Forum › Posts by XadarxBlack

XadarxBlack
Liberta discussion 30 May 03:35
joined May 3, 2014

it is just something stupid about an teenager getting power only thinking of genociding humanity lol at least at that age the only thing i was doing was play video games and saving the world in thous games, thank god i wasn’t an social parasite like this little thing here

joined May 3, 2014

so it got axed :/ when i read the fact that the next chapter is the last it makes me feel like the romance was EXTREAMLY rushed with such an ending

last edited at May 30, 2023 3:31AM

joined May 3, 2014

Best way is to read comments everytime a new story comes out that MIGHT make you think it won’t end up the way you don’t like! I do that everytime there is het involved >.>

XadarxBlack
joined May 3, 2014

I hope they won't get rid of the sensory sharing in the end. What would happen to their sisterly horny bonding time? D:

that thing is the most werid curse you can have and worthless like no pros to it but only cons!

joined May 3, 2014

TBH this is definitely deserving of a horror and tragedy tag of some kind.

People really don't tend enjoy getting jebaited with promises of something fun and lighthearted only to get last-minute rug-pulled with horror and suffering even if it's still behind a thin veneer of parody. Personally, the trivia box stating explicitly that the MC is now dead, trapped in her own head but still able to think and feel while being puppeteered around by a crazy yandere necromancer is the point that definitively goes too far to not be tagged more clearly.

I love horror, don't get me wrong, but it's definitely a genre that people should have the basic right to decide to get into rather than having it sprung on them 90% into the narrative when they obviously can't choose not to read it anymore because they've already read it just to get to that point.

I think this deserves some extra tags

Im sure it will get them. On DS they often leave off spoilery tags for a bit on a new story as long as its not something really bad that might trigger people.

This is literally the premise of the story though:
-Random normal person walks into someplace dangerous without realizing it.
-They try to charm their way out of danger, but fail and is instead stabbed to death with a sword through the back.
-Their dead body is raised as a shambling corpse and her mind is locked up inside her head unable to control herself or do literally anything, but still feels the sensations of her walking dead body that she has no control over and is now effectively a slave of the person who murdered her specifically to accomplish this.

The End.

That doesn't strike you as a story dark enough to trigger someone with no fair chance to know what they were getting into?

yeah can we add the bloody tragedy tag? I REALLY WON’T Waste my time with tragedy stories since they are REALLY not my cup of tea!

and as Twinkler said, this IS QUITE DARK! desipite the jokingly idea of the status window :/

joined May 3, 2014

Unfortunate. I wanted them to have something sweet and for the witch to turn out to just be misunderstood. WELP. ༎ຶ⁠‿⁠༎ຶ

Honestly, I'm kind of sick of the "evil girl was just misunderstood" trope. It's such a cliche at this point

That being said, Knight's condescending attitude didn't earn a lot of sympathy points lol

what are you on about? condecending attitude is equal to being enslaved as an undead that can’t even talk to an psychopath witch? eh?

joined May 3, 2014

Terrible end

Well, she really is a n00b. Even a choose-your-own-adventure reader, typically 10 years old, would have made better choices. Hopefully, she'll be humbled and the witch will restore her to health.

she is bloody a undead, unless you talk about resurection like in an werid RPG world she is gone for good

joined May 3, 2014

Oh, I knew it! I knew! I knew from the very first instant I saw her that this Yomi woman was up to no good!!

Shizuku should have stuck to Honami. It was clear from the beginning that she was the right choice. Stupid Shizuku. Bah.

Shizuku doesn't have a say on who she visits.

But she has a say on whether to have sex or not.
I think they meant that Shizuku should have limited herself to sex with Akaya Honami (that is, go steady with her) instead of banging every girl she meets—which is what got her in trouble with that mf Yomi bitch.

I mean the girl asked but way in hell will Yomi do this tho? is she an secred inspector?

XadarxBlack
joined May 3, 2014

Aleast use the door for a nice trip anyway.

Sounds like its one-way though, makes it hard to go back.

yap, without the keys they will be stuck on whatever side they chose to go

joined May 3, 2014

Nadeshiko is great and all but im on team Jun with this one. I think there's some hint that akane indeed feels something to jun and i would feel bad if that means nothing at the end

ofc jun means bloody efing nothing! she SHPULD be nothing since she was not even the main character in the story, her personality is so bloody immature and childish that will be an shity fit for Akane since we NEVER got any hin of Akane liking jun in any shape or form!

XadarxBlack
joined May 3, 2014

I wonder if we'll get more from this author. I mean I really enjoyed this. Yuri aside, I was fully into the world building with all the different clans and stuff yk, it was a real gem to read.

well so we did got something from the author XD and this should had been the last chapter insted of the werid chapter were the MC fucking somone else >.>

joined May 3, 2014

Got the feeling it lacks of at least one important tag.

"Het"?

like some one already said, we have to see if the author pulls the yuri card in the last chapter before giving it the bisexual tag >.>

joined May 3, 2014

I think this is the fourth or fifth series I've read with this start... looks good tho

Came here to say this. That intro has been overdone and is stupid at this point, but there could still be potential here.

since every manga out there has an generic start do you think every manga has an stupid start too? because there is not much unique manga starts out there so everything is stupid by your definition, is just generic but not stupid

last edited at May 25, 2023 5:27AM

joined May 3, 2014

Another thing I swallowed in one go because I saw the [end] tag, and I sometimes wonder why do I skip over some of those :P It was pretty good, but it's kinda funny how it was 98% fluff, 1% violence (basically just that feral wolf at the start), and 1% sex (also half of it at the start). Really bizarre combination if you think about it, but it somehow worked!

eh? what on green earth did you eat to consider this kind of story traits combination BIZARRE?? 0.0 what i consider bizarre is the 1% violence >.>

XadarxBlack
joined May 3, 2014

lets hope we see the power of the wind now that she knows who took her sweet nun :3

XadarxBlack
joined May 3, 2014

this is very gripping for reasons I haven't parsed yet

there's a little BDSM in all of us

kind most her trauma from her childhood might make her use pain as an coping (having your mother do that to you as an child will surly leave you scared in a way) , not an healthy one for sure >.>

XadarxBlack
joined May 3, 2014

I’m confused how this is yuri tho >.> reads more like subtext, good one shot tho :3

last edited at May 20, 2023 4:47AM

joined May 3, 2014

the show has shown its true colors,this is ntr trash plain and simple.

Huh? it was clear as day NTR since chapter 1, what do you mean?

for real like? the title is literally "my girlfriend is not here today" and she cheats right off the bat, what did people think they were gonna get?

but anyway, this is actually pretty entertaining to me. it's quite clear that none of them are in the right so i'm just enjoying the shit show lmfao

what in green earth make you think EVERY cheat story is NTR?? lol what a wierd hung up on the fact people didn’t expect NTR since I DID read cheating story but only a HANDFULL of them were NTR

joined May 3, 2014

I love how polarized people are lol. You can't point out the mistakes a character made or the stupid decisions they made without someone else jumping at your neck for "justifying" the other one's actions

PSA: Saying how bad Nanase was as a girlfriend does not mean you're justifying Yuni's cheating
Saying how stupid Yuni is does not mean you're defending Nanase
Not everything is black and white in life, and especially not in this story lmao

you lot EXAGERATE Nanase fault here tho >.> like this crap of blaming Nanase for something like “neglect” becaus ONLY YUNI see it as neglect! in an healty relationship you discus the issue and fix it by compromising or changing or ANYTHING! then if all fails Yuni is in the rights to break up due to difference in relationship priorities such as Nanase puting the relationship AND club activities! you all acting as if the neglect was SO SEVEAR but I literaly fail to see how that is the case and forget me but Yuni definition of neglect is twisted in an narcisistic way, it’s like people think every relationship doesn’t have an form of “neglect” but since the ADULTS reach an understanding that they can’t spend to much time together who is to say that is “neglect”!!! this is the core issue in this depiction of relationship!

Yuni NEVER really tryed to do the right thing but chose cheating as the most stupid way to fix something that will fail the moment they are caught cheating, PUTING more wffort in cheating that fixing the damn relationship! and what is Nanase soo called “sin”? oh She thinks club ativities and her lover to be BOTH precious!!! like WHAT EVEY adult does!!!

I fell this will end with Nanase being the bloody cock in the relationship OR forgiving the disgusting Yuni right there and there as an werid form for “redemption”

I hope the ending will be Nanase breaking up and move on, or it will end in the most disgusting way and leave me with shit taste in my mouth :/

XadarxBlack
joined May 3, 2014

It has a name fit for a tragedy. I am scared

yeah I’m not touching this manga untill more chapters are out >.> so I cancread the comments that way I avoid if the story is….Tragic to say the least

joined May 3, 2014

oh sweet Jesus those spoilers

Yes! We will need the gay Jesus for when thous chapters drop here >_>

joined May 3, 2014

That’s the joke. The whole schtick of this series. It’s SUPPOSED TO BE DUMB AND GOOFY. It reminds me a lot of an inverse version of that “You’re Totally in Love With Me, Aren’t You?” manga where it’s just as goofy and the whole joke each time is the MC asking her friend who’s obviously crushing on her if she loves her and the friend always denying it. I think the only reason people are fine with that one and bash this one is cuz this manga has a more realistic art style and isn’t in 4-Koma style, so subconsciously think it’s supposed to be a realistic drama and not a silly comedy.

Maybe this isn’t your brand of comedy or whatever, but that doesn’t mean it sucks. It’s actually doing what it set out to do quite well.

Whatever, you can say it's supposed to be like this, "dumb and goofy", only problem is it is not like that, I would say it's "senseless" more than dumb, she's just making unrealistic excuses that no one, not even the most oblivious person would think, and "frustrating" more than goofy, because up till now, or at least in the latest chapters it hasn't been funny at all.

And it's nothing to do with my "brand of comedy", I actually quite like this type of manga, for instance another one that uses this same type of dynamic and is being uploaded right now in the site is shoujo manga protag X rival and guess what, it's pretty funny and I like it a lot.

Another thing to add to the senseless of the story, and someone else pointed before, she's supposed to be a "former womanizer" or "woman eater" or whatever, but how come when she can't get these obvious signals? Or what, you expect me to think every girl she hit on wore a shirt saying "I'm a lesbian"? or the rainbow flag or was registered in the national lesbian catalogue or something? IT DOESN'T MAKE ANY SENSE, like most of this manga, but the main point is, it's not funny, because there's a lot of things in shoujo protag X rival that are senseless too, but at least they're funny, this is just stupid

ok you made your opinion clear, unless this manga is EXACTLY how you THINK is supposed to be is bad in the univers that you exist

joined May 3, 2014

damn, this is excellent so far, the latest chapter really turned it up. i always suspected the government was running the hitmen but now i'm almost certain.

i've never read a manga that felt remotely so politically timely and vital before (possibly excluding lgbt issues), it's very refreshing.

here we go again people think everything is american politics lol

here from were I live in EU there is jack of politics not the same way US seemns to boil every time the president forget’s were he is, or the talking orange ex-president says something and twitter boils over

joined May 3, 2014

... that tailing scene was nonsense. What was the point of that? If you want to apprehend her, do it right away. If you don't, then, uh, why are you trying so hard to follow her? Everyone's just bored, or what? ^^;

Besides, the thing about trains is that they have known destinations. They kinda are the worst getaway vehicles ...

The whole scene was another aptitude test. They wanted to see how good she is before they offered her the big score. Kinda pointless, knowing what they already knew about her abilities, but maybe they had their own superiors to impress with a live demonstration.

she err on one of her work and maybe they decided to do a test? like what do people wanna here? super detailed extream logic of everything in this story ?

joined May 3, 2014

I mean, I really like it idk what you're saying people. Of course Ayaka is heartbroken but her expressions are hilarious and it's not that big of a deal to me. I've been through dumb heartbreaks and honestly much better to poke fun of them like this instead of taking them seriously lol. I think the tonal contrast really funny, especially how Hiroko is totally into her and in deep denial. Yeah ok, this chapter is kinda wacky I was so confused with the conclusions she draws but believe me it gets better lol.

In my opinion at least it's frankly just annoying to have 3 introduction chapters to a series that all end in the same frustrating punch line, and only escalate in absurdity each chapter. Especially frustrating when the "joke" is simply, wow she really must like men!, I don't find it funny personally. It's good that you're enjoying it, but I think the frustrated reaction from a lot of the readers is definitely understandable and justified.

I guess you just expected something else from this manga and it didn’t happen, that’s all there is to it really >.>

last edited at May 9, 2023 5:05AM