kami-sama:
well, the cliche turn of events never bothered me cause it's the same genre. [...] but I never saw Seol-a and No-rae struggle to the fact that they're falling in love with the same sex. [...] I can relate to everything Seol-a and No-rae's struggles from the past but I can't relate to them when it comes to the forbidden love situation. cause it never was brought up.[...]
MacySan:
Regarding the cliches. Yes there are quite lot in here. But despite them, the way the author handles the situations make the story real and interesting. Besides, it's drama and slice of life, so sometimes these can not be avoided.
There is actually a very good character development. The story flow doesn't get trapped into repetitive cycles for the shake of more chapters.
I think the author doesn't mention sexuality as a way to show that it's ok to fall in love with the same sex, and it's the same as falling for the opposite. Basically, acceptance of gay/bi people. Or a hope for the future when gender won't be such an issue when it comes to romantic relationships.
Btw, anyone mentioned what is Seol-a and No-rae's sexuality supposed to be? I'd say Seol-a is most probably bi. No-rae as well, although she might be gay too idk.
[...]
My thoughts are very similar to MacySan. I'm actually glad that Ssamba didn't go that route of dwelling on the forbidden love. I thought it was fantastic that she chose to do it the regular shoujo manga way, spreading the message of love to the readers, that two seemingly straight girls could fall in love with each other so naturally just like any other couples. But it doesn't mean they didn't struggle with the nature of liking someone in the same gender. Ssamba did give us subtle views of the characters' anxiety and worries (Norae's immediate shutting Seola out harshly after finding out her own feelings, or Seola's sadness that Hye-Kyung noticed. Seola just chose to bounce back real quick due to her "utterly cool" nature lol).
Regarding the weak plot devices that Nya-chan mentioned, I agree about the cliché. But like I said, I loved it that Ssamba chose to stay "faithful" to her title "Fluttering Feelings" and follow the shoujo manga way. I don't think she set out to create a masterpiece in the first place. And to me that's what made it great, and exactly what the current community is in need of. It's just a message of pure love. All the feelings and character development just felt very real and natural. And thats how it became the most read comic on Korean Comico, followed by many straight fans of both genders. It's like Ssamba was saying "Let's talk about their love instead of contemplating whether they should be together or not because they're two girls." If Ssamba had started talking about the nature of their forbidden love, I'm sure it had been full of hate talk by now. Comico wouldn't have put an ad with this couple in the middle of the city where there are many hard-core religious people.
To sum up my opinion, Ssamba's [not dwelling on the forbidden nature of their love] + [exploring deep into their past] + [repeating clichés of romantic/dramatic love fictions] = an emphasis that [they're just like a regular straight couple, portrayed million times by the media] (even better because the girls are so cute and pretty xD)
last edited at Oct 19, 2015 6:48PM