Forum › Posts by Amanda9708

joined Jun 14, 2013

@People saying remove the guy;

I get your point but I also don't, were like nowhere in the manga yet so there's no reason to call it bad just because your impatient. The guy is actually super important since he's the catalyst for the relationship, he allows the author to develop the characters and he creates a turning point ie the newest chapter and one soon to come 8/9 depending on where you read.

Soo shh

Anyways I think this manga will be super cute I just hope it dosnt run into the same problem of Tamen De Gushi that has 105 chapters before ANYTHING happens.

@Faust I totally agree, it super nice how the author has set up the relationship as its a love triangle of confusion.

I doubt it's going to be that slow with development. And how bout you shush cause that guy sucks and needs to go away forever. ^_^

last edited at Jan 9, 2017 9:41PM by Nezchan

Amanda9708
Image Comments 13 Dec 02:38
joined Jun 14, 2013
11

I hope ssamba gets better :'( fuck cancer

Amanda9708
Lily Love discussion 13 Dec 02:31
joined Jun 14, 2013

Me, this entire chapter: "Tell her you cheated. Tell her you cheated. Tell her you cheated. Please for the love of God, tell her you cheated. Just tell her you cheated, don't drag this shit out for no fucking reason. Tell her you cheated. DAMMIT ALL!"

Is that honestly not gonna become a plot point later on? I find that fucking ridiculous. Just get it fucking over with. Like are they honestly trying to imply that WASN'T a big issue? Please, just...*sigh* I'm just so tired of bullshit drama...I don't want this to come back later and become a whole big thing cuz nobody said anything and then, even if it doesn't come back later, it just feels dishonest.

I know!! Ughh!!

Amanda9708
Lily Love discussion 13 Dec 02:30
joined Jun 14, 2013

Super pro-supporting-Ratana-by-all-means (buying all the stuff on Lezhin, etc), but chp 29 lays on thick her tendency to write too much :| I could have done without pretty much all of the text from page 5 and on... some times less really is more, and her art's enough to know what the characters are feeling most of the time. Gets particularly cringy at "You're mine now", yikes, run awayyy.

Agreed. Exactly how I feel.

Amanda9708
joined Jun 14, 2013

More please I don't want to wait arghh >_<

Amanda9708
Opapagoto discussion 08 Dec 04:15
joined Jun 14, 2013

Meh I don't expect much from this manga. Just can't get into it. Its like too cliche or something.

Amanda9708
joined Jun 14, 2013

I swear this manga has been out since the dynasty site's format was before how it is currently. I was like likely 13 now 18. Man mangas can really drag. I remember when the format was just a bunch of mangas with their chapters and a bunch of scrambled one shots at the bottom. I probably read 98% of it all too. Like the whole time I was 13/14 I was just reading on my side on my couch or bed. Never looked back after that. (Meaning never fell in love with any other genre other than yuri) Nothing can beat yuri for me. It's a need for me.

Amanda9708
joined Jun 14, 2013

This deserves a long Boooooooo. Tried too hard and it turned out to be really lame. From beginning to end this did nothing for my interest or emotions, just felt really indifferent the whole way through. I'm glad I won't be seeing more of this.

Amanda9708
joined Jun 14, 2013

I don't like this. I hope it doesn't have many chapters and ends soon. Read this kind too many times, always end up feeling disappointed.

Amanda9708
joined Jun 14, 2013

Perfect example of a shitty work. By how the plot was. A decade of waiting. Jesus.

Amanda9708
Yuru Yuri discussion 09 Nov 14:59
joined Jun 14, 2013

Kyouko and Yui are my OTP. They were first. I'm sure yuru yuri will always be light shoujo ai tho.

Amanda9708
joined Jun 14, 2013

Probably just me. Its just really annoying already knowing I'm likely not gonna like this or how it'll end. After reading all chapters, so far it's pretty predictable. I'm finding it hard to like any of the characters besides MC and who she likes (not even much tho). Guess that love triangle tag really isn't for me. So tedious. Makes me wanna groan ughhh out loud.

joined Jun 14, 2013

This is really garbage. I wasn't even surprised and kinda rushed through this cause bisexual tag but seriously why the obvious troll slap in the face? Y'all like to torture us or something? BOO this shit.

joined Jun 14, 2013

haha fuck you

Amanda9708
Lily Love discussion 04 Nov 06:36
joined Jun 14, 2013

Spoilers
What a disappointment this manga turned out to be. Of course I'll always appreciate well done art but come on, this was written pretty generically. Like using the same old tropes we've all seen before, fucking cheating, dumbass misunderstandings, but I guess that's melo drama for you. It's a boring genre especially if the writers don't get creative with their writing plots, or at least try to make it different from the usual. It's really a shame how it turned out to be, in my opinion of course.

Amanda9708
joined Jun 14, 2013

BOO love triangle tag. Thanks for the heads up even though I'll probably end up reading it anyway.

joined Jun 14, 2013

This kinda yuri is pretty annoying. I'd considered it more subtext since there won't be much (if any) yuri progression.

joined Jun 14, 2013

:'(

Amanda9708
joined Jun 14, 2013

After reading the comments, I just wanna say it's really nice to see other people feel the same about this manga and how it ended. I kept going past this in lezhin and decided what the hell. By now, as a yuri fan I know to be cautious with new material, so I read a few of the free latest ones SPOILER .....where Joy and Namsu? (Black long haired girl) began dating in the end. After reading reading them, I just said fuck it and went bought the ending chapter and a couple before the last one. And what a fucking waste. I can't stop thinking how depressing it was. Just sucks. I feel so much for Namsu. Just maybe this manga Can redeem itself if it got a part 2 with only Namsu with a good ending (call it unrealistic all you want, I like that shit).

Amanda9708
Cocytus discussion 19 Aug 14:06
joined Jun 14, 2013

BOOOOOOOOOOOOO ch.3 pls end as one shot.

Amanda9708
joined Jun 14, 2013

SPOILERS (Maybe)

  From the get go this manga has been pretty bullshit. Making me pay and shit. like god damn, $40 is  probably what I spent to read this shit. Fuck, I don't mind spending that much if it was actually worth it, but after reading all the latest chaps, to me it's clearly not. I may and likely will continue paying to read the rest anyway cause now i'm invested, I can't go back now, those motherfuckers.
 So now here goes me me hoping and wishing for better writing in yuri, once again. The only 10/10 that can be given to this manga is the art. Like holy shit, yuri needs more of that style, hell yeah. The writing lately, though, like what the hell? Like shit, I'm not a writer but god damn they fucked up. I really wish I could change it and now i'm grieving here cause I can't and they neither can they. Even if the author tries to fix what happened in the latest chaps, the manga, in my opinion will no longer be realistic (was it ever really?) it's now become like the citrus manga (which started strong?  nah mei's kiss with male teacher was enough to tell me how that manga gonna turn out) a manga where it's really got one or two really good elements (the art) about it but other than that, that's it. Cliche, cliche, cliche. May as well be reading a lame het manga.
 So, the art for both mangas are soo  amazing but art only goes so far to truly make a manga a good worth read, shit I've read yuri manga where I can see the art doesn't compare like these but the story, yessss, the writing, ahhh, just makes it all close to perfect honestly and really hits the spot. Now it's just like oh well I guess this is better than nothing huh, at least the arts beautiful. It's bullshit cause I really liked this manga for awhile (I think?) but now how can I when I don't like how the author developed it? I read the aftermath of the author too, he/she knew they fucked up. Like fuck dude you had one amazing job that you truly fucked up imo. Just sucks. This manga had potential. Now it may as well be soft core porn, only good for looks but not if you want plot. 

Here's some examples of the best completed yuri manga: Girl Friends (my first), Cirque Arachne, Comprehensive Tovarisch (not all out but hell yeah so far), Hoshikawa Ginza District 4, Husky and Medley, Kimi Koi Limit (warning love triangle, I'm not a fan of the tag but the manga, yasss), Kimochi no Katachi, Majyo to Houki to Kurobuchi Megane, Notes From The Garden Of Lilies, Poor Poor Lips, Prism (cancelled but shit was so good, it's a shame the author turned out to be a yuri hating sadist, cough Stretch cough), Roommates, Shinigami Alice, The Flower And The Star, Unchanging Days, Yuri Yuri (ELEGY SYNDROME), and Yuri Yuri are all the my favorite completed yuri mangas on dynasty. I can probably add a whole bunch of ongoing ones that I'm really loving at the moment (if they don't fuck it up in a chap or in the end, they're always a risk) and oneshots (got so many that I love).

Amanda9708
Lemonade discussion 17 Jul 23:42
joined Jun 14, 2013

The author should be ashamed of this manga. It doesn't deserve being called a yuri manga. What garbage, seriously. It makes me think the author just added the yuri just for its tag, likely hey I guess this is what's kinda popular nowadays, so why not? If this manga will or has come out will in a physical book, it's only good use would be being completely burned to ashes. Like was this manga purposely meant to piss off yuri fans or what? Fuck you author.

Amanda9708
Toki discussion 10 Jul 20:07
joined Jun 14, 2013

This should be yuri.

joined Jun 14, 2013

I understand stories won't all have happy endings or have happy vibes throughout the whole story but the writing for those first two that came out with the sadist and machsochist just made me think wow this is stupid throughout the whole thing. Like what a waste. I guess maybe it's my fault since I'm not into the Whole BDSM(?) genre. Oh well, maybe next time.

joined Jun 14, 2013

I see that a lot of you agree with how the art is really good and the writing not so much. This is fact. This one shot and the past two chapters recently released, scare me. This author really needs to step it up with the writing cause it'd really suck if they made their other work start being shitty. I hope for better writing.