Forum › Who Are You? discussion

joined Apr 5, 2020

I really like takemiyas stories, but she kinda missed the mark with this one.

KatzeDerNacht
08f6612130a20845a480034c0567fbe1d8926209_hq
joined Apr 27, 2014

Alright, this was ..weird, but since it's Takemiya-sensei, I'll allow it. It's not the worst fake twin story ever!!!

joined Feb 24, 2019

Huh, I thought this was gonna be another entry from the mental illness yuri anthology, but guess not. That's the real twist here.

Rsz_1rsz_0232-006
joined Mar 16, 2018

Imagine someone actually ordering a hired help to do that and have it actually be obeyed

Like I dunno just quit

Fbk
joined Aug 19, 2019

Imagine someone actually ordering a hired help to do that and have it actually be obeyed

Like I dunno just quit

Maybe there was already some type of attraction the maid had going on beforehand? I doubt it tho.

AnimexObsession
Screenshot%20(107)
joined Dec 27, 2014

I am confusion

Carmilla%20reading
joined Sep 15, 2015

The heck? Takemiya has been watching too much telenovelas.

Screenshot_2020-06-05%20dorian%20electra%20has%20a%20full%20on%20broment
joined Jun 20, 2017

I'm all for crazy plots, but this was just so nonsensical and all over the place that it ended up giving nothing interesting to think about.

Evcp4u3uyaabsc_%20(1)%20(1)
joined Jul 2, 2018

Everything is so creepy lately... Lmao, I was excited for Takemiya but this one was eh

Evcp4u3uyaabsc_%20(1)%20(1)
joined Jul 2, 2018

Everything is so creepy lately... Lmao, I was excited for Takemiya but this one was eh

Rx_5_50
joined May 3, 2016

I skimmed through it because I wasn't overly interested in reading it, so I missed the maid and dead twin part. I reread it after seeing how short it was and...

Yukari%20sweet%20-%20copy
joined Nov 24, 2016

I'll take it

Image
joined Feb 23, 2016

Insane alright

Fubukurri%20s
joined Aug 18, 2015

I was half expecting the twist to be that the twin WASN'T dead.

"Surprise! It really was just a rumor!"

joined Apr 24, 2015

I like this but it feels unfinished. Why is the maid considered insane? Is it because she puts up with the abuse? Did she kill the twin sister with some warped perception that she'd score with the big sister in her fragile state? By that i mean is a case of a character not being afraid to hurt the person they love if it means they can get together with them in the end.

Don't%20forget%20the%20best%20girl
joined Jul 22, 2018

meh

Cow%202
joined Sep 27, 2017

I often don't like Takemiya Jin's works, they from what I remember write a lot of weird and/or grim dark stories. So I'm kind of shocked that people are surprised that this story was weird, while reading this I could only think, "Oh great here Takemiya goes again". I always want to give new works a fair chance regardless of author, but yeah I definitely didn't enjoy this one-shot unfortunately.

last edited at Jun 21, 2020 1:39AM

joined Jan 3, 2020

@FluffyCow You must be thinking of a different author (there's several who fit your description). Takemiya Jin's manga are almost all romance-based with light to moderate drama and happy endings. The amount of stories from her that don't fit that mold is extremely low. If one of her works has a bad ending, it is usually because it's a 2 part work (which is why people were asking if it was truly complete).

Gothic_Catalyst
14883450_345545539125601_1739065670976333342_o
joined Jun 20, 2015

....nice....

Richardevans
joined Jun 1, 2016

Lol

Download
joined Jun 4, 2015

@FluffyCow You must be thinking of a different author (there's several who fit your description). Takemiya Jin's manga are almost all romance-based with light to moderate drama and happy endings. The amount of stories from her that don't fit that mold is extremely low. If one of her works has a bad ending, it is usually because it's a 2 part work (which is why people were asking if it was truly complete).

Maby Kodama, I'd like to think Takemiya has more comedic plots with drama with mostly happy endings or sometimes ambiguous ones.

Edit: If she went through a lot of surgery to look identical though, she definitely could have had a breast reduction to match as well since she was willing to go so far.

last edited at Jun 21, 2020 3:31AM

TifalovesAerith
__aerith_gainsborough_and_tifa_lockhart_final_fantasy_and_final_fantasy_vii__1b3d5b3389d43da1956a0fa45627f6c0
joined May 7, 2017

RIP her neck though

Yuu
joined Mar 28, 2015

Takemiya is a genius.

joined Oct 10, 2016

creepy pls

pumpkinmonster
12dc224e72d923961c53b2d099ea3d50
joined Mar 26, 2020

takemiya sensei story is getting creepier and creepier

To reply you must either login or sign up.