An image cannot be tagged both "NSFW" and "Ecchi". It either contains nudity or it doesnt. (This doesn't.)
Vincent Kellen
Jul 12, 2025 2:13PM
This doesn't? She was topless though
HifuuEnjoyer
Jul 12, 2025 6:17PM
Nazrin's ears on Marisa and Rin's ears on Reimu?
Tamahime
Jul 13, 2025 12:15AM
^^ The general societal understanding of “nudity” = female nipples or any genitals. Anything else that is sexy-but-not-nude is what “ecchi” is for.
If Dynasty is using some different definition here then it should be clearly spelled out in the tag description, but IMO that would just make things unnecessarily confusing and arbitrary. This character’s almost entirely obscured breast is arguably much LESS nude than a bikini. Is a silhouette in a shower “nudity” then? Aren’t we all naked under our clothes?
Tags should have concrete, clear definitions that are correctly and consistently applied/enforced or what is the point of having them? I’m scarred from I don’t know how many years of battling on other H-manga sites over correctly using the “yuri” tag, and to this day it still gets misused most everywhere (not here obviously, which is why I expect better from tagging here).
last edited at Jul 13, 2025 12:17AM
FluffyCow
Jul 13, 2025 12:45AM
^Thing is that tags are always going to mean different things to different people, there was a whole debate that wasn't worth arguing about with some tagging stuff recently. That's all I say as I don't want to argue about it and I'm pretty indifferent about NSFW and Ecchi being used here.
Outside of Dynasty though, I will at least say I fully agree with you about H-manga websites completely misusing the Yuri tag.
Tamahime Jul 12, 2025 12:25AM
An image cannot be tagged both "NSFW" and "Ecchi". It either contains nudity or it doesnt. (This doesn't.)
Vincent Kellen Jul 12, 2025 2:13PM
This doesn't? She was topless though
HifuuEnjoyer Jul 12, 2025 6:17PM
Nazrin's ears on Marisa and Rin's ears on Reimu?
Tamahime Jul 13, 2025 12:15AM
^^ The general societal understanding of “nudity” = female nipples or any genitals. Anything else that is sexy-but-not-nude is what “ecchi” is for.
If Dynasty is using some different definition here then it should be clearly spelled out in the tag description, but IMO that would just make things unnecessarily confusing and arbitrary. This character’s almost entirely obscured breast is arguably much LESS nude than a bikini. Is a silhouette in a shower “nudity” then? Aren’t we all naked under our clothes?
Tags should have concrete, clear definitions that are correctly and consistently applied/enforced or what is the point of having them? I’m scarred from I don’t know how many years of battling on other H-manga sites over correctly using the “yuri” tag, and to this day it still gets misused most everywhere (not here obviously, which is why I expect better from tagging here).
last edited at Jul 13, 2025 12:17AM
FluffyCow Jul 13, 2025 12:45AM
^Thing is that tags are always going to mean different things to different people, there was a whole debate that wasn't worth arguing about with some tagging stuff recently. That's all I say as I don't want to argue about it and I'm pretty indifferent about NSFW and Ecchi being used here.
Outside of Dynasty though, I will at least say I fully agree with you about H-manga websites completely misusing the Yuri tag.