Forum › Posts by commentator

commentator
Mika-icon
joined Jan 31, 2013

I don't really like the "I used to live in America, so I'm fine with kissing my friends," thing. It's just such a cliche excuse, and not very accurate to boot. That kind of stuff is just not common.

commentator
Mika-icon
joined Jan 31, 2013

CELEBRATORY FLAILING!!!
(((\(゚▽゚)/)))
WOOHOO!
(also, fangirly squealing)

last edited at Mar 10, 2014 6:35PM

commentator
Stretch discussion 07 Mar 02:30
Mika-icon
joined Jan 31, 2013

Am I the only one going to say it? This manga is horseshit without any yuri. The only positive thing about this manga is the art.

It's all subtext and intrigue masked by fluffy stretching and whatnot. Technically there isn't any yuri at all (you need some yuri goggles to see it, albeit cheap ones). I think it's something really interesting even without the great art, though the quality and subtle detail seriously help pull it all together.

commentator
Mika-icon
joined Jan 31, 2013

Rushed is certainly an understatement. I feel like there could have been a lot of potential, but their powers and stuff were seriously too amped up from the start. There wasn't enough space to build up any kind of emotional investment on the part of the reader. It's more like reading an abridged version of something like those long running series like one piece, naruto, etc. with the entire middle section cut out... Too bad... (but at least we have our imagination to try to fill in the blank areas)

Mika-icon
joined Jan 31, 2013

Anal Animal ears Big breasts Boob Sex Lactation Lots of sex Monster girl NSFW Tailsex Threesome Yuri
That's an impressive tag set there...
Now, I must say, the fact that there is now enough of it out there to warrant a Boob Sex tag kinda weirds me out. I honestly can't imagine that being very appealing. Ever. Each time I see it it's just as strange as the first.

commentator
Mika-icon
joined Jan 31, 2013

Alice looks like a Yukkuri here.

I think that's her nose in those first two panels.

commentator
Oddman 11 discussion 07 Feb 12:25
Mika-icon
joined Jan 31, 2013

Hold the f##k up, number 4 is the witch from that latest chapter of Nickelodeon!? (Ch. 18) The Dowman universe just got a lot more compact.

commentator
Mika-icon
joined Jan 31, 2013

A pervert is born. lol
That's certainly quite the transformation (from not being/wanting to be seen to... that)

commentator
Mika-icon
joined Jan 31, 2013

Isn't that pool...? (NSFW) http://danbooru.donmai.us/pools/2146

commentator
Mika-icon
joined Jan 31, 2013

That awkward moment when people who are "gone" aren't actually dead.

commentator
Mika-icon
joined Jan 31, 2013

I knew something was up with that "tarot" card on the first page of ch22.
it stood out way to much.

Oh my, I didn't even notice it.

commentator
Mika-icon
joined Jan 31, 2013

... I think I've waited long enough. When's chapter 6 supposed to be released? Has the author even finished the chapter yet?

If you go to the release post on Yuri-ism (where you can get their releases much earlier than waiting here) it says:

"For those unaware, Secret Flowers 6 has been delayed repeatedly, spanning 2 Comikets and multiple events in between. There is currently no planned release for it, but Goyac says he will try for some event in March. Though I’m sure something will happen and his computer, tablet or both will break again. Yuru Yuri S3 or SF6 first? … I’d bet on Yuru Yuri."

Mika-icon
joined Jan 31, 2013

It gives me the warm fuzzies somehow whenever I see Precia being the super overly attached mother. Maybe that's how she would've been in the original 'verse if nothing had happened to Alicia?

commentator
Nickelodeon discussion 22 Jan 00:37
Mika-icon
joined Jan 31, 2013

Andersen territory. Brilliant, Grimm vs Andersen.

commentator
Mika-icon
joined Jan 31, 2013

Whoa! First time I've ever spotted an artist mistake, but prez's dad has an extra ear on page 15.

commentator
Mika-icon
joined Jan 31, 2013

I think it's the same as what happened to her in the otome anime. I don't quite remember the timeline for it, but I do know she disappeared for a while because she got scared of being appointed as one of the columns or something. She ran away then got lost and trapped in some remote place with Mikoto./

commentator
Mika-icon
joined Jan 31, 2013

Chapter six looks pretty rushed... I don't feel I have the skill/time to be a real good translator, but even I could tell stuff was off.

I thought it was pretty okay except for the final 4koma. I happened to see the /a/ thread where the scans were being edited and it seems like the translator totally missed the context of the background dialogue (the "royalty" stuff is probably a reference to the earlier "beach queens" scene). But yeah, the way it currently is is definitely jarring.

My biggest issue is the parts where I don't think the meaning got conveyed right, like the joke on the left of page three: here we have Yuzu saying "Beach ball", "It's like a beach" and the punchline "That's why I'm saying it's like a beach!" But the original has the same words for panels 2 and 3, something like "Do that at the beach", and the final one making the joke "That's why I'm saying do that at the beach!" Or so. Really I just think they made it less funny by getting the translation off.

Mika-icon
joined Jan 31, 2013

It took me a moment to process that that wasn't the letter "o" but a censor circle...

commentator
Mika-icon
joined Jan 31, 2013

Chapter six looks pretty rushed... I don't feel I have the skill/time to be a real good translator, but even I could tell stuff was off.

commentator
Mika-icon
joined Jan 31, 2013

You mean Nadeshiko gets called right? And which chapter was that? I've got vague memories of that scene but I can't seem to track it down... or was it that I saw it in the anime?

Yeah I fixed it I meant to say Nadeshiko >.> I don't know if it was an actual chapter but it was definitely in the anime.

I finally found it on the bakkin reader. It's chapter 54 of the main series...

commentator
Mika-icon
joined Jan 31, 2013

It's pretty much obvious that it's Megumi now. Nadeshiko just said the place where Megumi worked slipped in their conversation on the phone. Aww yeeaaaaah

I thought so too. I remember the chapter where Megumi gets a called when Himawari was visiting and they were being all lovey dovey on the phone. I hope it's Megumi but I'm like 99% sure!

You mean Nadeshiko gets called right? And which chapter was that? I've got vague memories of that scene but I can't seem to track it down... or was it that I saw it in the anime?

last edited at Jan 12, 2014 4:33AM

commentator
Mika-icon
joined Jan 31, 2013

An older sister has now been added.

commentator
Mika-icon
joined Jan 31, 2013

@Kaja Rainbow

The stuff they've been signing in the story, were there any gestures that were similar (similar gesture, similar meaning) to the sign language you know (American, Chinese sign language/whatever sign language is used in your country, or was it totally different (for example as different as Japanese Spoken is to English Spoken)?

What I know is American Sign Language, which's pretty different from Japanese Sign language. But I still recognized the signs in the manga as clearly sign language, if sign language in a foreign language. There seem to be certain universal elements, like the general kinds of handshapes people'll be making--gestural stuff using easy to make finger shapes. Some of those handshapes're ones ASL use, but in different ways and for different words. Overall, I'm fairly certain that was actual JSL in the manga.

to tell the truth i always thought that sign language was universal...like a drawing.... good that i always learn something new everyday :D

I was told by a friend who was taking sign language that there is a kind of "general" or "universal" sign language that people can use aside from the ones that coincide with national languages like ASL or JSL. The way she described it made me think it was a bit more like standardized charades though, but that's just the way I interpreted her second hand information.

commentator
Mika-icon
joined Jan 31, 2013

It's pretty much obvious that it's Megumi now. Nadeshiko just said the place where Megumi worked slipped in their conversation on the phone. Aww yeeaaaaah

Actually she (allegedly) overheard Megumi talking to a coworker on the phone.
Either way, this has definitely given Megumi a ton of points in the speculation pool.

commentator
Seasons discussion 31 Dec 23:20
Mika-icon
joined Jan 31, 2013

to fully grasp the volume,
DDD/E.

Nope. Can't grasp that volume. Hands are too small.

Thanks, now I have to explain why I just burst out laughing.