Forum › Posts by GID

GID
Image Comments 17 Sep 14:35
joined Jun 28, 2017
Pocky_tl

The downside with Kasumi is you have to bait her with food to get her to engage in any physical activity.
Although that really is more of an upside.

GID
joined Jun 28, 2017

Yamado Ako really is the savior of Madoka fanfiction. Most of Madoka fanfiction is complete rubbish, but she manages to create one masterpiece after another.
Thank you TFO Scans for giving us the pleasure of reading another of Yamado's amazing creations.

GID
joined Jun 28, 2017

Top Homu ಠ_ಠ

Which is as it always is since it is the natural order of things.
I know Homu top cuts the faint-hearted haters of dark-haired female characters like the end of Rebellion, but you have to perform some really twisted psychosis level self-deluding to make yourself believe that there is any other way to realistically portray Mado/Homu.
The only places where I have seen it any different is in the cotton-candy fantasies of doujinshi's who hate Homaru.

last edited at Sep 13, 2018 5:11PM

joined Jun 28, 2017

That was a nice slice of life story. Also nice to have something from Mei's pov.

GID
Image Comments 27 Aug 12:12
joined Jun 28, 2017
67439897_p0

Very cute. Love the colors.

GID
joined Jun 28, 2017

Thank goodness there was no drama. (Not that it would make sense for Nakatani to add any in.)

I am massively frustrated at how modern internet has perverted the classic literary terms. "Drama" is what this manga is all about -- the best kind of drama in fact, the believable, human, character-driven one. Please don't say that this manga has "no drama" when you, in fact, mean "melodrama" and "poorly written and unnecessary complications".

Well, there's one thing that's been on my mind: the possibility of Touko's suicide. I kinda doubt this is the route the story is taking, but damn, her emotional & mental state right now is so unstable, if you just consider her character alone without the whole picture of the story, she honestly is someone who is at the brink of doing it.

Even if the thought enters her silly young head, she has two very committed women in her life who would keep her from it. As I said earlier, the girl is lucky AF.

I almost feel a bit silly saying this, maybe a bit biased too, but I believe this is factually a literary masterpiece, especially for what manga can usually accomplish.

Silly Mizu, we all know that the only literary masterpiece there is in the yuri genre is the Yuri Mekuru series.

This.

If only you would it get it into your silly little head that there is nothing about this nonsense that is believable, human, relatable or even dramatic.
This is all just a crappy exploitation story using the unoriginal, boring and misogynistic melancholy dark-haired girl trope like a billion boring misogynistic stories have done since the dawn of the entertainment industry.
And if anything it is Yuu and Sayaka who are lucky to have such a hard-working, dedicated friend who loves them so much.
Even so, the idea of Touko commoting suicide is something that has only ever existed in the minds of salivating misogynists.
Nothing of the kind has ever had a grain of possibility in a character with such a love of life and people.

joined Jun 28, 2017

I'm a bit disappointed it doesn't seem to fit in with her other post Rebellion stories and also by Homaru's seeming coldness and the distance there seemed to be between them.
But I do so love those Devil Homura eyes and Yamado Ako does them so well.
And in the end, it was as great a Yamado Ako HomuMado story as always, full of sweetness and love.
Thank you Ako and TFO scans.

joined Jun 28, 2017

Damn, why did it end when it was getting good

Indeed :lol
I wouldn't mind a sequel.

joined Jun 28, 2017

This is incredibly cute. Hajime's desire was portrayed very poignantly and Touko's giving in to it wholeheartedly but hesitatingly was very sensual. If only there was more Yuri like this. Touko reminded me of LWA's Diana somewhat,

GID
joined Jun 28, 2017

This was adorable and awesome! Pity there isn't more.

joined Jun 28, 2017

Whiny voice: "I'm a helpless dark-haired cliché who is a slave to a confident blonde cliché and we were created to please the sick fantasies of people who hate dark-haired women."
Nobody cares about your boring misogynist couple, tNmR. The only thing we care about are Uta and Kaoru... And Uta's mother. She actually seems interesting.

joined Jun 28, 2017

"Yipee! A special!"
Sees the first page.
"Oh, It's you: The boring couple.
If a special is what it takes to keep you two out of the next five chapters I'll still applaud it. But I know I won't be that lucky."

GID
Image Comments 23 Jul 16:13
joined Jun 28, 2017
16a84cf6cac48b43ef56264532a4f1be

Perfect :)

GID
Image Comments 23 Jul 16:10
joined Jun 28, 2017
Ccszmpzukaaobla-orig

"... are so beautiful... to meee!"
It's that ole devil called love again.

joined Jun 28, 2017

Cute jealous Madoka deserves lots of kisses from Homaru <3
OMG! They are both such smooth operators with those gloves!
I really hope we'll get another sequel to Yamado's post-Rebellion series, but this was equally full of the usual goodness. I loved the way they smiled at each other in Sayaka's diaries.

joined Jun 28, 2017

... Why is Sayaka feeling embarrased by Madoka and Homura's lovey-doveyness to the point of hiding her face?

lol My thoughts exactly.

joined Jun 28, 2017

Yes!!! New Yamado HomuMado! I will immerse myself in the sweetness.

joined Jun 28, 2017

Huh. This Homura's thoughts on Madoka are pretty tame and pure.

Yamada Ako's post-Rebellion Homaru tends to be more Devilish than ordinary Yamada Ako Homaru in that respect :)
Although that grin, in the end, hinted things might get more heated behind the scenes.

last edited at Jun 24, 2018 3:29PM

joined Jun 28, 2017

Pity it's not a sequel to Yamada Ako's post-Rebellion doujinshi, but it was perfect as usual.
I was so happy when I saw this. I hope Yamada Ako has lots more MadokaxHomaru doujinshi that'll be translated and uploaded.

This was so cute. How she wanted to know Homaru's thoughts and then Homaru was all "If Madoka loves me back I don't care who sees us!"
And then they end up at Homaru's house so they can get intimate héhé.

joined Jun 28, 2017

Kinda disgusting.
Also kind of easy, the way she just happened to hurt her hand while the MC wished for it.
But yeah, it really is disgusting that the MC needed her to get a scar because she felt the other girl was too "perfect?" otherwise.
Then what scar does the MC need to get in order to get less perfect?
I'd like to read a story about that.

GID
Delusion discussion 14 Jun 13:08
joined Jun 28, 2017

I love how poignant this is.

GID
Snow discussion 14 Jun 13:04
joined Jun 28, 2017

Loved the parody punchline. "That idiot! Why didn't she say so in the first place!" lol

GID
Snow discussion 14 Jun 13:03
joined Jun 28, 2017

This was great. And I was listening to Nonon's theme while reading it ;)

GID
Image Comments 13 Jun 17:05
joined Jun 28, 2017
40165995_big_p0

Happy MadoHomu is pure bliss <3

GID
Image Comments 13 Jun 17:03
joined Jun 28, 2017
Ibtbxd3s2myz2w

Please tell her!!!
I love Yamado Ako's MadoHomu.