Forum › Posts by Rosenakahara

Beatorokken
joined Feb 23, 2014

Yeaahhh, I couldn't really get into this story because the characters were just amazingly... flat? And not even particularly in a cute way. The pretty girl wants unconditional acceptance and love more than she's willing to give it. It really does remind me more of an owner and pet relationship more than a healthy normal one :/ Even if she was comparing the shy girl to her old stuffed animal dog, the way she forces herself on the other girl just unacceptable in not even considering her feelings. At all. And that isn't any sort of loving relationship.

Although the nerdy girl is even creepier. Going out of her way to help her studies and know her schedule and past history too well. She is just asking to be stepped on :/ And that just leads to disrespect and bad news. I don't know if she would ever stand up to her crush--which can't ever end well.

But I suppose in a way they match :( overall this one left a bad taste in my mouth. (thanks for translating and posting though! It's always interesting to see a wide variety of stories and styles!)

@the unconditional love part
Sound like anyone else we know? cough shinji ikari cough

Rosenakahara
Stretch discussion 01 Apr 13:22
Beatorokken
joined Feb 23, 2014

How did so many people fall for this? its april first and there was a NSFW tag in STRETCH that immediately makes it suspect which is why you read comments first

Rosenakahara
Stretch discussion 01 Apr 12:39
Beatorokken
joined Feb 23, 2014

Read the comments first, but dammit i wish this was true

Rosenakahara
Beatorokken
joined Feb 23, 2014

"I want to listen to your piano."

l-lewd..

Lol

Seriously though this was freaking adorable even if it was just subtext

Beatorokken
joined Feb 23, 2014

This manga is becoming seinen xD

How can something BECOME a demographic?

I dont know but this manga has done it.

last edited at Mar 30, 2014 4:03PM

Rosenakahara
Game discussion 30 Mar 05:33
Beatorokken
joined Feb 23, 2014

oh also......i see quickly resolved angst coming from her thinking she is just a stand in!

Rosenakahara
Game discussion 30 Mar 05:29
Beatorokken
joined Feb 23, 2014

Oh god this chapter was so cute, embrace the yuri!

Rosenakahara
Beatorokken
joined Feb 23, 2014

This is adorable

Beatorokken
joined Feb 23, 2014

FueXAsuna

Anyone that gets back with a cheater is a fool. If it's written that way, I'd feel sorry for Fue.

Same

Beatorokken
joined Feb 23, 2014

Wow, it's really odd to see how quickly opinions change here. So far it also seemed Masaa is a good person to me, but considering this manga is all about superstitious appearance and the truth behind it I#d advise to be careful with any judgements. We see a lot of not nice behavior (cheating, gluttony & porn), but Amano uses this to then turn you around by showing you what is behind it. Which makes it a really good work imo.

Btw, calling Asuna a nymphomaniac might be a little drastic (especially if you also want to imply promiscuity, i.e. "maximizing the number of partners"). Perhaps she has a higher sex drive than some (definitely higher than Fue), but whether it's manic or not is hard to tell so far. Take a look at http://dynasty-scans.com/chapters/the_feelings_we_all_must_endure_ch02#16 for example. Asuna tries, very politely, careful to instigate something and Fue immediately brushes her off. Asuna directly retreats. I think she does love Fue, but she's inexperienced with a real relationship (keep in mind all the girls more or less just entered adult life). She tries to do all for her beloved and not to bother her at all to the point of neglecting her own needs. Just like modern romance tales teach you to. Finally she kind of can't take it anymore and cheats. That doesn't make the act of cheating any better and it doesn't mean she "cheats because she loves Fue so much" (which does indeed sound like a bad porn script). No, she ultimately cheats because she strained herself too much. Stupid tactic. She was too afraid of confronting her girlfriend with her own needs. Sure, there might have been no solution at all (if Fue can't compromise, i.e. if they can't find a level of sex they are both comfortable with), but then they could have split up with a less messy cut.

I think this manga is all about that stuff. Things are not as black and white as they seem. People doing ugly things can actually be pitiful and easy to sympathize with, nobody is just an asshole out of pure spite.

Ruki is on the way of doing the same mistake as Asuna, by the way. Regardless of whether Sacchan is even able to fall in love with her or not (if she's just totally straight Ruki is out of luck I guess), in this example Ruki should perhaps have asked Sacchan to put the bigger problem first, i.e. tell her about the whole issue. But no, she didn't want to "bother Sacchan" and tried to only do what she wants (Ruki liosten to her) up until the point she literally zoned out due to the strain on her own mind.

I understand why she did it, does that make me sympathize with her at all? no because the fact is she still did it and i stated before that i hate cheaters.

Beatorokken
joined Feb 23, 2014

Guess I'm the only one who loves Asuna here. and i wish both Asuna and Fue will get back together.

Hey, you're not alone, I wish they could reconcile too. I just can't condemn Asuna for cheating; for me, what is abhorrent about cheating is the idea of betraying your partner or not caring about them enough, but here that's not the case. It's obvious that Asuna cares so much for Fue but receives painfully little in return, and that she would not be cheating on her if only Fue would do it with her. It's because she's realised that Fue doesn't want to do it, but can't just suppress her own needs forever, that she goes to Meru instead. Although it's technically cheating, the intentions are completely different - in fact, it's partly because she loves Fue that she cheats on her, because otherwise she would simply continue to press her with unwanted demands. I just can't for the life of me say that's wrong, though admittedly I am very biased towards Asuna since we don't see much of how Fue thinks.

Cheating on someone because you love them
That's straight out of a crappy porno script. That's disgusting. That's no justification for sleeping around, if you're incompatible or having issues you talk them out or break up, cheating is always unforgivable.

yeah kinda have to agree, i may be biased because i was cheated on before and it really REALLY hurt me and has kinda caused me to shy away from relationships but i don't agree with cheating.....like ever.

Pretty much, sometimes the intention don't justify the acts and "i'll cheat her because i love her" is straight up bullshit
I also got cheated heavily before but i don't think it's biased to look at it that way

yeah if you really love someone you don't cheat, if you need sex that much don't go out with someone and besides it called controlling your urges, look im going to get so much flack for this but people can control their urges as long as they put in the effort, one of my friends used to be sort of a nympho himself he couldn't go more than a couple days without sex, then he got a girlfriend and he put in a ton of effort to control himself, he has to my knowledge, never once cheated on her and is very happy from what he tells me whenever we gets drinks.

Beatorokken
joined Feb 23, 2014

Ugh guro, also it sounds completely nonsensical if there has to be yuri i would rather there be some existing history between the two characters.

last edited at Mar 28, 2014 7:02AM

Beatorokken
joined Feb 23, 2014

Guess I'm the only one who loves Asuna here. and i wish both Asuna and Fue will get back together.

Hey, you're not alone, I wish they could reconcile too. I just can't condemn Asuna for cheating; for me, what is abhorrent about cheating is the idea of betraying your partner or not caring about them enough, but here that's not the case. It's obvious that Asuna cares so much for Fue but receives painfully little in return, and that she would not be cheating on her if only Fue would do it with her. It's because she's realised that Fue doesn't want to do it, but can't just suppress her own needs forever, that she goes to Meru instead. Although it's technically cheating, the intentions are completely different - in fact, it's partly because she loves Fue that she cheats on her, because otherwise she would simply continue to press her with unwanted demands. I just can't for the life of me say that's wrong, though admittedly I am very biased towards Asuna since we don't see much of how Fue thinks.

Cheating on someone because you love them
That's straight out of a crappy porno script. That's disgusting. That's no justification for sleeping around, if you're incompatible or having issues you talk them out or break up, cheating is always unforgivable.

yeah kinda have to agree, i may be biased because i was cheated on before and it really REALLY hurt me and has kinda caused me to shy away from relationships but i don't agree with cheating.....like ever.

Rosenakahara
Beatorokken
joined Feb 23, 2014

still no upload on yuri-ism's new doujin? the hell?

Yuri-ism is on a one-week delay

And, yeah, this is a nice doujin. Kind of downplays how much of a jackass Sakurako is, but they all do

Ah kk, also just finished this, cute as hell also........this is canon in my head.

Rosenakahara
Beatorokken
joined Feb 23, 2014

still no upload on yuri-ism's new doujin? the hell?

Rosenakahara
Stretch discussion 27 Mar 13:30
Beatorokken
joined Feb 23, 2014

oh is yuri-ism's new release going to be uploaded here today?

Rosenakahara
Stretch discussion 27 Mar 12:51
Beatorokken
joined Feb 23, 2014

Me every new chapter: "is it yuri yet?" no "is it yuri yet?" NO "is it yuri yet" NO! "is it yuri-" oh my god just shut up it isnt yuri yet ok, just wait until it is! "..............yet" DAMMIT!!!

Rosenakahara
Beatorokken
joined Feb 23, 2014

Yes! I've been waiting for this for so long! Hopefully we'll actually get some answers about what was up with those penguins and bears from the first series

Er, for the story itself, it's interesting. You can definitely see the influence of both Ikuhara and Morishima in how it's told

The first series? this is a sequel to something!?

It was announced as having some kind of connection to Mawaru Penguindrum

ah kk thanks

Rosenakahara
Beatorokken
joined Feb 23, 2014

Yes! I've been waiting for this for so long! Hopefully we'll actually get some answers about what was up with those penguins and bears from the first series

Er, for the story itself, it's interesting. You can definitely see the influence of both Ikuhara and Morishima in how it's told

The first series? this is a sequel to something!?

Rosenakahara
Beatorokken
joined Feb 23, 2014

While i dont like some (and i say SOME because when she does good she does real good) of Akiko's works i did love 20-Year-Old Girl x 30-Year-Old Maiden and this was so weird i cant NOT be interested so i'll give it a chance

Beatorokken
joined Feb 23, 2014

Dammit i wanted to read but reimu x marisa is my OTP for touhou

Beatorokken
joined Feb 23, 2014

I avoided reading this for......reasons and judging by the comments i made the right decision because i hate depressing stuff already depressed enough

Rosenakahara
Normal Love discussion 22 Mar 10:25
Beatorokken
joined Feb 23, 2014

I don't think it's so weird, people have sex outside of commitment all the time.

Its not that im finding odd, what im finding odd is the leap in logic of:
my best friend likes me, well better have sex with them then later just pretend like everything after the whole finding out your best friend likes you thing never happened, it was....odd

Rosenakahara
Normal Love discussion 22 Mar 08:50
Beatorokken
joined Feb 23, 2014

So Komachi first has sex with Rie and THEN asks to be wooed romantically?

Komachi, I think you got the order all wrong.

yeah i find that a bit odd too

Rosenakahara
Beatorokken
joined Feb 23, 2014

This was my reality. There are people like that. We just never spoke up about it, but we took what we had for each other was something between us only. And reality was that we would eventually have to move on to whats expected from society.

or you could have moved to a country where it was accepted (not back then i mean if you are still in a country that does not accept this)