her feelings means that she may not have loved Touko).

While it was unfair of Touko to assume that Sayaka's feelings were as shallow as all her other suitors, Sayaka did admit that she'd been in love with Touko's "perfect" persona at first. As such, it's good that the discussion on the boat helps Touko realize that Sayaka knew about her vulnerability and imperfection but loved her anyway.

All in all, it's good that Sayaka's love for Touko was taken seriously and her (inevitable) rejection ended up helping move the plot forward, rather than being a way to tie up loose ends.

By the way, Special 6 should be moved to "Volum" 7(add an "e"), between Chapter 36 and Chapter 37. Otherwise, new readers will probably get confused when it references s a scene that hasn't happened yet.

Ultraxion
joined Mar 15, 2015

I wonder if Sayaka's confession will lead Touko to a personal epiphany- if Sayaka's loved Touko all this time and still remained a loyal friend, as well as loving her both when she was "perfect" and after learning of her vulnerabilities* might it be possible that being loved isn't such a bad thing? Perhaps she won't necessarily get together with Sayaka (the same goes for Yuu), but it's likely that she'll learn that lesson anyway. Alternatively, maybe having some time apart to talk to their other friends will help Yuu and Touko work out their issues.

*While I still hope Yuu and Touko ultimately get together, Yuu never saw Touko as perfect. Perhaps the fact that Sayaka once did, but her feelings never changed even as her perception of Touko did may prove significant.

One thing I like about this series, similar to what other people have said is that Sayaka's love for Touko is presented sympathetically, and she actually has a chance at winning Touko over. Rather than being just another member of Touko's harem, Sayaka's a well-written character in her own right.

Ultraxion
joined Mar 15, 2015

Personally, I enjoyed the anime adaptation, even if I did find the aquarium date to be a fairly abrupt cutoff point for the first season. At this point, the only alternative would be ending it at the play, which would require rushing the story too much for a 1cour anime. Besides, it may be possible that by leaving some plot threads not fully resolved, viewers who haven't read the manga will get interested in a second season.

Ultraxion
joined Mar 15, 2015

Does anyone know if Chapter 36 is the end of the volume 6?

Volume 6 ended with chapter 34. Someone should fix that. Also, chapter 23 and special 5 are part of volume 5.

Cool, I was thinking there was going to be a month hiatus if that was the end of the volume.

I mentioned this earlier, but no one seems to have made the change yet.

Speaking of volumes, I personally predict that this series will probably go on for at least 8 volumes, and probably reach Christmas in in-universe time. Of course, while it's good that the romance is a slow burn, it would probably be nice if Touko and Yuu actually start talking again by the end of Volume 7.

I wonder what sort of ending the anime will have, since we're already up to episode 5 and only up to Chapter 9. At least Citrus had a clear ending point when Yuzu and Mei started going out, even if it was less than halfway through the manga.

Ultraxion
joined Mar 15, 2015

That was an interesting look at Sayaka's perspective on how things are between Touko and Yuu. I personally have to wonder how Touko possibly learning that Sayaka has loved her all this time will affect their relationship. Perhaps it might even help Touko to realize that being loved might not be such a bad thing, and help convince her to talk things out with Yuu.

Of course, I personally thought that someone on the student council would probably sit Yuu and Touko down and say "You two have barely said a word to each other (for however long has passed since Yuu's confession). Could you please say what's going on, because things are really awkward right now?" People noticed when Yuu and Sayaka weren't getting along in Chapter 14, so I suspect it'll only be a matter of time before someone says something.

Ultraxion
joined Mar 15, 2015

So far, I have a fairly positive opinion of the anime. The performances seem fairly good so far, and while the color palette has taken a little while to get used to, I don't have too many complaints about the animation. It's quite unfortunate that it isn't available on Crunchyroll, though.

I think we discussed this before, but I'm also concerned about the fact that this anime is only 13 episodes long, which doesn't seem to be nearly enough to adapt even the 35 chapters thus far without rushing through things or abruptly concluding the series.

Ultraxion
joined Mar 15, 2015

Speaking of translation mistakes, I noticed a fairly significant difference between two translations of one of Ichigaya's lines in Chapter 21(Page 11), in response to Touko protesting that Mio wasn't like the person she remembers. In the translation on this site, Ichigaya says "Maybe (Mio) was just putting on an act to look cool in front of her little sister," but in the localization, he says "In a way, you may have surpassed your sister because of that." The latter is fairly consistent with Ichigaya's point that Touko is a better student council president than Mio, but if the former's true, it could paint Touko's relationship with Mio in a new light- we don't know much about that apart from that Touko admires Mio.

As for this chapter, as heartbreaking as it is, it does tie back to the characters themselves. Not only does Yuu not know what it's like to really be in love, but she's also not entirely sure what it means to have that love rejected, whereas Touko's forced to come to terms with the consequences of her insistence that Yuu not love her.

Of course, while Touko's insistence on loving Yuu while not being loved herself is an obstacle that must be overcome, I don't think either of them necessarily thinks of it as "emotional blackmail." To Touko, anyone who claims to love her present self merely loves the version of her that is a replica of her sister, while anyone who loves her "real" self loves a part of her that Touko wants to cast aside, and it logically follows that they won't necessarily continue to love her once she changes. As for Touko's love for Yuu, Touko seems to see it as something she freely gives for her own sake (as seen in Chapter 28, when she says it's the only part of her she knows belongs to her), rather than something she can choose to withhold if Yuu doesn't do what she says. Perhaps the solution(or at least part of it) may be for Touko to consider Yuu's perspective- that just as Touko chose to love Yuu, Yuu chose to do the same for Touko- and accept Yuu's choice.

joined Mar 15, 2015

While the story does have some pacing issues, I personally think it's to be expected of a one-shot. Most of the romance one-shots I've seen capture a small moment in time, and at the very least, you see a sense of development here.

At the start, Torii more or less took it as a given that Kai would simply agree to hang out with her, and got bitter when her offer was refused. When they do become closer, it's because Kai was there for Torii for several difficult months, having put in the effort to develop a relationship.

As for Kai, she admits later on that she'd probably gotten a bit too invested in the piano, and didn't originally understand her teacher's advice to go to a non-music school until after spending a few months without being able to play.

It might have been nice if this had been a short series, maybe a single manga volume worth of chapters, but the one-shot gets its point across fairly well.

As for the accident, the previous two cases of Torii imagining Kai's hands being injured immediately snapped back to reality, clearly showing that they're fantasies. When Kai's hand hits the side mirror, the next scene shows that it really is happening, and Torii realizes she didn't want it to happen.